The pitch made sense. Stop showing people things they don’t care about, and they’ll pay attention to what you do show them. Brands listened, engagement went up, click-through rates improved, and brands got smarter about timing and targeting. For a moment, personalization felt like real progress in reducing the noise we’ve become accustomed to online. So why does so much of it feel off now?
Netflix runs one of the most sophisticated recommendation engines in existence, and yet a familiar pattern keeps showing up across streaming services. People open the app, scroll through rows of content built specifically for them, and sometimes take longer to decide than they do to watch, or abandon the whole thing and rewatch something.
The algorithm did its job by curating recommendations for users at a cost. Better targeting to cut through the noise has come at the expense of personal discovery.
YOUR CONTENT IS NOT YOURS
Spend time on any major streaming platform, and you’ll start noticing that while the content options are technically shaped by your behavior, they could easily belong to someone else. For example, one week of tuning in to jazz, and suddenly the algorithm has decided that’s your whole identity.
E-commerce does this too, just without the pretense of curation. Add a pair of socks to your shopping cart online, and you’ll find versions of them trailing you across the internet for weeks. It is precise and relentless, and not always useful.
When every interaction gets filtered down to behavioral data, what often disappears first is what made the relationship matter: the unexpected moment, the discovery that didn’t come from an algorithm.
THE UNIVERSAL FAN EXPERIENCE
Sports fans do not have a transactional relationship with the teams or athletes they follow. Their connection runs deep, rooted in rituals and shared history, the kind of relationship behavioral data can observe but not fully capture.
A West Coast baseball fan and a Southern football fan in the United States can end up with a personalized experience that feels structurally identical. While each fan sees different content across streaming platforms, social media, and even at live games, the feeling is the same.
Teams that use behavioral data will know where to apply it: smarter ticket pricing, cooler merch, and better fan experiences. They also understand when to get out of the way and let fan discovery lead the moment. Because the best moments of fandom are not usually optimized for.
DOES THIS SERVE WHO YOU ARE OR WHAT YOU’VE DONE?
None of this means personalization has run its course, but the question driving it has to change.
For a long time, we asked how to make any brand or product more relevant to a specific person. That is still worth asking. But I’ve started pushing harder in our work to ask instead, does this personalization serve who someone is, or just what they’ve recently done?
Spotify’s Blend feature gets at this. Rather than optimizing for a single listener’s taste, Blend merges two people’s histories into a shared playlist. The personalization is aimed at connection rather than confirmation. The data is doing exactly what it usually does, but the goal shifted from “what does this person want?” to “what brings these two people closer together?” Small design decision, genuinely different outcome.
Personalization in the service of a real experience is additive. Personalization that substitutes for one is where things start to fall apart.
WHAT HAS TO CHANGE
The answer is using data toward a wider set of outcomes.
Behavioral data tells you what someone clicked, not who they are. The richer signal is what they care about, who they’re trying to be, and what they want to belong to. The brands building real staying power are working toward identity, building belonging, creating fandom, and not just cataloging behavior.
Personalization moved the industry away from talking to everyone in exactly the same way. That’s worth doing. But the next step isn’t a sharper version of the same thing. People aren’t the sum of what they’ve clicked, and those who feel genuinely seen aren’t always the most precisely targeted. More often, they’re the ones whose experience felt like someone understood something real about them.
The brands that get there won’t have the most advanced targeting. They’ll know when targeting is the wrong tool for what they’re trying to build.
Jim Caruso is Chief Innovation Officer of Elevate.