Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

5 signs your “agile” organization is chaotic

Leaders have confused adaptability with a lack of structure, creating organizations that pivot constantly but never actually execute anything.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Dustin Lemick

CEO/Founder · BriteCo

Agile has become the corporate equivalent of “clean eating.” Everyone claims to do it. Few can explain what it actually means. And most are doing it wrong.

I’ve spent years building what I believe is a genuinely agile organization at BriteCo. But I’ve also watched plenty of companies slap the agile label on what is, frankly, just chaos. Leaders have confused adaptability with a lack of structure, creating organizations that pivot constantly but never actually execute anything.

You can’t just announce that your company is agile and expect magic to happen. Telling your team, “We’re agile now, make your own decisions,” without guardrails is like handing someone a race car with no steering wheel. You’ll move fast, but you’ll also crash.

Here are five signs your company is more chaotic than agile.

1. Decisions feel like a coin flip

      The first sign your agile organization is actually just chaotic? Decision-making feels random.

      In a truly agile environment, decisions happen quickly because there’s clarity about who makes them and how. In a chaotic one, decisions get made in vacuums. There’s no consensus or a clear structure. People are empowered to decide but have no framework for doing so.

      I constantly see a leader declare their organization agile, then wonder why three different teams made contradictory choices this past week. The problem is there’s no decision tree and no criteria for how those decisions should happen.

      At BriteCo, we’ve learned that agility requires constraints. You need guidelines and boundaries to make fast decisions. Without them, you have anarchy with better branding.

      2. You can’t finish what you start

      Here’s a test: Can your teams complete a full initiative cycle? I mean truly complete it, from kickoff to measurable outcome. If you’re constantly shifting gears or abandoning initiative cycles midstream, especially urgent ones, that’s a clear sign you need more discipline around your workflows. Your team must avoid dropping everything the moment something shinier appears.

      There’s a difference between responsiveness and restlessness. Responsive teams adjust based on real information, while restless teams just bounce from task to task mistaking motion for progress.

      The ability to complete work is a core agile principle. Sprints exist for a reason. They create containers of focused execution. Not finishing anything means you’re being scattered instead of being agile.

      3. Too many pivots, not enough persistence

      Pivoting in business is important when something isn’t working. But timing is everything, and leaders need to be clear about when to stay the course versus when to strategically change direction. Yes, being agile should theoretically allow you to pivot easier and more often. But that doesn’t mean you always should.

      When we develop new products at BriteCo, they don’t always come firing off the start line at full sprint. New insurance products in niche markets like jewelry and watches require love and care, consideration, persistence, and effort to get off the ground. There are plenty of times where you could look at early market signals and say, “This isn’t working, time to pivot.” But there are also critical moments when you need to stay the course.

      The key is learning to interpret market signals. Is this genuine feedback indicating a fundamental problem? Or is this just the natural friction of building something new? Stakeholders need to understand when pivots are truly critical and when it’s too soon to pivot. Sometimes you just need to keep grinding.

      4. Planning is a dirty word

      Somewhere along the way, agile got twisted into an excuse for poor planning. Leaders started treating structure as the enemy of flexibility, but agility isn’t the absence of planning. It’s a different approach to planning, one that accounts for uncertainty and builds in regular checkpoints. Agile companies still need non-negotiable planning structures.

      Think of it like guardrails on a mountain road. They keep the car on track so you can drive fast without flying off a cliff. An organization without guardrails that claims to be agile is just an organization that hasn’t crashed yet.

      5. Culture doesn’t match the claims

      The final sign is the most fundamental: Your culture doesn’t support agility.

      You can’t just say “We’re agile,” and expect behavior to change. You have to walk the walk while talking the talk. That means leaders model adaptability. It means psychological safety exists for people to raise concerns. It means failure in pursuit of learning is treated differently than failure from negligence.

      If your leadership team preaches agility but punishes anyone who makes an autonomous decision that doesn’t work out, you don’t have an agile culture. You have a traditional hierarchy posing as agile.

      Final thoughts

      True agility requires boundaries. It requires discipline. It requires finishing what you start and knowing when persistence matters more than pivoting.

      Get those pieces right, and you’ll have an organization that can genuinely adapt.

      Skip them, and you’ll have chaos cloaked in a buzzword.

      Dustin Lemick is CEO and founder of BriteCo.