Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The energy behind engagement

Organizations attempt to solve the wrong problem.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Andrew Deutscher

Founder · Regenerate

The 2016 book Play Bigger offers a helpful approach for thinking about market problems. Every successful product or service solves one of two challenges. Either people know they have a problem but don’t know how to solve it, or they don’t yet realize the problem exists until someone helps them see it.

For decades, organizations have invested hundreds of billions of dollars globally, trying to resolve the first type when improving employee engagement. We’ve introduced recognition programs, redesigned performance reviews, expanded well-being offerings, and surveyed employees with increasing sophistication. Yet engagement remains frustratingly difficult to improve and even harder to sustain.

This raises the question: What if engagement isn’t actually the problem to solve? Engagement is often defined as an employee’s willingness to invest discretionary effort. Familiar ingredients include connection to meaningful work, positive relationships, opportunities to learn, psychological safety, and a sense that one’s contributions matter.

These vital ingredients depend on something else—energy.

Discretionary effort requires discretionary energy

Discretionary effort depends on capacity, which I’ve experienced personally.

Several years ago, my life was slipping away. I was traveling 45 weeks per year, trying to stay ahead of the pace of change and remain relevant in a tightening media landscape. Stress pervaded my life. I worked out less, ate more, got less sleep and became further disconnected from myself and my family.

You can’t consistently ask depleted people for discretionary effort. Without physical, emotional, and mental energy to support purpose, cognitive overload crowds out creativity. Emotional exhaustion diminishes collaboration. Stress narrows attention toward immediate, low-risk tasks rather than meaningful, high-value work.

We’ve all experienced this ourselves. When energy declines, we become less able to access our highest level of capability. The human brain begins to conserve resources. We default toward checking email, reacting, multitasking, and completing what’s easy rather than what’s most important.

Why performance needs energy

I believe framing “energy as part of employee wellbeing” unintentionally limits its strategic importance. Organizations care about outcomes such as innovation, collaboration, decision quality, customer experience, safety, resilience, adaptability, and engagement. These all depend on the physical, emotional, and mental capacity people bring to their work each day.

Willis Towers Watson’s Power of Three research found that high-performance organizations engage, enable, and energize employees. Engagement reflects willingness, or an attitude of caring and motivation to progress important work. Enablement creates the conditions to perform. Energy provides the readiness to sustain both.

Companies that combine all three dramatically outperform engagement-only organizations because they recognize that people cannot sustain what they don’t have the capacity to give.

The conversation executives should have

If you’re an executive leader, ensure both the willingness and readiness of your people. If you have an ability problem, that’s an entirely different problem and won’t be solved with greater energy.

Readiness asks a different question: “Do my people have the capacity to consistently perform at the level the business requires?”

Different priorities emerge when leaders begin asking that question, with the objective of helping your people consistently show up at their best. That requires building the knowledge, mindsets, and recovery practices that expand capacity over time.

Energy consumption and renewal

Leaders must intentionally cultivate an energy mindset where value creation stems from energy, not just hours worked.  

It’s a human non-negotiable that if you spend energy, you must recover it. I’ve seen workplace drains on human energy that include:

  • Unsustainable work expectations
  • Uncaring leadership
  • Lack of flexibility
  • Lack of meaningful work
  • Insufficient support
  • Poor psychological safety

While leaders often assume people leave an employer because they’ve become disengaged or disillusioned, I’ve seen them leave due to sheer exhaustion—physical, emotional, or mental.

Like a sprinter, when you are engaged, be fully engaged. When you disconnect, be truly disconnected. We often live in grey zones, rarely giving our attention to one thing.

A different starting point

If we’re serious about improving engagement, both the research and common sense point to the same conclusion. Engagement is best understood as an outcome. Energy creates readiness, readiness makes sustained engagement possible, and sustained engagement drives performance.

When leaders understand that sequence, the conversation changes, and they begin asking what enables and energizes people to consistently bring their best.

That’s a fundamentally different leadership challenge. In my next article, I’ll explore why leadership shapes the energetic conditions in which people perform. Because once we understand that energy creates readiness, an important question emerges: How much energy does your leadership create—or consume?

Andrew Deutscher is the founder of Regenerate.