Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The metrics that built digital advertising won’t build its future

We've been giving impressions too much credit

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Tim Vanderhook

CEO, Co-Founder & Chairman · Viant Technology

Advertising is entering its biggest transformation since the internet. Not because artificial intelligence is replacing marketers, but because it’s forcing the industry to confront a simple question: Have we been optimizing for the wrong thing?

For years, advertising rewarded what was easiest to measure. We counted impressions because they were easy to count. We optimized for clicks because they were easy to attribute. But neither answers the question every marketer ultimately cares about: Did this campaign influence someone?

THE PROBLEM WITH IMPRESSIONS

Imagine if a retailer judged every store by how many people walked by, without asking whether anyone came through the door, browsed, bought, or even noticed the merchandise. We’d never accept that standard anywhere else in business, yet we’ve built billions of dollars in advertising around it.

That matters even more in the age of AI. Artificial intelligence doesn’t decide what success looks like. It simply gets better at optimizing whatever signal we give it. If we continue training AI to maximize impressions and last-click attribution, we’ll simply automate yesterday’s mistakes at unprecedented speed.

The opportunity now is much bigger. For the first time, marketers can optimize around attention—the missing link between media delivery and business outcomes. Attention doesn’t replace impressions. It adds the layer we’ve been missing all along: It’s evidence that someone actually engaged with the advertising they were served.

Nowhere is that shift more important than television. For decades, TV has been advertising’s most powerful storytelling medium. It combines sight, sound, and motion on the largest screen in the home to build memory, emotion, and long-term brand preference.

With the emergence of attention metrics, TV’s brand-building potential becomes even more measurable and actionable. Here’s how attention is reshaping television advertising—and why it matters for marketers.

ATTENTION CHANGES WHAT WE KNOW

The most exciting thing about attention is that it challenges assumptions we’ve held for years.

Recent research TVision, a Viant Technology company which measures second-by-second viewer engagement across linear and connected TV, reveals how profoundly context influences advertising effectiveness. It found the same Subaru creative generated an attention index of 131 during reality and home improvement programming, compared with just 81 during crime drama programming. TVision defines attention index as a measure of how much of the content is spent with eyes on screen. 100 is the benchmark for linear TV and connected TV.

Placement matters, too. Ads that run in the first position of a commercial pod consistently generate higher attention than those appearing in the middle or at the end. Across every daypart measured, premium streaming services also generated stronger viewer attention than YouTube.

The takeaway is clear: Creative doesn’t perform the same across every genre, timeslot, or advertising pod. The environment in which it’s experienced is part of its effectiveness, and today, we can finally quantify that impact. The difference between impressions and engagement is increasingly where advertising value lives.

THE BEST MARKETING BOTH CAPTURES AND CREATES DEMAND

I’ve long argued that demand generation and demand capture aren’t competing strategies. They’re complementary ones. One creates future customers. The other converts current, in-market customers. Sustainable growth requires both.

We’re already seeing leading marketers embrace this shift. As The Wall Street Journal recently reported, 1-800-Flowers is reinvesting in its brand after recognizing that long-term growth requires more than optimizing for conversions. CEO Adolfo Villagomez acknowledged that the company had been “buying transactions for $40 and making $20,” a realization that prompted a broader rethink of its marketing strategy. As he put it, “The most important asset we have, it’s our brand. And unfortunately, we hadn’t invested in the brand for a while. We are reversing that.”

It’s a powerful reminder that the strongest marketing strategies don’t optimize for the next transaction—they invest in the next customer. Better measurement gives marketers the confidence to do both.

ATTENTION WILL DRIVE TELEVISION’S NEXT ERA

Television has always excelled at building brands. What the industry lacked was a way to distinguish ads that were merely delivered from those that truly captured attention. Attention provides that missing signal, enabling marketers to optimize creative, placements, and media investment based on how audiences respond, not simply whether an ad was served.

The next generation of marketers won’t optimize for impressions alone. They’ll optimize for attention. In doing so, they’ll build stronger brands, create more effective advertising, and generate more value from every media dollar they spend.

Television isn’t changing. The way we value it is.

Tim Vanderhook is CEO and co-founder of Viant Technology.