Quantum computing is coming. Cybersecurity leaders are wondering when it’s coming, and perhaps more importantly, what they should be doing about it today.
Every few months, another story appears warning that quantum computers could break the encryption protecting corporate data. More recently, there have been discussions about ransomware operators using quantum-safe encryption. That sounds alarming. It also deserves some perspective.
For most organizations, the immediate risk from ransomware has little to do with quantum computing. There are more practical concerns that deserve attention today.
THE QUANTUM RANSOMWARE QUESTION
Imagine a ransomware attacker encrypting a company’s files with an encryption algorithm designed to withstand a future quantum computer. At first glance, that sounds like a major advancement in ransomware. But what does it actually accomplish? For the average company, probably very little.
A sufficiently powerful quantum computer could eventually threaten some of today’s encryption algorithms. However, practical quantum computing capable of breaking widely deployed encryption remains a significant technological challenge. The machines developed today are nowhere near the scale, reliability, and error correction required for many of the attacks people are discussing. That changes the economics of the ransomware problem.
If a criminal can already encrypt a company’s files using conventional encryption that the company cannot realistically break, adding quantum resistance does not provide much additional leverage. The victim is facing a computationally impractical decryption problem. In other words, quantum-safe ransomware may sound futuristic, but the underlying ransomware problem is very real at present.
Most organizations should be concerned with whether the attacker can encrypt the data, and whether the organization can recover it.
PROTECT THE DATA NOW
There is, however, a very good reason for corporations to start thinking about quantum-resistant encryption now. That’s because the data needs to remain protected for years or decades.
Consider a company holding intellectual property, financial records, engineering designs, customer information, government contracts, or other sensitive information. An attacker does not necessarily need to decrypt that information today. They can steal it today and attempt to decrypt it later.
This is sometimes described as a harvest now, decrypt later strategy. An attacker collects encrypted information while current encryption is still considered secure, stores it, and waits for technology to advance. That creates a very different problem.
A company should understand how long its data needs to remain confidential. If the answer is five years, 10 years, 20 years, or longer, quantum-resistant cryptography becomes much more relevant.
This is especially important for large organizations and governments that manage valuable information with long-term strategic value. The attacker trying to obtain that information may not be a ransomware criminal operating from a laptop. It could be a sophisticated criminal organization, a competitor, or even a foreign government. You may never know who is interested in your data.
That is a good reason to begin planning a transition to post-quantum cryptography where appropriate. It means understanding where cryptography is being used, which algorithms are in place, how long protected information must remain confidential, and how difficult those systems will be to replace.
THE BIGGER QUANTUM CYBERSECURITY PROBLEM
Another quantum issue deserves more attention than ransomware: authentication. Many organizations think about encryption primarily as a way to protect data from being read. Public key cryptography also plays a critical role in proving identity and establishing trust.
Digital certificates, secure connections, software signing, authentication systems, and other modern infrastructure components can depend on public key algorithms that may eventually be vulnerable to sufficiently capable quantum computers. That means the quantum transition is much bigger than changing the algorithm used to encrypt a file.
Organizations may eventually need to examine how devices identify themselves, how software proves that it is legitimate, how systems establish secure connections, and how certificates and cryptographic keys are managed. That is a much more complicated problem.
It also creates an important cybersecurity lesson. Sometimes the greatest risk from a new technology is the infrastructure surrounding the attack.
PROTECT DATA BASED ON HOW IT IS ACCESSED
There’s a more practical approach that has nothing to do with quantum computing. Instead of relying exclusively on encryption, organizations can look at controlling how protected data is accessed. Traditional access control generally considers who is requesting the data, whether an administrator or an employee. Then understand whether that user has permission.
This is important, but may not be enough. An attacker using stolen credentials may appear to be the legitimate user; a traditional access control system can think everything looks normal.
What needs further examination is how the data is being accessed. Is the application accessing the file the way it is supposed to? Is the data being accessed via the application’s user interface? Is the data being accessed in a way that only the local user can?
Adding context around the access method provides another protection layer.
Most importantly, this approach does not depend on whether the attacker is using a conventional computer, a quantum computer, AI, or a technology not yet invented.
Ransomware does not need a quantum computer to cause enormous damage. Attackers already have legitimate credentials, stolen identities, malicious applications, and techniques for abusing trusted systems.
The best strategy is to build layers of protection that remain useful regardless of how computing technology evolves. The future of computing is difficult to predict. The need to protect valuable data is much easier to understand.
That is a problem worth solving now.
Elisha Riedlinger is COO at NeuShield.