Higher education is clearly at a turning point. Institutions must reconsider generic enrollment strategies in the face of rising student expectations and unique challenges.
As one example, many colleges are witnessing the ramifications of what is commonly known as the “enrollment cliff,” a long-anticipated drop in the number of traditional college-age students, due to fewer births.
According to projections from the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education (WICHE), the number of U.S. high school graduates was expected to peak around 2025, then decline through 2041.
Institutions historically reliant on a steady flow of prospective students must compete for every enrollment. As a result, many administrators are turning to technology to streamline recruitment efforts and improve enrollment outcomes—even as they grapple with disappointing marketing and student engagement.
Universities and colleges are overhauling their strategy. Personalization is now a baseline expectation that must be evident across enrollment operations, student engagement, onboarding, and every aspect shaping a student’s experience at an institution.
Data and personalization in higher ed
There’s significant potential to change enrollment marketing in the next two years, according to the Marketing and Enrollment Management AI Readiness Report 2025. For example, 79% of survey respondents said that chatbots and personalized virtual assistants have the potential to transform enrollment marketing.
Much of this is due to the opportunity for personalization, which allows identifying which students are likely to enroll now and which may need additional encouragement or support in the future, particularly if a current student is struggling or considering leaving.
In practical terms, data is used for informed decisions about where to focus time and resources, improving both enrollment and retention outcomes. Not only do more students enroll in the institution, but the students stay enrolled and graduate.
Before the AI era, personalization included handwritten notes, campus visits, segmented email lists, and one-on-one phone calls. With 19.4 million postsecondary enrollments in Fall 2025, college enrollment teams can’t personalize every student touchpoint without AI infrastructure.
AI offers new options
Prospective students’ expectations have risen for real-time assistance with college applications, document submissions, and inquiry resolution. If students don’t get an adequate, swift response, they may disengage right then. Institutions can use modern databases, AI chatbots, automated student engagement tools, and predictive analytics to respond to students more quickly and efficiently.
Instead of sending generic emails to applicants, schools can tailor their communication based on real behavioral insights.
For example, AI can help universities understand where students struggle in the enrollment process, whether by disengaging after seeing tuition costs, having questions about credit transfer, or failing to submit required financial aid documents.
These patterns can reveal concerns or obstacles that application records or email exchanges may not illuminate. Admissions teams can provide timely support and help students move more confidently through the enrollment journey.
3 ways to deal with enrollment challenges
Enrollment teams are grappling with sustained enrollment pressure in recent memory. As traditional pipelines thin due to demographics, enrollment teams adopt technology in new ways, closing the widening gap between historical performance and current enrollment realities.
Personalization solves enrollment challenges by making communication matter. Here’s how it directly addresses the pressure points administrators are facing:
1. Offer students relevant messages
Students want institutions to be sensitive to their specific questions, goals, and concerns. When they receive emails that feel generic or disconnected from their current enrollment stage, they simply tune out.
To address this, enrollment teams are now moving to messages based on program interest, application progress, financial aid activity, or engagement history. Even small adjustments, such as referencing a student’s intended major or a recent campus visit, can demonstrate that the institution understands a student’s interests and goals.
2. Improve application rates
AI-powered chatbots and automated messaging tools can help answer student questions right away. Students can get quick, consistent responses when needed, keeping communication moving and making it easier for them to complete an application.
Enrollment teams are also sending timely nudges based on student behavior. For example, a student who logs in multiple times but never submits required documents might receive a reminder with a checklist of what’s still missing.
If an admitted student opens orientation emails but doesn’t complete registration steps, they may get a simple prompt guiding them to the next action. The idea is to respond to what students are doing in the moment so they don’t lose momentum.
3. Improve value-based communication
When students receive surface-level messaging about rankings, campus size, or generic outcomes, it rarely answers the question they are actually asking: “What does this mean for me?” Institutions are aligning messaging more closely with student intent and interests.
Instead of broad institutional narratives, they highlight program-specific outcomes, career pathways, alumni stories relevant to a student’s field, and scholarship options tailored to individual circumstances.
Behavioral insights help teams understand what a student is exploring and adjust communication accordingly.
If a student attends multiple virtual campus tours but spends little time on program pages, they may receive content focused on student life, campus experience, and housing options. If a student engages heavily with the application requirements pages but doesn’t complete the application, a simple checklist or step-by-step guidance can help them finish the process.
In each case, the outreach is shaped by what the student is already paying attention to.
Smarter prioritization always helps
Enrollment teams often notice drop-offs in the enrollment process. Students may inquire, browse programs, or even begin an application, but then stop midway without completing the next steps.
Without clear visibility into where or why this disengagement happens, teams are often left unsure which students need follow-up and which have already moved out of the process.
Institutions are shifting to insight-driven action. Analysis of engagement patterns, application milestones, and response behavior can identify where students stall and why. This allows teams to step in with targeted support, clarify next steps, or remove friction before momentum is lost. Smarter prioritization is less about doing more outreach and more about focusing on the right students at the right time.
Ashish Fernando is the founder and CEO of EDMO.