Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why community marketing deserves its own return metric

How to make the case to finance.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Kourtney Barnes

Vice President of Marketing · Bettermode

Every marketing leader knows the familiar tension of budget season. We walk into executive reviews armed with hard metrics for nearly every line item. We have return on ad spend to justify paid acquisition, and customer acquisition cost to prove growth efficiency. Yet, the moment the conversation turns to brand or community investments, that operational rigor abruptly vanishes, replaced by soft, abstract territory.

For years, community marketing teams have fallen into a predictable reporting trap, pointing to active users, comment threads, reply rates, and member growth on internal dashboards as key performance indicators. While directionally helpful for day-to-day engagement, those metrics fall flat in a board meeting or before a typical chief financial officer. Finance leaders do not care about engagement for engagement’s sake—and frankly, they shouldn’t.

When a program is evaluated strictly through qualitative, feel-good indicators, it inevitably gets categorized as a corporate nice-to-have rather than a business driver. In volatile economic environments, nice-to-haves are always the first programs cut. To defend, scale, and mature our strategy, we must establish community marketing as a recognized, measurable discipline by giving it a dedicated financial framework: return on community spend, or ROCS.

THE TRUTH WHISPERED BEHIND CLOSED DOORS

Throughout my career, I’ve sat down with numerous long-time customers over dinner and asked point-blank why they ultimately chose our platform. As a marketer, a small part of me always hopes to hear them credit a brilliant ad campaign or brand launch. But almost without exception, the real answer is far simpler: A peer they trusted recommended it, or they saw another customer solving their exact problem inside a community space.

That realization highlights the heavy lifting that community marketing performs behind the scenes. Modern B2B buyers are deeply skeptical of corporate marketing claims, but they do trust people. Industry data reflects this evolution: In fact, 72% of B2B marketing leaders rank word-of-mouth as the primary influence on vendor consideration. When prospective buyers watch real peers celebrate wins, share workflows, and solve hurdles in public, it creates an authentic track record no campaign can buy. So it is time to consider carefully how we translate this peer-driven credibility into scalable growth to efficiently allocate our go-to-market capital.

FROM RENTED AUDIENCES TO OWNED ADVANTAGE

As paid acquisition costs escalate and search habits move toward zero-click AI answer engines, relying exclusively on rented distribution channels becomes an increasingly risky strategy. Community marketing provides an owned, on-domain platform where trust scales naturally through authentic peer connection.

Traditional marketing relies heavily on one-to-many channels like ads and email. These scale reach effectively but lack credibility because buyers know the vendor wrote the copy. On the other end of the spectrum, one-to-one interactions—like direct sales calls—build deep trust. But expanding those efforts requires adding expensive headcount.

A branded community bridges this gap through a many-to-many model, where every resolved thread becomes permanent, indexable social proof that keeps working long after it is posted. Listening to member conversations also unlocks unprompted customer intelligence that can be fed straight back into paid copy and content, multiplying performance across every channel.

MEASURE WHAT FINANCE RESPECTS

To move community marketing from qualitative engagement to line-item accountability, its underlying data must integrate directly into the core customer relationship management systems your revenue teams rely on daily. If community insights remain trapped in a standalone tool, revenue leaders will simply overlook them. That’s why as my team at Bettermode and I prepare to launch our own customer community, Be Better, we made this structural connection our absolute top priority: integrating peer interactions directly with CRM account records in HubSpot and Salesforce to measure business outcomes rather than surface-level likes.

This structural alignment introduces a vital framework for revenue teams. Marketers routinely track marketing-qualified leads and sales-qualified leads to define pipeline progression. It is time we give equal weight to the community-qualified lead. When a prospect actively educates themselves within a peer-to-peer, ask-and-answer ecosystem before ever hopping on a sales call, they demonstrate clear buying intent.

In practice, bringing community touchpoints into standard CRM reporting exposes a clear economic return. A robust ROCS model captures direct returns—like faster deal velocity and higher renewal rates, and compounding returns—like lower acquisition costs and organic AI search visibility. Replacing subjective assertions with concrete velocity data hands finance leaders an equation they can underwrite.

BRING FOCUS TO A COMPOUNDING GROWTH ENGINE

Evaluating enterprise impact reveals that a thriving community network can support a multitude of go-to-market functions—from feeding the content engine and driving brand advocacy, to capturing demand and surfacing expansion signals. However, attempting to measure and optimize for every possible use case at once is a fast track to operational chaos and reporting clutter. To keep execution sharp and measurement defensible, I always fall back on a simple rule of thumb: Select just two primary use cases that directly align with your immediate business goals.

By anchoring your community strategy around two specific, measurable outcomes—such as increasing sales velocity or boosting net revenue retention—you create a focused feedback loop. Once you prove the financial return of those initial priorities, the conversation in the boardroom fundamentally changes. Community is no longer an ambiguous line item. It is recognized as a predictable revenue driver.

Ultimately, community marketing is neither a silver bullet, nor a soft luxury designed purely for goodwill. It is the fuel that makes every other channel in your marketing mix work harder. By giving community spend its own return metric, we stop asking finance to take brand value on faith—and start proving how human connection drives compounding growth.

Kourtney Barnes is vice president of marketing at Bettermode.