Most of the managers I meet call themselves “accidental.” They have no proper training or real idea whether they’re “doing” management right. Studies concur—a whopping 82% of managers say they received no formal leadership or management training.
We’ve built a work culture where untrained managers are the norm. Companies promote high performers without considering their leadership acumen—often setting those new managers up to fail. Meanwhile, many managers don’t have access to useful analytics about how they’re leading or any instrumentation layer that lets them observe themselves at work.
Without proper guidance and tools, new managers may turn to generic artificial intelligence and ask how to level up their leadership skills—but they’re immediately hamstrung by the limited scope of their own prompts. You cannot have a true “aha moment” about something as complex as leading if you don’t know what you don’t know.
I’ve long sympathized with managers who get thrown to the wolves. Only recently did I discover some numbers that inspire non-managers to really care. Consider the cost of weak employee engagement—something poor management often produces: Gallup finds when employees are not engaged or actively disengaged, it costs nearly $9 trillion in annual lost productivity—roughly 9% of global GDP. The same is true at the scale of individual companies. Blanchard Research finds that a lack of leadership development digs a 7% hole in an organization’s annual sales.
We already have the tools to fix this problem. Before we can implement them, we must define what really lifts new managers.
WHY TYPICAL LEADERSHIP TRAINING FAILS
American companies spend billions on leadership development courses, trying to turn accidental managers” into real leaders. But McKinsey finds those programs often devolve into an expensive waste of time.
Typical leadership programs fail because they try to help individuals without any knowledge of their specific work life. They fail because they don’t know the person being trained.
I believe deeply in the idea of praxis—tapping into real, everyday experience to learn and improve. Gallup research finds that we learn to lead by reflecting on real encounters, not studying a textbook or watching a training video. Likewise, Visier found that 91% of managers learn on the job and don’t credit training programs for their growth.
Imagine the equivalent of an Oura Ring for leaders: a tool designed to ride alongside every one-on-one, every meeting. Such a tool could provide personalized leadership intelligence to even a newbie manager. It could offer extraordinary longitudinal insights, too. Its memory would stitch together a mosaic of the manager’s experience, surfacing truths and patterns that would otherwise remain invisible.
The highly biased systems that we all inherited—annual reviews and engagement surveys—are plagued by recency bias and deliver feedback far too late to help. In their place, AI infrastructure will live inside almost every meeting, listening, transcribing, and analyzing the way we lead in everyday moments. The feedback we gain will be instant, personalized, and actionable.
THE TOOLS WE NEED NOW
The problem has never been accessto leadership theory. The problem is creating a ride-along system of leadership intelligence that turns assessment and insight into a form of daily maintenance: Leadership repetitions.
Every meeting, email, and touchpoint of a manager’s day can be aggregated into a private report that compiles decades of leadership wisdom into nonthreatening and immediately relevant guidance. Such infrastructure is the only solution that can scale far enough to provide real-time praxis to the next generation of managers.
In recent months, I’ve seen many managers try to hack together that infrastructure themselves. As Zapier CEO Wade Foster recently noted, some are piecing together ChatGPT with meeting transcription tools like Granola to get real-time feedback on their leadership.
The demand is clearly there. But this cobbled-together approach has serious limitations. AI’s sycophantic bias flatters rather than challenges. It also has no access to the broader context of your organization—the patterns across teams, the history of your relationships, or the culture you’re operating in. It’s a janky hack that proves the need for something more comprehensive.
Using an effective leadership analytics tool will feel like switching on a fitness app during a bike ride—insights are trusted, objective, and benchmarked against all your previous experiences. That’s the kind of real motivation new leadership intelligence tools can provide for millions of accidental managers.
THE INSIGHTS I WISH I HAD
The number of direct reports per manager has roughly doubled in recent years. The trend is even more pronounced in larger firms. As organizations continue to flatten and each accidental manager is given a larger team, new AI leadership infrastructure will become indispensable. The alternative? Poor management will be magnified. Weak leaders will have an outsized effect on their larger teams.
The larger their teams, the more support managers need so they can quickly absorb feedback and address the gaps in their leadership skills. In other words: We need to help them fast track their growth.
A novice frontline manager can then scale their work more easily—not just because some AI agent is pre-fabricating emails and schedules for them, but because they’re able to see their leadership strengths and weaknesses more clearly. I would have benefited enormously from that kind of insight when I started out.
Truth is, I owe an apology to the first team I ever led. At age 24, I was very much an accidental manager, too insecure to ask for help. I fumbled, guessed, and hoped nobody noticed the sweat. I performed the role of “leader” while waiting for clarity that took years to arrive. When it came, it was only because I’d cobbled together insights on my own.
Today’s new managers won’t have the luxury of time that I was given. Neither will they face the hindrances that fed my confusion. With new leadership intelligence infrastructure, they can develop an order of magnitude faster than I did.
Managers are demanding this already available technology. We can keep promoting people into leadership and hoping they figure it out, or we can guarantee their success by giving them the instrumentation they need.
Ben Perreau is founder and CEO of Parafoil.