At Luxury Presence, we manage over 50,000 websites and see more than 100 million consumer visits across those properties every year. We can see what’s actually happening in search, and we’re observing a shift most brands haven’t fully absorbed.
AI is rapidly gaining on search engines, with monthly sessions making up a little over half of search size worldwide. The businesses I talk to are, for the most part, still building their digital presence as if none of that is happening.
The mechanics are different
To understand why this matters, it helps to look at how the underlying behavior differs from traditional search. When someone searches on Google, they get ten or more results, and roughly 30% of those searches result in a click. The visitor arrives on your site still in research mode and comparing options, so you get meaningful traffic volumes but conversion rates that reflect an early-stage buyer.
When someone searches on ChatGPT, they typically get one response, maybe two. Often, the user stays entirely within ChatGPT, doing all their research inside the tool and synthesizing information without ever clicking through to a website.
When they do click through, they’ve already formed a view. The conversion rate on that traffic can be five to ten times higher than traditional search traffic. But the volume is dramatically lower, so whether you appear in AI search results carries much higher stakes than in Google results.
The conventional wisdom about platform shifts applies here. When there’s a meaningful change in how people find things, early movers capture a disproportionate share of the new landscape. The pattern is consistent: Go in early on a platform shift and reap compounding advantages that become very hard for later movers to overcome.
3 things that drive AI search citations
What actually determines whether a business gets cited by ChatGPT and similar tools? A few things are coming into focus.
1. Third-party validation carries more weight than owned content
ChatGPT heavily cites verified rankings, industry awards, and directory listings. When it recommends someone, it’s often because that person appears on recognized lists— such as trade publication rankings, verified directories, and industry awards—and not because they have a well-optimized website.
For most businesses, this means press and external recognition functions as a higher-value form of currency in AI search compared to traditional SEO.
2. AI cites surprising rates of community content on Reddit and review sites
AI tools surface and synthesize authentic forum-based conversations in ways that polished marketing content often isn’t. It’s worth reconsidering how most businesses spent years avoiding or ignoring these platforms as part of their content strategy.
3. AI offers a niche-specific path to visibility
When someone asks a general question, AI pulls from the most established, highest-authority sources. When they ask something specific, like the best solution for a particular type of buyer or the right vendor for a specific use case or geography, the brands that have built genuine niche authority get surfaced at a rate that’s disproportionate to their overall size.
Consumer behavior supports this too: The searches that benefit you most aren’t necessarily the broad ones. Someone asking who’s the best agent for athletes in their city, or who specializes in a specific type of transaction, represents a more qualified buyer than someone searching generically.
How businesses should prepare for AI search
Traditional search is still relevant. Ranking factors meaningfully overlap, and companies that invested in SEO start from a better position than those that didn’t.
But AI discoverability has additional layers that didn’t matter before, including how AI crawlers read your site’s technical structure, how your content is written to be scannable and citable rather than just readable, and how much your brand exists beyond your own website.
We’re seeing a fundamental tension across our customer base, where most businesses have optimized for a digital presence that made sense for Google. That optimization is increasingly incomplete for how AI-using consumers actually research and decide.
Updating for AI search requires actively building in places that previously felt optional, like third-party press, community presence, awards and rankings. Your content strategy should be designed around how AI tools actually synthesize and cite information.
Companies doing this work now are gaining visibility while acquisition costs are still relatively low and competition is sparser. That window has historically closed faster than people expect. Businesses that waited until SEO was fully mature found a much more crowded and expensive landscape than those that got in early. The same dynamic is playing out right now in AI search, compressed into a shorter timeframe.
Malte Kramer is the founder and CEO of Luxury Presence.