For decades, leaders encouraged employees to “think outside the box.” The phrase is among the most enduring pieces of business advice, appearing in brainstorming sessions, strategic planning retreats, and executive off-sites whenever organizations want fresh thinking.
That advice is likely solving the wrong problem, as what holds people back from fresh ideas is not knowing where the box’s edges are. When people don’t understand the boundaries around a decision, they become overwhelmed by possibilities, second-guess themselves, or default to familiar solutions.
I came to this realization after connecting two seemingly unrelated parts of my life. By profession, I lead a research and strategy firm with more than two decades of helping organizations make better decisions. Outside of work, I’m an award-winning wildlife photographer who has made eight photography expeditions to Africa.
For years, I thought those worlds had very little in common. It turns out they were teaching me the same lesson, and it took six trips to Africa before realizing I’d been solving the wrong problem.
On an expedition
Each year I packed more equipment than the year before. Another lens. Another camera body. More filters, more accessories. I was trying to reduce risk by preparing for every possible situation. Instead, every wildlife sighting became an exercise in indecision. Rather than focusing on the elephant standing in front of me, I wondered whether I should switch lenses or prepare for the animal that might appear next.
Before my seventh trip, I made a decision that initially felt risky. I spent time thinking about the kinds of photographs I wanted to create, instead of trying to prepare for every possible opportunity. I packed just two lenses and two camera bodies, with one as a backup.
Some of my favorite wildlife images accompanied me home, including a photograph of an elephant at sunset.
Looking back, I see how removing unnecessary complexity didn’t add risk. I still had backup equipment, years of experience, and everything necessary if conditions changed.
In the boardroom
Years earlier, I watched the same principle play out in a boardroom. As part of SurePayroll’s founding management team, we launched what looked like the perfect customer acquisition campaign.
The “buck slips” were small, dollar-sized pieces of paper printed and inserted into mailed statements for small-business customers. We knew this would have a nearly 100% open rate, as everyone has to reconcile their bank statements—especially small business owners—so we had a perfect target audience.
Citibank agreed to include our offer inside 300,000 monthly statements. We hired temporary staff and added phone lines because we were confident the response would be overwhelming.
Out of 300,000 offers, we received three calls and one new customer.
Our cofounder shut the campaign down immediately. At the time, I thought we were giving up too quickly. Looking back, I realize that he understood our limits. As a startup, our scarcest resource was time, and continuing the campaign would have been expensive wishful thinking.
Both experiences taught me to ask a different question: What can we realistically absorb if this doesn’t work?
Over the years, I’ve noticed that same pattern across the organizations I’ve worked with. Teams struggle because they aren’t sure where they have permission to explore. When the boundaries around decision-making are unclear, caution becomes a rational response.
3 steps to lead with risk capacity
Risk tolerance concerns emotion, and asks whether people are comfortable with uncertainty. Risk capacity asks something different: Does the organization have the resources, clarity, and margin to absorb an experiment without creating unacceptable consequences? For leaders, risk capacity changes how new ideas are formed.
1. Define the frame: Focus on creativity with a clear objective, a handful of meaningful constraints, and a shared understanding of success.
2. Understand your organization’s capacity to learn from risks: Every organization has different financial, operational, and reputational margins. Pursue experiments whose upside justifies the downside.
3. Stop thinking of boundaries as barriers: With the right constraints, people no longer waste energy trying to interpret what leadership really wants and can devote energy to solving the problem in front of them.
I still travel to Africa with far less camera equipment than I once believed necessary, and consistently return with stronger photographs. The difference is that I’ve stopped preparing for every possibility and started focusing on what matters most.
Organizations innovate the same way, requiring leaders who define the frame clearly enough that people know exactly where they have room to explore.
Sheri Jacobs is a keynote speaker, an author, and CEO of Avenue M Group.