Every few months, I get a version of the same call. A senior marketer, good at their job, telling me something feels off but they can’t name it.
That unease has a structural explanation. In a 2025 survey of more than 400 chief marketing officers, Gartner found that 84% report high levels of strategic dysfunction in their role. Most of the time, the dysfunction traces back to how the function was built.
Over the past two years I’ve given names to the six patterns I see most often. Most mid-market companies are living inside at least one of these structural failures right now.
1. THE SENIORITY INVERSION
Most mid-market companies hire a senior marketing leader because they need strategic direction. They don’t account for the fact that strategy requires infrastructure to execute against. When there’s no mid-level team to carry the work, the senior leader becomes the team. They’re talented enough to do the tactical work, so they do it. The pipeline doesn’t move and nobody can explain why, because on paper the function looks staffed.
2. THE MARKETING DISCOUNT
Walk into most mid-market companies and you’ll find the vice president of sales with real upside tied to closed revenue. The vice president of marketing is on a flat base with a bonus tied to leads generated or campaigns launched. Same table, completely different signal about what the company thinks each role is worth. The compensation structure communicates that one function drives the business and one supports it.
Chief executives and chief financial officers only consider 14% of CMOs as highly effective at market shaping, according to Gartner. The structure precedes the perception.
3. THE MISSING MIDDLE
There’s a version of this I see constantly: a CMO or vice president at the top, a coordinator handling logistics at the bottom, and nothing in between. No one to own a campaign end to end. No one to turn a strategic priority into a project with a timeline and a budget. The senior leader ends up filling that gap the same way they fill every other one—by doing it themselves, until they can’t anymore.
4. RANDOM ACTS OF MARKETING
The plan exists. The problem is that it’s a list, not a strategy. Every quarter brings new priorities from sales, from the CEO, or from whoever read something somewhere. The team executes against all of it because nothing ever gets officially deprioritized. At the end of the year, there’s plenty of activity to report and not much revenue to show for it.
5. THE BOLT-ON TRAP
An artificial intelligence strategy lands on the desk of a functional leader who already has a full-time job. No dedicated budget, no clear owner, and no timeline. The initiative gets announced, gets added to someone’s plate, and slowly loses altitude. The companies I see stuck here aren’t resistant to AI. They’re just treating a discipline like a task and wondering why the results aren’t materializing.
6. THE JUDGMENT PREMIUM
For most of the last decade, marketing rewarded execution. Build the campaign, run the channels, and keep the dashboard clean. That’s what companies hired for, and that’s what marketers developed. AI now handles most of that execution. The 2026 Microsoft Work Trend Index found that 46% of AI users say critical thinking and judgment are the most important human skills as AI takes on more work. The companies that invested only in execution are now short on the one thing they didn’t build: the capacity to decide what work should ship in the first place.
WHAT TO DO WITH THIS INFORMATION
None of these patterns are the fault of the marketer inside them. Most aren’t the CEO’s fault either. They’re what happens when a marketing function gets assembled one hire at a time, with no one designing the whole.
Adding people rarely solves it. Naming what’s actually broken usually does.
Every one of these is fixable. I’ve seen companies work their way out of all six. It starts with someone deciding to look at the function as a whole and asking whether it was ever built to work. Most weren’t. And once you see that, the individual problems get a lot easier to solve.
Once a company can name what it’s dealing with, it can build its way out.
Debra Andrews is the founder and president of Marketri.