One of the most common misconceptions for Americans living abroad is that the IRS can’t see their foreign assets. However, just because assets are “foreign” doesn’t mean they’re hidden from the IRS.
Under the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA), foreign financial institutions must report U.S. account holders to the IRS, so offshore assets are already visible to the IRS. Even if you don’t owe tax on a foreign asset, you may still be required to report it, and failure to disclose can result in penalties that exceed the asset’s value.
For Americans living abroad, understanding what’s taxable versus what’s reportable helps you stay compliant and avoid surprises.
TAXABLE VS. REPORTABLE: WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE?
U.S. citizens and Green Card holders must report and pay tax on their worldwide income. Additionally, filing requirements such as the Foreign Bank Account Report and Financial Accounts (FBAR) and FATCA require reporting of certain foreign accounts and assets, whether or not they generate income.
Not all foreign assets are treated the same. Some are taxable, some are reportable, some are both, while others are neither.
In simple terms, taxable assets generate income such as interest, dividends, or rental income, or create a gain when sold, while reportable assets must be disclosed even if they don’t produce income.
The easiest way to understand the difference is by considering different asset types.
FOREIGN BANK ACCOUNTS
Foreign bank accounts can be reportable. If the combined balance of all your foreign financial accounts exceeds $10,000 at any point during the year, you must file an FBAR. You may also need to report these accounts on Form 8938 (Statement of Specified Foreign Financial Assets), at higher thresholds.
Filing an FBAR does not create any tax liability. However, any income the account generates, such as interest, is taxable.
Accounts can include checking, savings, and digital accounts, including those where you have signatory authority, which count toward the threshold.
FOREIGN INVESTMENT ACCOUNTS
Foreign investment accounts can be both reportable and taxable. You may need to report the account on an FBAR and on Form 8938, depending on your total assets. While reporting applies to the account itself and doesn’t trigger tax, any income it generates, such as dividends, interest, or capital gains, is considered taxable.
Currency fluctuations can also affect your gains. For example, if you sell an investment for the same price in your local currency, you could have a taxable gain (or a nominal loss) in USD if the exchange rate has changed since you bought it.
Additionally, the tax treatment often depends on what’s held inside the account. If the account contains foreign mutual funds or ETFs, they may be classified as Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs), which come with their own tax and reporting rules.
FOREIGN MUTUAL FUNDS AND ETFS
Foreign mutual funds and ETFs are typically classified as PFICs, which means they are both reportable and taxable.
PFICs are subject to harsh tax treatment, strict reporting requirements, and steep penalties for missed or late filings. In some cases, you may owe tax even without any distributions.
Many expats avoid foreign mutual funds and ETFs altogether and instead invest in U.S.-based ETFs, since the reporting burden and tax treatment can often outweigh the benefits.
FOREIGN REAL ESTATE
When it comes to foreign real estate ownership, structure matters. If you hold the asset directly, it is generally not reportable, but it may still be taxable.
For example, if the property produces rental income, you will need to report it and pay tax on that income. If you sell the property, any gains must also be reported and may trigger capital gains tax, including gains caused by currency fluctuations, and are taxable income.
Things get more complex if you hold the property through a foreign company, trust, or other entity, which can create additional reporting requirements and make a big difference when it comes to how the income and gains are taxed.
A common misconception is that “not reportable” means “not relevant,” but foreign real estate can still have significant tax implications depending on how it is used and structured.
FOREIGN RETIREMENT AND PENSION ACCOUNTS
Foreign retirement and pension accounts may not have the same tax advantages under the U.S. tax system as they do locally. These types of accounts are often reportable and taxable, but the rules vary by account type and country.
If a tax treaty exists between the U.S. and your country of residence, employment-related pension accounts may benefit from a treaty-based tax deferral. This means contributions and growth are not taxed each year but deferred until distributions. However, this is very limited, so non-exempt pensions may be subject to U.S. taxation on employer contributions made and growth earned in the tax year.
In some cases, investments held in the account, such as pooled funds, may be treated as PFICs, resulting in punitive tax treatment and complex reporting requirements.
FOREIGN BUSINESS INTERESTS (COMPANIES, PARTNERSHIPS, TRUSTS)
If you hold interests in foreign businesses, even a minority ownership can trigger reporting obligations, and the filings, such as Form 5471, Form 8865, or Form 8858, are often complex and time-consuming.
This is because tax treatment depends heavily on the business’s structure. Corporations, partnerships, and trusts are treated differently for U.S. tax purposes, which can affect how income is taxed and what needs to be reported.
OTHER TYPES OF ASSETS
Some assets depend on how you use them to determine whether they create any reporting or tax obligations. Personal-use assets like cars, jewelry, and art are generally not reportable or taxable. However, if sold for a gain or used for business, any income must be reported and is taxed.
In summary, not all foreign assets are treated the same, which is where much of the confusion comes from.
Once you understand how each asset type is treated, it’s much easier to structure things properly, stay compliant, and avoid unnecessary taxes or penalties. If you’re not sure, seek assistance from an expat tax specialist.
Nathalie Goldstein is the founder and CEO of My Expat Taxes.