Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The “both/and” versus “either/or” supply chain

Given tariff volatility, manufacturers need to rethink their strategy.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Dave Evans

Co-Founder, CEO · Fictiv

For the better part of a year, the conversation about American manufacturing has been framed as a binary choice: Keep sourcing overseas, or bring production home. That framing made sense in early 2025, when tariffs were rising fast and the political message was simple. It makes less sense now. The legal basis for those tariffs has shifted at least three times since February, new duties have been layered on under different statutes, and companies that reorganized their supply chains around any single version of that policy have already had to reorganize them again.

Instead of whether to reshore or offshore, companies should consider which parts of a supply chain benefit from being close to home, and which don’t.

WHAT THE DATA SHOWS

The investment case for U.S. manufacturing is strong, and it’s not close. Manufacturing value added hit $2.91 trillion in 2024, a nominal record, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. If U.S. manufacturing were its own economy, it would rank eighth in the world, ahead of France. The ISM Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index reached 54 in May 2026, the strongest reading in four years, after spending most of 2025 below the growth threshold. Foreign direct investment in U.S. manufacturing has reached $2.42 trillion cumulatively, more than any other sector attracts, led by Japan, Canada, and Germany.

But hand in hand with these highs comes a less celebratory number. The U.S. manufacturing industry will need 3.8 million additional workers by 2033, and as many as 1.9 million of those positions could go unfilled without intervention. Roughly 65% of manufacturers already cite attracting and retaining skilled talent as their top challenge, more than material costs or tariffs.

That gap matters for the reshoring debate specifically, because it puts a hard ceiling on how much production can realistically move home in the near term, regardless of what happens with tariffs. Capacity built without the people to run it doesn’t produce anything.

WHY “EITHER/OR” BREAKS DOWN IN PRACTICE

The tariff landscape hasn’t made the calculation any simpler. The Supreme Court struck down the administration’s broadest tariff authority, under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, in February. The government moved quickly to a different statute, which a trade court then found unlawful as well. Meanwhile, tariffs under Section 232, covering steel, aluminum, copper, and an expanding list of other categories, have stayed in place and grown. Deloitte’s 2026 manufacturing outlook describes an industry now planning around “should-cost” models that treat tariff exposure as one variable among several, rather than the deciding one, because the rules keep changing faster than a sourcing strategy can be rebuilt around them.

Manufacturers that spent the past 18 months trying to guess which country or category would be taxed next have mostly concluded that the guessing isn’t worth it. A more durable approach treats offshore and domestic capacity as complementary tools rather than competing ones. In other words, keep offshore sourcing for standardized, cost-sensitive components where the economics still clearly favor it, and reshore or nearshore the stages where speed, IP protection, or quality control carry more weight than unit cost—final assembly, critical subcomponents, anything that benefits from being a shorter flight from the engineering team that designed it.

THE MIDDLE DISTANCE

Between offshore and reshore sits a third option: nearshoring, typically to Mexico. It has become the practical middle ground for manufacturers that need to shorten a supply chain. USMCA-qualifying goods have largely sat outside the tariff turbulence of the past year. This has made Mexico-based production more predictable than sourcing from overseas.

This is why “both/and” is a better description of what’s actually happening than either reshoring or offshoring alone. The objective isn’t necessarily a wholesale move of production across a border in either direction, but a redistribution of specific stages of production—design, prototyping, subassembly, final assembly—across whichever location best matches that stage’s tolerance for cost, speed, and risk. Nearshoring is often where that redistribution lands first, because it requires the smallest change to an existing supply chain to capture most of the benefit.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR HOW COMPANIES BUILD

In practice, this shows up earlier in the process than most people expect—at the design stage, not the purchasing stage. A part’s manufacturability, its tolerance for supplier substitution, and its exposure to a specific tariff category are all decisions made before a sourcing team ever puts out a bid. Companies building that flexibility into the design, rather than trying to negotiate it into a contract later, are adapting fastest to a policy environment that has changed direction four times in a single year.

None of this argues against reshoring. More than 2 million reshoring and foreign-investment jobs have been announced since 2010, and community college enrollment in vocational manufacturing programs is up nearly 20% since 2020. But treating reshoring as a wholesale replacement for global sourcing, rather than one part of a blended strategy, sets companies up to be surprised by the next policy shift—and there will be a next one. Betting everything on a single direction is not the path forward. The manufacturers pulling ahead right now are building a supply chain flexible enough not to have to guess.

Dave Evans is president and CEO of MISUMI Americas.