Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Employee engagement without ownership is theater

Learn to recognize the symptoms and address the issues.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Shawn Galloway

CEO · ProAct Safety, Inc.

Every leadership conference, every culture initiative, every town hall meeting circles back to the same word: engagement. Companies spend on measuring it, chasing it, and celebrating it. Engagement scores climb. Leaders congratulate themselves.

In my opinion, the organizations posting their highest engagement numbers often struggle with accountability gaps, initiative fatigue, and a workforce that participates without owning outcomes. That should concern us more than it does.

The engagement-industrial complex

Somewhere along the way, employee engagement became the finish line. It isn’t. At best, engagement is a starting condition. At worst, it’s a vanity metric that gives leaders permission to stop thinking about what actually drives sustainable performance.

There is a fundamental difference between a workforce that is engaged and a workforce that takes ownership.

Engaged employees buy in, show up, willingly participate, and respond to what leadership initiates. Employees taking ownership act without prompting to identify problems before they become crises. They hold standards when no one is watching, creating continuous improvement. They’re the reason for innovation.

Picture the maintenance technician who shuts down a line, knowing the lost minutes count against his numbers. But he’s decided that the standard matters more than the metric.

Engagement is responsive. Ownership is generative. Most organizations have optimized for the wrong one.

Why confusion persists

Engagement is easier to measure. It shows up in surveys, participation rates, and sentiment scores. It produces dashboards that look impressive in board presentations.

Moreover, it creates the appearance of a healthy culture without requiring leaders to confront the deeper architectural question: Have we built a system in which people feel genuinely responsible for outcomes, or one in which they feel responsible for compliance?

The answer determines whether an organization can sustain performance under pressure or only perform well under favorable conditions.

As Harvard Business Review points out, Wells Fargo is the cautionary version of this. For years, its people were fully engaged in the work in front of them, hitting aggressive cross-selling targets while the company pointed to its ethics program and whistleblower hotline as proof of a healthy culture.

There’s no question that employees were engaged, but in my opinion, they didn’t own the outcome. But by the time regulators finished their investigation, employees had opened an estimated 3.5 million unauthorized accounts, and the bank had paid at least $1 billion in penalties.

Or consider this pattern. An organization launches a new initiative. At first, participation is strong, and engagement scores tick upward. Leaders declare success. Six months later, the initiative stalls. A new one replaces it, and the cycle repeats as participation remains high, but progress does not.

For example, I worked with a pulp and paper manufacturer that rolled out a behavior-based observation program to address the factors influencing risky behaviors. Observation card counts climbed, and leaders celebrated the participation.

Within a year, the cards used to observe behavior and identify risk influences were being completed to meet a weekly quota, yet the same hazards kept reappearing, so the effort stalled because no one actually owned the conditions the program was meant to fix.

What went wrong? Nothing, if engagement was the goal. Everything, if performance was.

The ownership gap

Organizations building genuine ownership design systems where ownership is the natural consequence of how work is structured. They hold leaders accountable not for running programs but for developing the capacity of employees closest to the work.

In ownership-focused organizations, you see specific behaviors. For example, imagine a frontline operator who flags a failing process weeks before it would have resulted in a recordable injury. She does so because she will not let a teammate get hurt, and shows ownership that no engagement survey would ever capture.

Ownership requires shared accountability for outcomes. It’s built through structural choices about how accountability is distributed, how leaders respond to bad news, and how the organization treats the gap between what it says and what it tolerates.

You can have a highly engaged workforce with almost no ownership. In fact, some of the most engaged cultures are also the most dependent on leadership to initiate, direct, and sustain every effort.

Ownership demands that leaders move beyond asking “Are people bought in and involved?” and start asking “Do people feel the weight of what happens next and feel responsible for their peers?”

But building that system requires a trade-off most executives resist: Ownership requires leaders to relinquish control over how outcomes are achieved, not just whether they are achieved.

The truth test

Here is a simple diagnostic.

Where practical, remove a leader from an operation for 30 days and place them on a special value-added project. If performance holds, you have ownership. Run it deliberately, not as a trap.

Tell the team in advance that the leader is stepping back for a set period, perhaps on a special assignment. Name who holds which decisions in the interim, and agree on the threshold that would justify pulling the leader back in early.

You are not testing whether people can survive chaos. You are testing whether the standards, decision rights, and sense of responsibility were actually transferred. The operations that hold are the ones where ownership was built long before it was measured.

Organizations that depend on leadership presence to sustain standards have built an internal system of dependency. And dependency, no matter how enthusiastically it participates in surveys, is fragile.

If you stepped away from your operation for a month, what would hold, and what would come apart? That answer is your real culture.

Where this leaves us

The next evolution of leadership builds systems in which ownership is embedded in how work is designed, how accountability flows, and how the organization learns from success and failure.

Leadership must keep closing the gap between engagement and ownership until the standards no longer require you to be in the room. Do that, and the scores take care of themselves. Skip it, and you run a performance that holds up until the house lights come up.

Shawn M. Galloway is the CEO of ProAct Safety.