Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Ask 6 questions before you sign up for reputation management

The billion-dollar reputation management industry attracts all types, so investigate first.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Darius Fisher

Chairman of Millbrook Companies, CEO & Co-Founder of Status Labs, Co-Founder and Managing Partner of BLP, Co-Founder of Sensei Advisory · Status Labs

The reputation-management industry has grown significantly. The global online reputation management market (services and software) is projected to hit $14 billion by 2031. That growth has attracted both genuinely capable agencies and vendors whose primary skill is selling, not delivering. Knowing the difference before you sign matters.

After 13 years and more than 1,000 client engagements, we know the questions that separate a capable reputation management firm from one that takes your money and underdelivers.

6 questions to ask before you hire a reputation management firm

Before meeting with a reputation management firm’s sales team, it’s important to prepare questions that will ensure your needs, vision, business ethics, and methodology align with the firm’s. Though initial meetings may vary, you can expect to meet with members of the firm’s sales team, technical staff, or leadership.

Clear at least 30 minutes for an introductory or discovery call. Nuanced or complex situations may warrant more time for additional exploration, to ensure you receive a well-discussed, tailored plan you feel confident pursuing (or not). 

1. Which publications will my content appear in?

The most revealing question on the list is the one that most agencies deflect. Ask them to name actual publications, not categories like “tier-two business sites” or “high-authority news outlets.”

Ask which publications, specifically, may carry content about you or your brand. Are there any friendly publisher relationships that the firm intends to leverage? What will content outreach look like on my behalf?

Domain authority and editorial credibility give some content the ranking power to displace negative results in search. A firm that can’t name specific publications either doesn’t have those relationships or produces content that doesn’t meet a publication’s editorial standards. Either answer tells you something important.

Any firm presenting itself as a full-service reputation management agency in 2026 needs a real answer to this question, not a vague “optimizing for AI” or “staying current with search trends” reply. 

Ask specifically: How do you monitor what ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity say about my brand? What content and distribution strategy do you use to influence those AI tools? How do you measure improvement in AI representation over time?

A firm with a real AI reputation capability answers these questions without hesitation, highlighting a breadth of knowledge and experience utilizing analysis tools, research data, and available technology partners. A firm without it will pivot to talking about traditional SEO. The pivot is your answer.

3. What do you guarantee within realistic timelines?

Here, bad agencies reveal themselves. Our experience shows that most well-executed programs produce tangible results—such as movement in how an entity ranks on a search engine results page or increased visibility across AI results, for example—within 6 to 12 months.

Displacing a high-authority negative result could require 12 months or longer, particularly if they have strong backlink profiles (the unique domains or outlets that link back to an original source article via their own content). Some highly touted outlets can take a long time to displace, especially when paired with a volatile search term or high monthly search volume for a particular query.

Any agency promising you’ll no longer appear on page one of search results in 30 or 60 days is not being honest with you. Some tactics may displace results quickly, but they rarely hold, given how the win was approached in the first place.

Legitimate reputation management guarantees rely on the vendor’s effort, transparency, and reporting quality, not specific ranking outcomes. Many factors outside any agency’s direct control influence rankings. An agency guaranteeing specific outcomes is either naive about how search works or comfortable making promises it can’t keep.

4. How do you ensure your review programs are Federal Trade Commission compliant?

The FTC’s 2024 final rule on consumer reviews and testimonials prohibits fake reviews, AI-generated fake reviews, and incentivized reviews without disclosure, with civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation. If a firm’s review program involves any of these practices, it could create federal legal exposure for you and for the firm.

Ask this question directly. A legitimate firm answers immediately and specifically, while deflection or vagueness is a red flag.

5. Can you show me case studies from situations like mine?

Experienced firms have case studies, even if they anonymize client identities. They can describe the situation types, including executive reputation, brand crisis, and negative press from a specific publication type. Then they can describe the strategy the agency used, the timeline, and the measured outcome.

Ask for real references. Then call them.

6. Will you ask me detailed questions?

Any firm that quotes a price or proposes a strategy before fully understanding your situation shouldn’t be offering a solution. They first need to research the search landscape, the authority of any negative sources, and the affected platforms. Otherwise, they’re selling you a package, not a solution.

What the answers tell you

These six questions don’t require you to understand search engines or AI algorithms. They require the firm to be specific about publications, timelines, compliance, and your particular situation. A capable firm will welcome questions such as these.

Darius Fisher is the cofounder of Status Labs.