Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why brands must first build emotional investment

Slowing down is the fastest path to brand growth.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Amy Lanzi

CEO · Digitas

This might sound counterintuitive in an era of optimization dashboards and real-time attribution, but the highest-performing creative strategies focus on brand building. It comes down to managing timelessness versus timely themes that resonate with consumers, algorithms, and AI agents.

Short-term ad spending’s ephemeral promise leads brands to abandon the power of emotionally resonant advertising grounded in original storytelling.

For me, Nike circa 2021 was the cautionary tale. Watching from the outside, it looked like one of the greatest storytelling brands in history decided the story could take a back seat and that you didn’t need to keep earning emotional connections. The organization seemed to reorient around direct-to-consumer selling, and the brand-building faded into the background. To me, that was a bet that affinity is permanent. It isn’t.

Nike’s stance has shifted lately, directing marketing, social, and communications outreach to build influence across sport-specific community networks. “We did that through our deep portfolio of athletes, creators, and sport partners,” Nike CEO Elliott Hill said. “And through those networks, we brought energy and a uniquely Nike point of view to sports moments, both big and small.”

You just cannot skip to conversion without first building affinity. Storytelling drives new and repeat customers, laying the foundation to convert first-time buyers into loyal advocates. In 2026, no genuine performance can stand without a strong basis of original creative expression tied to a clear brand identity.

The zombie brand epidemic

Hyper-targeting (narrowly aiming ads at tightly defined audiences) forced all brands to chase an ever-elusive consumer through supposed “personalized ads” on social media. At first glance, this sort of targeted, algorithmic marketing seemed like scientific progress.

But an over-concentration on short-form, high-frequency, low-quality content conditioned audiences to tune out. It’s understandable, as the proliferation of practically infinite channels gives brands mere seconds to get consumers to stop and look.

But, as we’ve all heard many times, looks aren’t everything.

The targeting trap shrinks marketers’ growth potential. If you’re just talking to your own customers, you’re just picking the same fruit off the same tree and ignoring the orchard, sacrificing audience expansion. And when those existing consumers stop buying what you’re offering, you’re left with a dead tree.

John Long, our Digitas executive creative director, authored a book that captures this dynamic, Zombie Brand. The term refers to brands that play to the algorithm, devolving into unfeeling husks that bombard audiences with cheap, undifferentiated messages in pursuit of conversion metrics. Like horror-movie zombies, these brands appear alive, but they’re slow-moving, dull, and mindlessly destructive.

The smartphone-centric media ecosystem eroded what makes brands viscerally appealing. Twenty years of stock photography made some brands look identical. We all recognize photos of “women laughing alone with salad” because we’ve seen it used ad infinitum.

Digital ad formats were optimized for efficiency, not emotional impact. And brief chief marketing officer tenures (averaging 4 years) perpetuate pressure for immediate results, undermining long-term brand health.

The counterintuitive truth

To be clear, “depth” isn’t just format size or project length. The Oscars don’t automatically go to massive tomes and endless reels.

That said, form matters. Short-form video content trains audiences to absently flit their precious attention away. Long-form forces creators to acknowledge that they must earn attention with quality.

When done right, that generates a relationship with substance and trust. When audiences choose to spend time with your brand, they’re making an emotional investment. The trick is making them pay attention and stick around for more.

The thing is that it’s not a trick. In the 1990s, 30-second spots often cost as much as TV episodes—and sometimes matched or even exceeded their production value. In addition, some commercials’ entertainment value sometimes rivaled the programming they ran against.

Brands competing with entertainment remember that every interface offers a portal to storytelling. Without product placement, brands need to build equity together with Hollywood, not simply as a random scene insert.

Liquid Death’s success is a great example, taking the least differentiated product imaginable—water in a can—and building one of the most talked-about brands in consumer goods. What I find instructive is the discipline behind the irreverence. Liquid Death behaves like an entertainment brand first and a beverage company second, treating its marketing with the same care most companies reserve for product. The lesson for the rest of us: When your story is doing that much work, brand affinity starts driving the business.

The AI paradox and what works

Every brand now has access to the same artificial intelligence tools. The results tend to be average, and nothing stands out but the obvious use of AI. Sure, AI can amplify production—goodbye, stock photography.

But AI is based on the mathematically determined “most likely next word.” It scrapes conventional wisdom and produces technically competent mediocrity at scale. What AI cannot do, at least right now, is generate original ideas, recognize human truths, or understand emotional resonance.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company’s campaign about the uncomfortable feeling as you “become” your parents. That’s a human insight, told humorously and engagingly, and one that an algorithm could never surface. Depth and humanity are the new disruptive forces when consumers are increasingly conditioned to tune out marketing,

What marketers must do now

Emotional equity—the deep, trusting bond a consumer feels toward a brand—requires creative investment. Long-form content isn’t expensive compared to the alternative of declining brand health.

My advice is to redefine performance. Emotional connection is the highest-performing marketing strategy. So measure accordingly.

Investing in high-attention media starts with individual ideas. Match quality to context so your creative competes with the content it interrupts. Build affinity first, because you cannot skip to conversion without emotional equity.

And be willing to slow down. The brands winning hearts will win clicks—in that order.

While there are more media options, more data and more automation, brands are less distinctive than ever. The challenge facing every marketer in 2026: Will you build emotional equity or just add to the noise?

Amy Lanzi is CEO at Digitas.