Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Your brand is a character, not a logo

What novelists know about building unforgettable characters—and how it translates to brand identity.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of JD Barker

AuthorPublisher · Hampton Creek Press

Before I became a business owner, I spent years doing what novelists do: building people from scratch. Not real people—fictional ones. People who had never existed, whom I had to make feel so vivid, so particular, so unmistakably themselves that readers would grieve when they turned the last page. What I didn’t realize, until I was deep in the work of building my company, was that I had been practicing brand strategy the entire time.

The best brands in the world aren’t logos. They aren’t color palettes or taglines or mission statements, though those things can be useful tools. The best brands are characters—fully realized, internally consistent, and recognizable the moment they walk into the room. Most companies, even brilliant ones, are getting this wrong.

Here is what fiction writers understand that brand consultants often don’t: A character is not defined by how they look. They are defined by what they want, what they fear, how they speak, what they refuse to do, and what they would sacrifice everything for. Strip away the physical description of any great literary character, say Atticus Finch, Holden Caulfield, or Elizabeth Bennet, and you still know exactly who they are. That’s the test. Can your brand pass it?

WHAT DRIVES BRAND CHARACTER

When I teach character development, I always start with desire and wound. Every compelling character has something they want, urgently and specifically. They also have something that happened to them that shaped why they want it. The desire creates forward momentum. The wound creates depth. Together, they create someone you believe in.

Your brand should have both. The desire is your mission—not the sanitized, committee-approved version, but the raw version, the one your founders argued about at midnight. The wound is your origin story, the problem in the world that made you furious enough to build something.

Patagonia’s wound is environmental destruction. Apple’s wound, in its Jobs-era incarnation, was the ugliness and arrogance of corporate technology. Glossier’s wound was the alienation of traditional beauty marketing. These weren’t talking points. They were injuries. Brands built on genuine wounds have a specificity that no focus group can manufacture.

The second thing novelists know is that character is revealed under pressure. You don’t learn who someone is when things are easy. You learn it in crisis. The brands that have endured—and the ones that haven’t—are largely defined by how they behaved when the stakes were real. Did they hold the line or fold? Did they speak first or wait to see which way the wind blew?

Johnson & Johnson’s handling of the 1982 Tylenol poisoning crisis didn’t just protect the brand. It wrote a chapter in the character’s history that still resonates four decades later. Conversely, brands that abandon their stated values the moment it becomes costly reveal that those values were costume, not character.

The third lesson from fiction is the one most executives resist: Your character needs flaws. Not performed flaws or the carefully curated “we’re not perfect, but we try” language that has become its own form of corporate polish. Actual flaws. Tension. Contradiction. The thing your brand is genuinely bad at, or the value you hold that puts you in direct conflict with what the market sometimes wants from you.

Flaws are what make characters feel real. They are also what create loyalty, because loyalty is not the result of admiration alone. It is the result of recognition. Customers stay with brands they feel they truly know and you cannot truly know someone who has no edges.

HOW TO BUILD BRAND CHARACTER

So, how do you build a brand character rather than a brand identity? Start with the novelist’s questions, not the marketer’s. Don’t ask: What do we want customers to feel? Ask: What does this brand want? What keeps it up at night? What would it never do, even if doing it would be profitable? What does it sound like at 2 a.m. when no one is watching? What does it find funny? What makes it angry?

Then—and this is the part most brand exercises skip entirely—stress test for consistency. Would this character post that tweet? Would this character apologize in that way? Would this character launch that product?

Inconsistency is the death of fictional characters, and it is the death of brand characters, too. When a brand that has built its identity around quiet, artisanal values starts running Super Bowl ads, audiences don’t just notice. They feel betrayed. Because they thought they knew this character. It turns out they didn’t.

Brands that have mattered most to me as both a consumer and a business owner are the ones I can describe the way I describe a character I love: Here is who they are, here is what they stand for, and here is what they would never do. That kind of clarity doesn’t come from a logo refresh or a brand sprint. It comes from the same difficult, exhilarating, deeply human work that novelists have been doing for centuries—the work of figuring out, in precise and unsparing detail, exactly who someone is.

Your brand is a character. The only question is whether you know them well enough to write them honestly.

J.D. Barker is president of Hampton Creek Press.