Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The simple tool that fixes bad ideas

The hardest part of innovation is choosing which idea deserves your time, budget, and reputation.

[Photo: Duncan Wardle]

Profile photo of Duncan Wardle

Founder · iD8 & innov8

Your team has done the work. You’ve generated a pile of ideas, some practical, some weird, a few that feel electric. Then the meeting happens.

Someone senior frowns. Someone confident talks faster. Someone else starts defending their favorite concept like it’s a family member. Ten minutes later, you have a winner, often the safest idea that survived the room’s politics.

Psychologists have a name for this phenomenon. Groupthink occurs when people become so focused on agreeing with one another that they stop thinking clearly. It’s a real phenomenon, and it shows up in workplaces that are smart, busy, and under pressure. I’ve watched this play out in boardrooms, creative reviews, and product meetings, even at Walt Disney Company, where I was the former vice president of innovation and creativity.

When the selection process is fuzzy, we reach for shortcuts, whether hierarchy, volume, or vibes. The “Highest Paid Person’s Opinion,” which is as common as it is expensive.

So let’s make idea selection less subjective, without sucking the energy out of it.

5 STEPS TO APPLY THE STARGAZER TOOL

The tool I use is called Stargazer. I borrowed it from Richard Branson of Virgin, then adapted it for teams that need a clean way to compare ideas against what success actually means.

1. DEFINE SUCCESS BEFORE YOU FALL IN LOVE

Most teams do this backward. They hold brainstorming sessions, pick a few favorites, then scramble to justify them with criteria they invent after the fact.

Flip it. Before evaluating a single concept, define what “good” looks like for this project. Choose five success criteria that matter for the decision you’re making right now. Keep them specific and measurable enough that you can argue about them productively.

Here are five example criteria:

  • Brand fit: Does the idea align with the organization’s values?
  • Customer truth: Is this idea embedded in consumer insight?
  • Speed to market: Can you deliver a first version within an agreed-upon timeline?
  • Financial impact: Is there a believable path to the numbers you need?
  • Social energy: Would people talk about it, share it, rally around it?

Other criteria may also apply, such as whether the idea can be executed within the allowed time frame and budget, or whether it has the potential to meet or exceed revenue projections. The criteria will differ for each challenge, which is why early definition is so important.

2. DRAW YOUR STARFISH

The Stargazer method, when illustrated, looks like a starfish. Draw a circle in the middle, then five arms reaching out. Label each arm with one of your criteria.

At the end of each arm, mark three levels:

  • Poor
  • Good
  • Outstanding

Each arm represents a success criterion, and the three notches allow you to quickly score how well an idea performs against it. The closer the mark is to the outer edge, the better the idea meets that particular criterion.

That’s it. You’ve built a decision compass that makes your strategy visible.

Use the same criteria for every idea in this round. If you change the rules midstream, you’re back to politics. Second, make the criteria project-specific, as described in step one.  

3. SCORE IDEAS FAST AND QUIETLY

Now, take your first idea. Go criterion by criterion and rate it: poor, good, or outstanding. Do the same for each idea.

The best practice I’ve learned the hard way is to ask everyone to score silently first. Give everyone two minutes to rate an idea on their own before sharing and discussing. You can do this on a shared board, sticky notes, or a simple template. When you start with independent judgment, you reduce the social pressure to conform, which is where groupthink gets its oxygen.

After the silent score, discuss the gaps:

  • “I rated speed to market as poor. What am I missing?”
  • “You rated customer truth as outstanding. What evidence do you have?”

Notice what changed. You’re no longer arguing taste. You’re trading observations. When criteria are agreed upfront, you’re debating the work, not the person.

5. READ THE SHAPE

Once you score an idea, connect the dots across the five arms. You’ll get a shape. Do this for each idea in a different color.

Now stand back and look at the shapes, because the shapes tell you what your meeting cannot.

  • A big, balanced shape suggests a concept that hits most of what you said matters.
  • A lopsided shape can still be a winner, but it tells you the tradeoff you’re making.
  • A small shape with one long arm is often an idea with one charming feature and many hidden risks.

The tool works because it turns abstract debate into something you can see. This is also where hierarchy loses its grip. A senior leader can still have a strong point, but the diagram asks a better question: “Does the idea meet the criteria we agreed would define success?” That’s how you make the decision feel fair, even to the people whose idea you don’t pick.

6. RUN A SECOND PASS BEFORE YOU COMMIT

A second Stargazer pass gives you confidence. Before you commit resources to a project, do two quick upgrades:

Pressure-test your criteria. Are any redundant? Are you missing a constraint that will matter later (regulation, operational load, security, supply chain)?

Add one evidence step per arm. This could be a:

  • Customer quote
  • Cost range
  • Prototype demo
  • Delivery estimate from the people who will build the project

If you want to get fancy, you can weight the criteria. If you want to keep it fast, don’t. Richard Branson often treated brand alignment and core human truth as non-negotiables. If an idea didn’t meet those standards, it didn’t move forward. Other factors, such as profitability or speed to market, could be improved later, but misalignment with the brand or the customer was a deal-breaker.

Because idea selection is where great ideas die young inside organizations. Not in the brainstorm, but in the meeting where opinions masquerade as strategy.

When you make success visible, the best ideas no longer need permission.

Duncan Wardle is cofounder of iD8 & innov8.