Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to maintain energy while you manage business reality

The approach I call optimistic pragmatism.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Andrew Thomas

A specific kind of internal friction defines a marketing leader’s life, particularly during a high-stakes growth phase. On one hand, you are the chief enthusiast, responsible for fueling the creative engine, keeping the team inspired, and maintaining the belief that your brand can punch well above its weight.

On the other hand, you’re a general manager navigating the world of operational physics. You see the supply chain constraints, the tightening budgets, and the cold reality of the profit-and-loss statement.

Early in my career, I viewed these roles as directly opposed. I assumed leadership was a binary choice where you’re either the visionary leader who protected the creative spark by ignoring the “no” from the finance department, or the pragmatic operator who eventually crushed that spark under a spreadsheet’s weight. I thought you had to choose between being the inspiration or being the anchor.

After nearly two decades in the consumer packaged goods trenches, I’ve realized this is a false dichotomy. The most effective leaders fuse optimism and pragmatism into a single operating system I call “optimistic pragmatism.” It’s the ability to keep the wheel’s hub spinning at high RPM while remaining fully aware of how much stress the axle can withstand.

The “fun” mandate as a performance standard

This balance begins with the department’s cultural temperature. As a creative discipline, marketing is sensitive to the energy of the people doing the work. If paralyzed by the weight of business reality, a team’s work inevitably becomes clinical, defensive, and worst of all, boring.

I’ve made having fun a non-negotiable part of my leadership framework. It sounds like corporate fluff, but in my experience, it’s a hard-nosed performance standard. I constantly tell my team: “If we aren’t having fun, we’re doing it wrong.”

At the end of the day, we sell meat snacks. We aren’t performing open-heart surgery. When a team loses sight of that, the pressure becomes existential. Lowering the existential stakes raises the creative ceiling. You create a space where a team can take an intuitive leap because they know that a failed campaign isn’t a life-or-death event.

Navigate the business physics

However, that optimism must be tethered to something real, or it quickly devolves into toxic positivity. Many leaders mistakenly try to shield their team from ugly business realities, like budget cuts or manufacturing delays, thinking they’re protecting the team’s energy.

In reality, when you shield a team from the truth, you’re letting them build a creative house on a foundation of sand. When the eventual reality hits and the project gets killed, the team’s morale is shattered because they felt blindsided by a reality they didn’t know existed.

To avoid this, I practice a “push-pull” approach to internal communication. The “push” is the clinical reality or constraints. If the supply chain tells us a ship date is physically impossible, I immediately acknowledge the physics of the situation without sugarcoating it.

But then comes the “pull.” Once the constraints are on the table, I pull the team back into the solution space. We use the barrier’s frustration as a creative prompt.

I’ll ask the team: “Okay, if the physical ship date is fixed, how do we use that lead time to create a ‘pull’ strategy that makes the eventual launch twice as loud?”

By framing the reality as a guardrail rather than a roadblock, you maintain momentum without lying to your people about the challenges ahead.

Ownership as an energy source

The pivot from problem to solution is about trust, which only works if the team feels a genuine sense of ownership over the outcome. This is where the “Hub of the Wheel” philosophy I learned while at General Mills truly comes to life. For marketing to function as the strategic center coordinating sales, operations, and finance, the people running the individual spokes need the car keys.

When you empower people in this way, you realize that micromanagement is the ultimate energy killer during a crisis. If I’m the one making every tactical pivot, I’ve essentially become a bottleneck. The moment a team has to wait for my instructions, their momentum stalls and their energy flags.

To prevent that, I treat my team as fellow general managers. When we hit a market disruption, I provide the context and the physics of the problem, and then step back. When people have the autonomy to navigate a constraint themselves, their resilience spikes.

The team starts seeing reality as a challenge they are actively solving. And that sense of agency is a far more sustainable fuel than any “rah-rah” speech a leader could ever give.

The discipline of the filter

Finally, maintaining long-term energy requires the discipline to know what not to chase. My industry is addicted to the zeitgeist, where a new social media villain prompts a pivot away, or a viral trend prompts a pivot toward. Chase every wave, and you’ll drown your team.

Optimistic pragmatism means having a filter. Just because a competitor is shouting about a niche nutritional fad doesn’t mean we need to burn our team’s energy responding to it. I’ve learned to distinguish between a genuine cultural shift—like the long-term move toward protein—and a passing social media trend.

Pragmatic courage stays focused on the fundamentals of flavor, real ingredients, and convenience. You provide your team with a stable foundation, then decide which parts of that market actually deserve your team’s brilliance.

Balance high-level optimism with a grounded understanding of the business, and build a team resilient enough to handle any disruption. They’ll know how to work within the business’s physics without ever losing the joy of the game.

Andrew Thomas is the head of marketing at Archer Meat Snacks.