What’s the latest threat that will undo marketing and kill it forever? No, it isn’t artificial intelligence, though the headlines and your LinkedIn feed would tell you differently. The newest threat to marketing is its oldest threat: Bad marketers.
The latest polls show that 94% of marketers already use AI, driving the AI marketing industry to grow to over $84 billion by 2030. Not every marketer that uses AI is a bad marketer. But every bad marketer uses AI.
Marketers need to ask questions about how the least talented of us will use AI to ruin the industry’s reputation, and how we can counteract this, and win.
EDGERANK AND BEYOND
When Facebook first started, if you had a business page and you made a post, nearly every single person who liked or followed your page would see that post. Then Facebook launched its EdgeRank algorithm and the birth of modern social media marketing. A few years later, Facebook switched to an advanced machine-learning algorithm and over 100,000 weight factors to determine what people see in their news feeds.
Since 2014, organic reach has suffered a slow and steady decline. Bad marketers are directly responsible for creating not only pay to play, but also the pay-to-even-view-the-game-from-the-sidelines ethos. These same types of marketers are addicted to gadgets, gimmicks, and every shortcut you can imagine. And the rest of us are paying for it, literally.
BAD MARKETERS CONTINUE TO RUIN MARKETING
Bad marketers flood every social media platform with low-quality, generic content, leading to ad fatigue, trust erosion, and platform abandonment. Creative built with AI is where bad marketers are sowing the most discord. This isn’t confined to small boutique agencies or local business owners. Large companies like Guess, Vogue, and even Coca-Cola put out AI-generated content in the last year that was immediately rejected by the public.
If the biggest brands are cutting corners with AI, and they employ the most experienced marketers in the world, imagine what is happening at smaller businesses or those with less experienced marketers.
Another way bad marketers give the industry a bad name is selling clients on “vanity metrics.” I’ve seen it in meetings with clients: As soon as you start talking about likes, comments, and even clicks or view-throughs, smart business owners can smell the fraud. Businesses hire marketing agencies to help them sell more products or services, not to get “engagement.” Growing followers and getting more people to like and comment on a post doesn’t drive sales. Smart business owners know that.
The real issue is when agencies sell naive business owners on these metrics and all the owner gets in return is a larger following without increased sales. These owners then develop a career-long distrust of all marketers.
SHINY NEW TOY SYNDROME
When ChatGPT launched, it felt like 80% of my LinkedIn feed was posts from marketers that were using it to “optimize their efficiency” and create “relevant content in a fraction of the time” freeing them to be “more creative.” Only 5% of companies see any real return on investment from using generative AI. So, what are they doing in that free time to drive return?
In terms of creative and content, generative AI has been a net negative for marketing. Generic, non-personalized creative has flooded the market, and it is turning people off. Users know when they’re being lied to and they’re spending their money elsewhere. You must market to a person, not the lowest common denominator.
Additionally, deploying generative AI in marketing at too great a rate of speed has been shown to exaggerate preexisting biases. Simply put, generative AI produces content based on available data. It doesn’t create anything completely new: It just rearranges information based on prompts.
Despite all this, there is hope.
HOW GREAT MARKETERS CAPITALIZE ON AI
Greatness in marketing begins and ends in the same place: with the client. It doesn’t matter how great your data is, how much reach you can provide, or how amazing your creative team is if you don’t know exactly what the customer wants and needs. You must know their business, their industry, their competition, and the person with whom you are directly working. If you don’t have all of that mastered, none of the rest matters.
When used well, AI can be the greatest creative and analytical tool you have ever used. In campaign creation and optimization, AI can drive return on investment to unprecedented levels. Social media campaigns using AI improve ad engagement rates by 47%. AI-automated bidding also reduces Facebook ad costs by 35%, increasing ROI.
I was recently speaking with my friend and former colleague, Stephen Nations, senior vice president of Drive Social Media, and he perfectly explained how great marketers can leverage AI.
“AI makes good creative cheaper. That’s not scary, that’s leveling the field. The advantage shifts from who can spend to who can iterate. More tests, more platforms, more offers, more hooks. Faster feedback loops. That’s the new moat. AI didn’t just automate production. It raised the bar. If everyone can ship decent ads, ‘decent’ stops being a differentiator. Strategy, speed, and iteration become the whole game.”
With AI at your disposal, you can compete with agencies of any size. Knowing how to leverage AI to increase speed and decrease costs allows you to simultaneously stay lean and deliver great ROI for your clients. If you’re a great marketer, you will win in the long run.
Marketing and advertising have faced the threat of new technology for decades and always survived. Technology was never the enemy: It was, and remains, bad marketers. Great marketers will always win in the long run by using AI as a tool to build a sustaining, client-centered, and successful agency.
AI alone won’t win anything. AI plus a great marketing team, however, will win every time.
Will Saulsbery is founder and CEO of Ashtonbery Consulting.