For many years, supply chain integrity was viewed primarily through a sustainability or compliance lens. Today, it sits at the intersection of enterprise risk, market access, brand reputation, and long-term growth. As regulatory expectations increase and global sourcing becomes more complex, boards are increasingly being asked not just what they know about their supply chains, but how confidently they can substantiate it.
Oritain’s 2026 Supply Chain Intelligence Report found that 87% of U.S. companies and 94% of U.K. companies now trace their cotton supply chains. Yet the proportion of brands with at least one garment containing cotton consistent with prohibited-origin exposure increased from 64% in 2024 to 90% in 2025.
The paradox is clear: Organizations are becoming better at documenting their supply chains, but not necessarily better at proving the integrity of the products moving through them. Rather than signaling a failure of transparency, these findings highlight why traceability alone is no longer enough. Visibility into a supply chain is valuable, but visibility without verification can leave organizations relying on assumptions rather than evidence. Increasingly, boards need confidence not only in where products are expected to come from, but in their ability to substantiate those claims when challenged.
With less than 16 months until the EU Forced Labour Regulation becomes applicable, many organizations are focused on compliance readiness. But the bigger opportunity is to create the governance structures, behaviors, and culture that enable risks to be surfaced, discussed, and managed proactively before they become material business issues.
THE VISIBILITY PARADOX
Organizations know more about their supply chains today than they did five years ago. Yet visibility does not always translate into certainty. McKinsey’s latest supply chain risk research found that while 95% of organizations report visibility into tier-one supplier risks, only 42% report visibility beyond tier two, where many origin and sourcing risks emerge.
The distinction between traceability and verification becomes critical in this context. Traceability helps organizations understand where products are believed to have come from. Verification helps establish whether products are what they claim to be.
THE FEAR BARRIER RARELY DISCUSSED
An issue remains that many leaders recognize privately but few discuss openly: The closer organizations look, the greater the possibility they may uncover something they were not expecting to find. That unspoken fear can create hesitation because transparency demands responsibility. Once an issue is identified, action is expected.
This is where boards play an important leadership role, because supply chain integrity was never going to be achieved through perfect knowledge. The objective is to create an environment where risks can be surfaced early and managed proactively.
Boards set the tone for how organizations respond to uncertainty. Organizations that view vulnerabilities as opportunities to strengthen the business are ultimately better positioned to address them. The most progressive boards recognize that their role is not simply to oversee compliance, but to create the conditions in which transparency can flourish.
WHY THIS HAS BECOME A BOARD-LEVEL ISSUE
This fear barrier can carry material consequences in today’s regulatory environment. U.S. Customs and Border Protection has stopped more than 43,000 shipments worth $4.12 billion under forced-labor enforcement measures. The investigations by the Office of the United States Trade Representative into 60 trading partners under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 introduced an updated tariff landscape for the investigated economies. Meanwhile, the Department of Justice recovered more than $6.8 billion through False Claims Act settlements and judgments during fiscal year 2025, with trade fraud emerging as a growing area of enforcement focus.
Accountability is increasingly extending beyond the organization itself. Across multiple regulatory regimes, enforcement trends are placing greater scrutiny on directors’ and executives’ oversight responsibilities. This makes it harder for supply chain risks to be viewed as issues that can simply be delegated elsewhere in the business. In trade fraud cases brought under the False Claims Act, scrutiny can extend beyond operational teams to the leadership oversight of, and evidence underpinning, declarations made to government authorities. Many cases originate from whistleblowers inside the organization.
As expectations around due diligence, disclosure, and supply chain governance continue to evolve, boards are being asked to evaluate not only the assurances they receive, but the evidence that underpins them. Supply chain integrity is no longer just a compliance issue. It is increasingly tied to strategic decision-making and business resilience.
EVIDENCE SHOULD GUIDE DECISIONS
Supplier declarations, certifications, and digital traceability systems remain important parts of modern compliance frameworks. Yet our research found that 84% of U.K. companies continue to rely on supplier declarations as part of their traceability approach.
The question for boards is not whether documentation exists. It is whether the evidence available would support timely and defensible decision-making if assumptions were challenged.
Recent enforcement actions demonstrate how quickly origin claims, sourcing practices, and supplier representations can become legal, commercial, and reputational issues. Cases such as Boise Cascade, where a major timber supplier faced criminal penalties linked to the sourcing and importation of plywood that had been misrepresented within the supply chain, illustrate the consequences when gaps emerge between what organizations believe to be true and what can ultimately be substantiated. More importantly, they highlight the value of fostering the right culture and behaviors to identify issues before someone else does.
THE OPPORTUNITY AHEAD
While some organizations are building supply chains grounded in independently verifiable evidence, many have yet to take the first step. Across industries, leading brands, manufacturers, and suppliers are investing in programmatic verification and participating in networks built on trust. They are proving that transparency is not a barrier to commercial success. Instead, better visibility is enabling them to understand risk earlier, make more informed decisions and respond with greater confidence when scrutiny arises.
Ultimately, supply chain integrity is not about proving perfection. It is about creating organizations where risks can be surfaced without fear, evidence informs better decisions, and continuous improvement is viewed as a strength.
Organizations that embrace that mindset are unlikely to be the ones struggling with the future of supply chain transparency. They are far more likely to help define it.
Alyn Franklin is CEO of Oritain