Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Your company’s honest AI signal isn’t on your website

The story is inside the smaller moments.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Kathleen Lucente

Founder and CEO · Red Fan Communications

The most honest signal your company sends about its AI strategy isn’t on your website, your press release, or your CEO’s latest podcast appearance. It’s in the conversation your product manager had last week at a conference. A friend asked her what the AI initiative was really about, and she hesitated before answering.

The honest signal is the sales rep who froze for a half-second when the potential customer asked how the product uses AI. The engineer who didn’t include AI in the LinkedIn post about work she’s proud of. The departing employee’s Glassdoor review highlighting what leadership says about AI versus what the roadmap actually funds. 

Each moment is a data point when a prospect hears it, a journalist notices it, or an analyst picks it up. And the market begins to assemble a picture of your company that is different from, and more accurate than, the one your communications team is trying to convey.

Humans have always read companies this way

The practice of reading a company through its people is older than the marketing function itself.

Buyers, acquirers, journalists, and analysts have always formed their most reliable impressions of a company by talking to the people in it. Long before LinkedIn or Glassdoor, a single customer reference call could end a deal, and a quiet word from a former employee could sink a quarter.

While the underlying mechanism is the same, the speed has changed. People pick up on the gap between what a company says and what the people inside it actually believe, but faster than any communications plan can catch up.

A buyer evaluating three vendors used to spend weeks triangulating between the sales deck, a reference call, a conversation with an analyst, and whatever they could pick up at a conference.

Now the same buyer forms an impression in an hour because conference conversations have moved to LinkedIn posts, Glassdoor reviews are indexed, and the trade press that quotes employees is a search query away. The timeline has compressed from months to hours.

AI accelerated this dynamic. And the companies most at risk right now are the ones treating AI narrative as a communications exercise when it’s actually a belief problem.

Why AI makes this especially dangerous

The companies under pressure to claim AI leadership are those whose employees are skeptical. Investors want a faster AI story. Boards want a sharper AI story. CEOs are being asked to show AI momentum in quarterly reviews.

The language layer moves fast because language is cheap. The belief layer moves slowly because belief is earned, and earning it requires the product, the roadmap, and the customer outcomes to have caught up with the claim.

When those things have not caught up, the external claim goes out anyway via website updates, published bylines, and press releases.

And inside the company, the employees who build the product, talk to customers, and know what the roadmap actually contains, read the external story and feel the gap. That feeling travels to their networks, to reporters, to analysts, to prospects they meet at industry events.

By the time leadership realizes the external narrative is not landing, the market has already priced in the skepticism. And the skepticism did not come from the market. It came from inside the company.

What leadership can do

The ones scrambling to align external language with an unrealized internal reality are already being read, and the reading is not in their favor. Once the external claim and the internal belief are out of sync, there is no communications fix.

The only real intervention is to stop making the gap worse. What leadership actually needs in this moment is a partner willing to sit with management, feel the pressure they are under, and help shape a realistic plan employees can feel good about.

That version may be more conservative than the investor deck wants. It is also the version that will hold under the scrutiny of any buyer, acquirer, analyst, or large language model assembling a picture of the company.

Hold the external claim at whatever version your employees can defend in their own words, to their own networks, without wincing. When employees feel good about the plan, the plan radiates outward. That is the only AI communications version that holds up under scrutiny because it is built on a solid foundation.

The companies emerging with their reputations intact will be those employees who were already telling the right story before leadership asked them to.

Kathleen Lucente is the CEO and founder of Red Fan Communications.