Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Free your people and the work will follow

What most companies get wrong about employee loyalty.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Bryan Christian

CEO · Proof Advertising

The average employee tenure at my advertising agency is longer than the average American marriage. In an industry that loses 20% to 30% of its people every year, we have lost 1% since 2021. But it wasn’t always that way.

THE STORY EVERY AGENCY TELLS ITSELF

For decades, agencies have explained their churn the same way: Creative people are restless by nature. They get bored. They need new stimulus. It is just how the work goes.

These are convenient explanations. But they don’t force us to ask hard questions about why people are actually leaving.

A few years back, we doubled down on a hunch we’d had for a while. We thought the people the industry was calling restless were just worn out. Strip away the things that wear out creative people and they would stay.

So, we killed the office lease. We went permanently remote. We bought a house on Lake Austin for the times we needed to be together. We removed the cap on time off. We stopped tracking when and where work happened and started tracking what came out of it.

We redesigned the agency to be built around the lives of its employees, instead of the other way around. Then we waited.

WHAT FREEDOM LOOKS LIKE IN PRACTICE

Five years later, things look a lot different. Instead of sleep-deprived people huddled in a conference room, we have a Zoom call with people in four states and one calling from a kid’s soccer game. Instead of obligatory office happy hours, we get together in person once a month for things like go-karting and pickleball.

Our associate creative director, 31 years with us, spends his weekends sculpting latex monster masks and handcrafting the trophies we give out at internal competitions. Our executive creative director earned her Master of Fine Arts while running the department. And our media director fulfilled a lifelong dream of starting a mobile cocktail business and now she rolls it up to agency parties.

What a person brings to work comes from the life they live outside of it. You don’t get that from someone running on fumes.

THE HIDDEN COST OF TURNOVER

The obvious costs of turnover are easy to total. Recruiting fees. Onboarding. The months it takes a new hire to get useful. But what about the bigger cost? The one where every new person spends their first year learning what the person before them already knew.

Industry average tenure is 2.5 years. Ours is more than 10 years, or roughly four times the experience on every account. Industry retention runs 70% to 80%. Ours has been 100% for five years. That’s 20 to 30 points less churn, less retraining, and less work falling onto the people who stayed.

When an account director has been on the same client account for 11 years, she stops waiting for the brief and starts anticipating it. When a creative director has watched three chief marketing officers cycle through, he knows which ideas already failed and why. You can’t hire that. You can’t onboard it. It is paid for in years.

THE OBVIOUS OBJECTION

The pushback we hear is that fresh people bring fresh ideas and stable teams go stale. That has not been our experience. Ideas in advertising are abundant; anyone can have one. The harder part is knowing which idea will work for a specific brand at a specific moment. And that knowing only comes from years on the account. Remembering what already fell flat is what lets you swing harder on what comes next.

Then there’s what happens to a team that’s worked together for years. A new hire is learning the client and the room at the same time—how everyone thinks, what they care about, and what gets them to push back. After a few years, that knowledge turns into shorthand. The work moves faster because nobody needs to translate anymore.

MOST COMPANIES HAVE IT BACKWARDS

Most companies say: If you’re loyal, you get flexibility. Look at vacation time. You start with a handful of days a year. Stay long enough, prove your loyalty, get a few more days a year.

We said: Start with flexibility, and loyalty will follow. It did. People stuck around. Turnover became almost nonexistent. And we won best culture awards inside and outside of advertising.

The ad industry has called its best people restless for decades. They were just tired. Build the agency around their lives instead of the other way around, and they stay long enough to do the best work of their careers.

Bryan Christian is the founder and CEO of Proof Advertising.