Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The competitive advantage hiding in plain sight

How building in public earns valuable trust.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Mack McKelvey

Founder & CEO · SalientMG and The Credentialed

Creating a company in stealth mode used to be a badge of honor. Now, it’s just a cozy place to hide unvetted assumptions.

Artificial intelligence has changed the economics of building companies. Ideas and content are abundant, software development is accelerating, and execution alone is becoming less of a differentiator. What isn’t becoming easier is earning genuine trust. People still buy from founders they believe in. They join communities where they feel heard. And they advocate for companies that show them their input matters.

Those qualities can’t be generated with a prompt. They must be earned. That may be the real advantage of building in public: You’re not just building in front of people. You’re building with them.

That’s why we made a conscious decision to build in public. We’re creating an ecosystem for marketers at startups and scaleups, with the community, resources, and expertise they need to do their jobs. And we’re building it with them.

Our members don’t just see the finished features. They see the roadmap, the experiments, the pivots—and the mistakes, too. So far, members have challenged our priorities, changed how we think about features, introduced us to partners, volunteered to lead sessions, and helped us see what they need faster than we could have figured out on our own.

That’s the obvious benefit of building in public: You shorten the distance between hypothesis and proof. But something else happened along the way. The more we let our members into the process, the more invested they became in what we were building. They stopped feeling like an audience for the product and started acting like participants in it.

TRUST STARTS BEFORE THE PRODUCT IS FINISHED

Research shows consumers consider trust in a brand just as important as its products, services, quality, or value. Trust isn’t a byproduct of success. It’s a prerequisite for it.

One of the biggest objections I hear to building in public is simple: What happens when people see something unfinished? They will. And sometimes, they won’t like it.

But customers are often more forgiving of imperfection than companies expect. What frustrates them is surprise. When expectations don’t match reality and customers don’t understand why something changed, trust erodes.

Transparency changes that dynamic. When customers see what you’re working toward, why a feature was delayed, why priorities changed, or what you learned when something didn’t work, they can see the progress, not just the gaps. More importantly, they can see whether you listen. When someone tells you what isn’t working and then sees that feedback reflected in what you build next, you’ve demonstrated that their input matters.

COMMUNITY COMPOUNDS FASTER THAN FEATURES

Every startup is chasing product-market fit. I think more of them should be thinking about community-market fit.

Features can be copied. Pricing can be undercut. AI is making it easier than ever to replicate functionality. But communities are different. They’re built one conversation, one interaction, and one shared experience at a time. Founders who invite customers into the process early enough to have meaningful influence create something competitors cannot easily replicate: a sense of ownership over what they helped shape.

That changes the relationship. Customers aren’t simply evaluating what you’ve built for them. They’re helping you determine what should be built next. They become a continuous feedback loop, a source of ideas, and, eventually, advocates for the company.

We’ve experienced this firsthand. Our members are engaged not because everything is finished or perfect, but because they know they have a role in where it goes next. People support what they help create. As building features get faster and cheaper, that kind of emotional investment may become the real competitive advantage.

WHY BUILDING IN PUBLIC ISN’T FOR EVERYONE

There are good reasons to keep some things behind closed doors. Discretion matters if you’re protecting genuine intellectual property, navigating regulatory requirements, or handling confidential information.

But for most startups, there’s a lot of room between operating in stealth and putting every internal decision on display. The goal isn’t radical transparency. It’s giving customers enough visibility to contribute while you still have time to act on what they tell you.

Before deciding what to keep behind closed doors, ask yourself whether the secrecy is helping you build a better company.

THREE QUESTIONS FOUNDERS SHOULD ASK

If you’re considering building in public, start with three questions.

1. Are you building for your customers or with them? If customers rarely influence your roadmap, you may be missing one of your greatest sources of competitive intelligence.

2. Is secrecy protecting your intellectual property or your assumptions? Protect proprietary technology, confidential information, and genuine competitive advantages, but don’t confuse secrecy with strategy.

3. Are you optimizing for perfection or momentum? Companies that succeed aren’t necessarily the ones that get everything right before launch. They’re often the ones that learn fastest. Building in public compresses the feedback loop and gives you an opportunity to create advocates before the product is finished.


GIVE PEOPLE A REASON TO CARE

    We’re still building. Some members joined before key features existed. Others have watched us change direction entirely because the community challenged our assumptions. The product is better because of it. And so is the community.

    You can build behind closed doors and hope people care when you’re ready. Or you can give them a reason to care from the start.

    Mack McKelvey is founder and CEO of SalientMG and The Credentialed.