Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why powering reputation is the new SEO

It’s time to look at where your reputation stands.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Evan Nierman

Founder & CEO · Red Banyan

For two decades, the rules of being found online held steady. You chose the right keywords, earned some backlinks, cleaned up your metadata, and waited for Google to rank you. Search engine optimization was a technical craft, and companies that mastered it won placement for themselves or their clients at the top of the page.

The era of SEO as ranking overlord is coming to a close.

More people now begin their search inside an artificial intelligence assistant. They ask these tools to recommend a vendor, vet a job candidate, identify an industry expert, or determine whether a company can be trusted. Instead of receiving a page of links, they receive a single, direct answer.

The shift to AI raises an important question for business leaders: When a machine describes your company, where does it get its information?

The answer is not your website. It is your reputation.

AI RUNS ON REPUTATION 

One of the biggest misconceptions about AI search is that it works like traditional search engines. It does not.

A language model does not reward the cleverest metadata or the most optimized landing page. Instead, it looks for patterns across sources it considers credible and draws conclusions based on those signals.

According to research from Muck Rack, some 99% of links cited in AI-generated answers come from earned, non-paid sources. Those sources include mainstream journalism, industry-specific publications, independent reviews, expert commentary, and third-party mentions.

That represents a meaningful shift. Traditional SEO focused on assets under your full control. AI-driven discovery increasingly relies on a broader mix of signals, particularly earned media, third-party validation, and independent sources. Visibility is becoming less about what you publish about yourself, and more about what others publish about you.

YOUR ORGANIZATION’S AUDIENCE HAS CHANGED

I have spent over two decades advising leaders on how the world perceives them, and the underlying dynamic has not fundamentally changed. But what has evolved is the audience.

That audience now includes machines that can read thousands of articles, reviews, interviews, and online conversations in mere seconds before generating a summary of who you are and what you represent.

Think of every credible mention of your organization as a brick. Whether it is a quote in a trade publication, a bylined article in a respected outlet, a well-crafted press release that earns pickup, a video clip of you speaking at a conference, or a thoughtful customer review, each one contributes to the foundation that AI systems use to understand your business.

When that foundation is weak, incomplete, or inconsistent, machines often fill in the gaps using whatever information is most available. But when the foundation is strong, the resulting narrative is more likely to reflect reality or the positioning that you desire.

MACHINES ARE SHAPING HOW YOU ARE SEEN

The impact of this shift toward machine-generated reality is already visible.

Consider Reddit’s growing importance in the AI ecosystem. For years, Reddit was often viewed as a chaotic collection of user-generated conversations. Yet, as AI tools became more widely adopted, companies such as OpenAI and Google struck deals to access Reddit’s content because millions of discussions, recommendations, reviews, and firsthand experiences provide valuable signals about what real people think.

The same principle increasingly applies to companies and executives.

Ask an AI assistant to describe a business or a public figure. The response rarely sounds like marketing copy pulled from a corporate website. Instead, it reflects years of media coverage, interviews, reviews, commentary, and third-party validations or degradations.

In many respects, the machines are now assembling their own version of your reputation.

Every article, interview, review, and mention contributes to a larger body of information that helps determine how an organization is understood. When those signals are consistent, the resulting narrative is often accurate and coherent. When they are fragmented, outdated, or sparse, the resulting picture can be incomplete, misleading, or not what you would consider optimal.

PUBLIC RELATIONS HAS BECOME A SEARCH STRATEGY

For all these reasons, public relations has become a vital search strategy.

Earning credible media coverage has always helped build trust and awareness. But today, it serves another critical purpose. It helps shape the information ecosystem that AI systems rely upon when generating answers.

Organizations that consistently contribute expertise, publish original insights, and earn coverage in respected press outlets create a body of information that machines can reference. Organizations that remain absent from the broader conversation will find themselves increasingly difficult to discover.

This does not mean traditional SEO no longer matters. But it is no longer enough on its own. It needs to be adapted for the new realities of an AI-powered world.

Companies that succeed in the AI-driven environment understand that discoverability now extends far beyond their websites and marketing materials. Their voice must be present in the broader reputational landscape that surrounds them.

REPUTATION IS A KEY INGREDIENT FOR AI SUCCESS

Search once rewarded the best-optimized page. In the age of AI, visibility increasingly depends on what others say about you and how you are presented across a range of sources.

Reputation has become more tangible than ever before. It is a digitally indexed signal that influences whether your organization appears in the answer, how it is described, and whether it is recommended.

Organizations that are recognizing this shift and investing in building strong reputations will be better positioned to earn trust, shape perception, and remain highly visible in this AI-driven world. The rest will find themselves wondering why they disappeared from a search they once dominated.

Evan Nierman is founder and CEO of Red Banyan.