Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Build better email relationships with AI

Reclaim strategic time and provide improved experiences.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Cynthia Price

SVP of Marketing · Validity

For years, email has been a marketer’s workhorse for connecting with customers. It’s direct, personal, and reliable. But lately, it’s felt more like a numbers game. Inboxes are overloaded, engagement is harder to earn, and personalizing at scale feels out of reach.

With AI advancements, this could change. Marketers are using AI to create smarter, more relevant experiences rooted in context, personalization, and trust. Emails show up at the right time, say the right thing, and feel like they were meant for the person reading them.

Advanced AI adopters—companies that have deeply integrated AI into their email marketing workflows and decision-making—are 75% more likely to see email campaigns produce a $45-plus return on investment for every $1 spent, according to our Litmus from Validity State of Email 2026 report.

Yet these days, building relationships matters more than ROI. Here’s how to shift your email strategy from transactional to relational.

1. Use AI to reclaim time and transform strategy

When 76% of marketing teams are producing emails in three days or fewer, there’s often no time to do more than assemble and send. Teams skip testing and default to one-size-fits-all segmentation.  Personalization may stop at “Hi, [First Name],” while storytelling goes off the table.

AI can handle routine tasks alongside the team. This includes automating quality assurance, ensuring emails display correctly across devices and email apps, building smarter consumer segments, and generating content variations.

AI gives your team breathing room. The more space you have to focus on voice, message, and timing, the better your emails will perform. Your team can spend time refining what makes each message matter, while AI enables faster production and stronger connection.

2. Move from list management to understanding people

Traditional email personalization often includes only first names and location-based segments. But customers expect more, which AI makes possible.

Our report found that 37% of marketers expect AI to handle up to 25–50% of their email marketing operations by year’s end, with another 33% predicting AI will run 50–75% of operations. AI can analyze behavior in real time, personalize send times, and adapt content based on what someone does, not just who they are.

Think beyond segments. With AI, you can:

  • Trigger automated email sequences that change based on customer behavior
  • Personalize content in real time, from product recommendations to tone
  • Optimize send times around each subscriber’s habits

These tools let you move from campaign management to customer understanding, where relationship building starts to scale.

3. Trust starts with relevance

One of the biggest myths in AI marketing is that customers won’t trust machine-created content. The reality is more nuanced.

In a 2025 Litmus consumer survey, 39% of consumers said AI authorship wouldn’t change their level of trust, while 38% said they’d trust the brand less. But among millennials and Gen Z, 38% said they’d trust it more if they knew AI was involved.

The key is how you use the technology. AI should support your brand’s voice while allowing you to keep creative control. Use AI to handle the structure, timing, and targeting, so your team can focus on tone and substance. When AI helps you send more relevant, timely, and respectful messages, trust actually grows.

4. Reinforce the business case with smarter metrics

AI works as an inbox intermediary, deciding which emails to surface, in what order, and how to summarize their content. Our research shows this inflates open rates (the share of recipients who open an email) yet decreases click-throughs (the share who click a link inside the email). AI “opens” emails to summarize key details, leaving consumers less motivated to click through.

That means direct performance metrics no longer fully capture how email campaigns shape business outcomes and subscriber behavior. To justify further investments in email programs, start tracking:

  1. Retention and reengagement
  2. Email’s impact on customer lifetime value
  3. The added results that email drives in other channels (site visits, social, etc.).

When you start viewing email as part of a larger customer experience, the ROI expands and so does your strategy.

5. Look ahead and put AI to work

AI is already transforming how companies handle email. Our 2026 report found that 57% of companies already describe email marketing AI use as either moderate or advanced, while another 28% are exploring pilot use cases for AI. By 2027, 94% expect up to 75% of their email operations to involve AI in some form.

Teams are using AI to work more efficiently and connect more meaningfully to streamline production, refine personalization, and respond faster to what their audiences need.

More than just increasing volume, incorporating AI offers an opportunity to build a more agile, thoughtful, relevant email program that will grow with your customers and ensure your messages are worth opening for years to come.

Email’s human side is finally scalable

At its best, email provides subscribers with relevance and value. This outcome requires knowing your audience, respecting their time, and making every message feel like it was written just for them. That’s exactly where AI can help.

When used thoughtfully, AI reinforces the human side of email and gives marketers the tools to deliver timely, meaningful messages at scale without losing the personal touches that power lasting relationships. That’s the real ROI of email, where the trust, loyalty, and customer connection keep paying off long after the initial click.

Cynthia Price is the senior vice president of marketing at Validity.