In the late 1990s, I was a young manager at Def Jam Recordings. The label was scrappy and still ran like the independent label that began in 1984, fighting for every inch in a business consolidating fast. Then came 1998, and a big swing.
We put DMX’s It’s Dark and Hell Is Hot out in the spring and Jay-Z’s Vol. 2… Hard Knock Life in the fall. Two flagship releases in one year, from a label our size, at a moment when we needed revenue. We believed in the records and decided to show up big rather than hedge. It paid off, and everything shifted in our direction.
Somewhere in that run, Lyor Cohen, then president of Def Jam and now global head of music at YouTube and Google, said something that stayed with me for almost 30 years: We want our unequal fair share.
I heard it as a rallying cry, and it worked like one. What took me a few more industries to understand is that it was never a slogan. It was a description of how economic growth works, said in a hallway years before I saw it written down.
Parity is a slow way to shrink
I spent the years after the music business in manufacturing, advertising and media, where fair share is not a feeling. It is arithmetic. If everyone selling what you sell takes in $1 billion a year and $100,000,000 of it is yours, your share of market is 10%. Your share of voice is your cut of what the category spends on advertising. Fair share means keeping the second number in line with the first, and every planning deck presents that as discipline.
The numbers here come from marketing because that is the field that measures what happens when those two numbers come apart. The principle is not a marketing one. Hold 10% of your category’s sales and 10% of its advertising and you are at parity. Hold 15% and you are above your weight.
That gap has a name, excess share of voice. Advertising and marketing pioneer John Philip Jones first laid out the relationship in Harvard Business Review in 1990. Marketing experts Les Binet and Peter Field later quantified it using the IPA databank: every ten points of excess share of voice predicts about half a point of market share growth a year. Nielsen and LinkedIn found the same ratio.
Now the outcome, which nobody says out loud in the budget meeting. If your share of voice merely equals your share of market, you have bought nothing. You have purchased the right to remain exactly the size you already are, while anyone spending above their weight takes ground from you.
Fair share is not the responsible middle. It is the setting at which you stand still.
Take the word advertising out and the shape holds. Headcount sized to last year’s headcount. A program funded in proportion to results the last funding decision allowed. The number gets set by the size of the thing rather than the opportunity. We were small at Def Jam, and small was what we could not afford to be.
Sized before you sat down
Here is where I have taken Lyor’s idea somewhere he probably did not intend. All of it assumes you know your share of the market. Brands do. People often do not, and organizations building something that has not existed before certainly do not.
In every industry I have entered, I have been the first Black woman to sit in the senior chair I was hired into, and so far, the only one. That is four now: recorded music, manufacturing, advertising, and media. Each time, a model already existed for how much attention, budget, and runway someone in that seat should get. And each time, that model had been built out of a history that had never included anyone like me, for the simple reason that it could not.
That is rarely unfair by intent. It is precedent doing what precedent does. But the effect compounds. When you are the first, your share of the market is not a measured fact. It is an estimate made from the closest thing anyone had seen. Your allocation gets sized to it, your results judged against it, and if you deliver, you have proven the estimate correct and funded it again next year. That is how a seat, a business unit, or an audience gets held at the size somebody once assumed. Not through hostility but through a formula running correctly on unquestioned inputs.
Which is why I have never been satisfied with a piece of the pie, and I offer that as a habit rather than a virtue. In the music business I took on the entire roster rather than work only urban music. When I saw how easily one industry can pigeonhole a career, I went into four. And now I am in media, working to change how the industry classifies growth audiences. None of those was about a bigger slice inside the lines. Each was a refusal to accept the lines.
The invitation
The world feels upside down right now, and the instinct in a hard year is to protect everything a little. Hold the line, wait for conditions to improve. I have felt it too. It also produces exactly what the research predicts. At this moment your competitors are making the same choice and one of them will not. Which is what makes a downturn the cheapest time to buy an unequal fair share.
So here is what I would ask you to look at this quarter. Find the place where you are accepting an allocation calculated before you got there. A budget line. An audience your model still treats as a segment. Your own career, and how much room you have decided you are allowed.
Then ask a better question than how do I get my fair share. Ask who built the estimate you are sized against, what they had to work with, and what you would have to prove to change it. It is the only question I have seen move anything.
Almost 30 years later, I am still working on mine.
Amani Duncan is CEO of My Code Media.