Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Your hiring problem starts with the job description

Effective hiring processes start with clear expectations.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Trent Cotton

Head of Talent Insights · ICIMS

Most job descriptions today are not designed to help you hire. They are designed to attract attention, and that distinction is now costing organizations in every part of the hiring process.

According to ICIMS research, 45% of workers said they plan to look for a new job this year. Unfortunately, candidates are increasingly frustrated by roles that look one way on paper and another in interviews. Job descriptions were never created to function as decision-making tools, and that gap is showing up everywhere. We have turned job descriptions into advertisements when they should function as scorecards.

The marketing mindset is creating hiring problems

Look at most job descriptions, and the patterns are easy to spot. Requirements are inflated, experience is used as a proxy for skill, and the language consists of broad, feel-good terms to make the role sound appealing. Words like dynamic and fast-paced appear often, even though no one defines how those traits are evaluated.

That approach may increase applicant volume, but it does not improve hiring outcomes. Instead, it creates confusion. Recruiters screen candidates based on loose interpretations and hiring managers enter interviews without a shared definition of success. After a few conversations, hiring managers begin to add to what they are looking for in a candidate. A manager decides they now want stronger strategic thinking or different experience, even though those expectations were never clearly defined.

The result is a moving target. Recruiters go back to the market with revised criteria and candidates who have already invested time are evaluated against shifting expectations. The process drags out, and frustration builds on all sides.

A scorecard brings clarity

A job description should define how success in the role will be measured. That requires a shift from marketing language to measurable skills.

A scorecard-based job description outlines the specific capabilities required for the role and assigns weight to each one. It focuses on the skills someone needs to be successful instead of how the company wants to describe itself.

For example, critical thinking can be translated into structured interview questions or practical exercises. A requirement like seven years of experience does not tell you whether someone can solve the problems the role demands.

This level of specificity changes how candidates engage. They can quickly determine whether they are a fit and how to prepare. It could also improve the quality of the applicant pool because people are responding to clear expectations rather than broad signals.

Consistency changes the entire process

Most interviews today lack consistency. Different interviewers focus on different areas, questions vary widely, feedback is subjective, and decisions often come down to personal preference rather than a shared standard.

A scorecard-style job description creates alignment before the first interview. When the same criteria define the role and shape the interview questions, each candidate is assessed against the same set of weighted skills.

Consistency improves speed and fairness and hiring teams spend less time debating what matters because they already agreed on it. More importantly, candidates experience an equitable process that reflects the role they applied for instead of one that evolves midstream.

In my own work building recruiting functions, creating a scorecard at the front end changed the recruiter’s role. It evolved their responsibility from taking orders to advising the business. It also reduced wasted effort by limiting restarted searches and eliminating the need to continuously adjust the profile once interviews had already begun.

This is the starting point for better use of AI

The same structural clarity that aligns hiring teams is also what makes AI-driven hiring tools work. While there is a growing focus on how AI will shape hiring, most of that conversation skips over a critical detail: The quality of the output depends on the quality of the input.

Job descriptions are among the primary inputs into AI-driven matching and screening. When those descriptions are vague or inconsistent, the technology interprets unclear signals. That could lead to weaker matches, less reliable outcomes, and compounding biases and inefficiencies.

A scorecard introduces the structure that makes AI useful. It provides clear, skills-based data that both people and systems can use more effectively. It does not solve every challenge, but it establishes a foundation that supports better decision-making as technology becomes more embedded in hiring.

Stop trying to attract everyone

This shift does not require a full organizational overhaul on day one. In fact, trying to change everything at once often turns into a compliance exercise that misses the point.

Start with one team. Build scorecards for a small set of roles, define the core skills, assign weights to each, and align the interview process with those criteria. Then track what changes, evaluate candidate quality, measure new hire retention, and hiring manager satisfaction.

Organizations that can shift from making job descriptions more appeal to making hiring more precise will move faster, evaluate more consistently, and create a better experience for candidates and hiring teams alike. In a market that has little tolerance for inefficiency, clarity becomes a competitive advantage.

Trent Cotton is the head of talent insights at ICIMS.