CEOs trust the clean numbers from the performance marketing team. Performance marketing is advertising based on metrics such as return on ad spend or pay-per-click.
Measuring systems with known metrics seems logical, but it’s a flawed approach.
In contrast, the brand marketing team creates the conditions for any campaign’s success. Branding is advertising that relies on emotional ties to the company and builds a presence that doesn’t necessarily equate with performance.
Branding doesn’t have the clear indicators that performance marketing does, and that’s where misunderstandings start. Significant portions of marketing budgets are spent on branding and upper-funnel channels, but no one measures them well, so their contribution to performance metrics remains largely unknown.
Brand drives what performance captures
Customers typically purchase from companies they recognize and trust, making branding essential to achieving sustainable sales performance.
Brand recognition increases the value of every performance dollar by building an emotional connection with customers through the logo, brand image, and advertising. People buy because of the brand.
Companies like Walmart, Apple, Nike, Coca-Cola, and Tesla don’t rely on outspending competitors through pay-per-click advertising, social media marketing, and sales campaigns. Legacy brands often spend less on paid channels because strong branding brings steady, cost-effective client acquisition.
Coca-Cola is one of the best examples of branding affecting performance metrics. Its “Share a Coke” campaign launched after years of declining sales. The strategy was simple: put people’s names on Coke bottles and cans. It boosted global sales and reversed a decade-long downward trend.
The measurement problem no one wants to admit
A structural problem is built into performance metrics. When every dollar spent must be justified to the board, performance metrics provide clean answers. Dashboards show conversions, cost per acquisition, and return on ad spend in real time.
Measurement models are designed to consider the last interaction, but fail to account for the most influential one. Numbers are skewed to favor channels that record demand rather than those that create it. Brand does the heavy lifting but remains invisible in reporting metrics.
Most CEOs choose visibility over accuracy—not entirely their fault, as they are taught to measure metrics. Investing in proven performance channels like pay-per-click or social media ads seems logical, but that flawed measurement fails to capture brand.
Overinvesting in these channels while cutting back on branding leads to diminished long-term revenue by prioritizing short-term wins over the sustained success of legacy companies that plan for the future, such as Nike, Walmart, and Coca-Cola.
Imbalance compounds over time. Performance marketing becomes less efficient as brand investment declines. Customer acquisition costs rise, and conversion rates fall. The typical response is to spend more on performance, sending the company into a spiral that’s hard to escape. Numbers aren’t growing, but additional spending masks dropping efficiency.
Many CEOs and marketers don’t realize what the true picture of return on investment ROI could do for their companies. They are doubling down on the huge mistake of over-investing in performance channels, with 70% of marketers increasing spending, according to Nielsen.
Weak branding relies on discounts and promotions for higher conversion rates. Customers start waiting for lower prices to buy.
And yet, CEOs still don’t trust branding because results are hard to measure, including the impact of awareness on conversions. Among CFOs, 45% turn down marketing plans because they don’t see a defined return on investment, according to McKinsey & Company.
A better approach
The solution is integration. Including branding as part of performance metrics multiplies the effect, yielding up to 30% efficiency gains and 10% revenue growth, according to McKinsey & Company.
Strong branding enhances your pricing power and marketing efficiency. Strong brands attract customers willing to pay more to ensure they get quality products or services. The results are higher-value customers and sustainable revenue.
Companies should stop viewing performance and brand as separate investments and treat them as a single system, and ask how each investment improves efficiency over time rather than which channel drives the fastest return.
This shift in thought changes the evaluation of success. Companies look at longer acquisition cost trends rather than immediate, momentary costs. An improvement in conversion rates and a decrease in reliance on paid channels create a more efficient system, making growth more predictable.
Baruch Labunski is the founder and CEO of Rank Secure.