A credit report tells lenders how someone has handled credit in the past. But what happens when there is not much history to review?
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) estimates that 7 million consumers are credit invisible, or have no credit record at all. Another 30 million have what’s called an unscored credit record—an insufficient credit history to have a credit score.
According to an older CFPB report, consumers most likely to be credit invisible are younger, lower-income, Black, or Hispanic.
While some of these borrowers may actually be risky, others may simply be difficult to assess with the limited information available. The goal should be to ensure lenders have enough relevant information to understand the individual behind the application and expand access for those who could qualify.
A credit score cannot evaluate information it never receives
Traditional credit data has long been the baseline for predicting repayment risk using a consumer credit bureau-documented payment history, outstanding debt, account age, and previous borrowing behavior.
The limitation appears when there is little history to analyze. Someone may pay rent and household bills consistently for years without building much credit history. Another borrower may manage money responsibly but have used very little formal credit.
I see the same challenge in underwriting tech infrastructure: Where else can a credit-risk team look besides credit history to make an informed decision about potential risks? My company builds tools in this space, and I think that’s where alternative data can help.
Federal regulators recognized this potential in their 2019 interagency statement on alternative-data underwriting. The agencies were aware of firms expanding the use of data to evaluate a borrower’s income and expense activities and ability to meet new credit obligations. This approach can help lenders assess people receiving income from several sources.
Evidence has grown since then, including on the reinforcing cycle of credit access and financial challenges.
In 2023, CFPB researchers found that indicators such as overdrafts and nonsufficient funds (NSF) fees correlate with lower credit scores. In turn, these fees may reflect a lack of access to credit.
5 alternative data sources that can add context
Not every alternative signal deserves the same weight, an October 2025 Federal Reserve report noted. The strongest candidates have a logical relationship with someone’s ability to meet financial obligations. Financial alternative data usually relies on signals from deposit-account information or household income and expenses.
1. Cash-flow transaction patterns
Money leaving a bank account can show how someone manages current financial obligations and may include discretionary spending and small-business sales and expenses.
The Federal Reserve described transaction-level cash-flow data as one of the most promising areas for responsible alternative-data underwriting.
2. Summary deposit-account history
At a higher level, the Federal Reserve noted that averages and broader patterns in account activity—such as regular deposits, average balances, and balance changes—can help describe someone’s financial position over time.
The Federal Reserve draws direct parallels between summary measures and familiar credit-score components. For example, instead of payment history for unpaid bills, a creditor could look at an applicant’s overdraft history. Instead of credit history length, they could review the account’s tenure. Average balances and deposits can add context around available resources.
3. Income from multiple sources
Bank financial data can help demonstrate reliable income streams from various sources, as noted by the Federal Reserve.
A traditional employment record doesn’t describe every way people earn money. Freelancers, contractors, gig workers, and people combining several income sources may look less predictable on paper. Alternative income streams can help applicants whose earnings are real but don’t show up in a traditional employment record.
4. Rent payment history
Rent is often one of a household’s largest recurring obligations. A record of consistent payments can therefore add useful context for someone with little conventional borrowing history. It gives the lender another piece of relevant financial behavior to evaluate, along with the cash flow available to repay a loan.
According to a 2022 Urban Institute and FinRegLab report, even when rental payments are reflected in a consumer’s credit history, most common credit scoring models don’t account for that information.
5. Utility and telecom payments
Electricity, internet, and phone bills can also show how someone handles recurring commitments. Only an estimated 2% to 5% of consumers making utility and rental payments have that data appearing in their credit bureau files, according to the same 2022 report.
The future of credit access
In my opinion, lenders shouldn’t treat these as substitutes for conventional credit history. But where reliable payment information is available, it can help fill an otherwise sparse file. The principle is simple: Actual payment behavior is generally more meaningful than inferences about financial responsibility from unrelated lifestyle data.
Alternative data gives lenders more information for lending qualification. The infrastructure around permissioned financial data is still evolving as the regulatory debate continues, but good underwriting doesn’t depend on how that debate ends. When traditional credit data tells only part of the story, relevant and permissioned financial information can provide another part.
For some borrowers, that extra context may be the difference between appearing unscorable and being understood.
Artem Lalaiants is the CEO and cofounder at RiskSeal.