In 2025, Target made a decision that reflects the impossible terrain facing leaders today. After years of publicly embracing diversity, equity, and inclusion, the retailer announced it would roll back major elements of its DEI strategy.
The move came amid intense political pressure and backlash over earlier initiatives. Yet the retreat did not resolve the controversy. Some customers and advocates felt betrayed. Other stakeholders believed Target went too far in the first place. By early 2026, shareholders were questioning management decisions and warning of reputational and operational risks.
Target’s predicament points to a dilemma leaders face constantly. Today, this friction has escalated into a deeper leadership crisis: How do you remain authentic when the world sets an increasingly high price on authenticity?
AUTHENTICITY AND VOLATILITY
We have entered an era where, increasingly, traditions are upended, norms shattered overnight, and moral clarity routinely weaponized or ridiculed in the public square. Volatility ensures that positions that felt firm yesterday can shift beneath our feet today.
For years, executive coaching and management literature preached a simple gospel: Be your authentic self. Authenticity meant alignment among our core beliefs, words, and actions. It promised trust, integrity, moral clarity, and personal coherence.
Many still believe leadership authenticity matters. But rigid authenticity can become a trap. When every decision, statement, and strategy must perfectly reflect a leader’s unadulterated personal convictions, authenticity becomes fragile and unmanageable.
A leader can become so concerned with maintaining consistency that they lose the capacity to negotiate, adapt, or influence. The pursuit of moral purity can result in paralysis—or worse, in being sidelined, muzzled, or rendered ineffective.
THE TENSIONS OF TRANSFORMATIONAL LEADERSHIP
This tension is not new. Transformational leaders have always faced two unforgiving forces:Supporters who can interpret any concession, nuanced communication, or tactical retreat as evidence of weakening resolve and detractors who operate from the opposite extreme. They rarely acknowledge goodwill or progress, interpreting every statement as disingenuous, manipulative, or radical.
Martin Luther King Jr. experienced both pressures. History rightly remembers King’s uncompromising vision of racial justice. But the day-to-day work of the Civil Rights Movement required something far more complex than rhetoric. King had to navigate competing organizations, political relationships, strategic disagreements, and direct-action tactics.
His leadership required holding an uncomfortable tension—absolute clarity about the destination alongside flexibility about the route. That tension was precisely how the movement he championed built capacity to produce real change.
The danger for today’s leaders is confusing ideological purity with effective leadership. A leader can remain completely consistent with their convictions and still fail to move the needle. That is not successful leadership.
THE ALTERNATIVE OF PRINCIPLED PRAGMATISM
Still, the alternative is not selling out, which means abandoning a core principle simply because defending it became inconvenient—a move that destroys credibility and self-respect over time. The true alternative is principled pragmatism. It means remaining deeply committed to what matters while accepting that strategies, language, sequencing, alliances, and tactics must adapt.
Principled pragmatism recognizes that leadership in complex environments is rarely about winning a cause outright in one decisive victory. It is about moving the cause measurably forward. That becomes the true metric of progress.
Abraham Lincoln understood this. Lincoln’s presidency was defined by a profound tension between moral conviction and political reality. The Civil War initially centered on preserving the Union. Over time, Lincoln strategically connected preservation of the Union with emancipation.
The Emancipation Proclamation of 1863 was itself an exercise in strategic constraint. It applied to enslaved people in areas still in rebellion, while leaving slavery untouched in loyal border states and areas already under Union control. Yet it fundamentally changed the war, strengthened the Union cause, and paved the way toward slavery’s abolition.
Lincoln did not achieve everything at once. He moved the country.
To idealists, this approach might seem insufficient. But for history, it proved transformational. The goal of leadership is not to win every argument, satisfy every supporter, or maintain perfect ideological consistency. It is to create meaningful movement toward a purpose.
SIX RULES FOR NAVIGATING COMPLEXITY
For boards, CEOs, and political leaders navigating today’s polarized environment, six core practices can help maintain this balance:
1. Anchor in purpose—and distinguish it from tactics. Define your non-negotiable purpose as your North Star. Treat strategies, policies, alliances, and communication as tools for advancing it, not as sacred doctrines.
2. Balance impact with intent. Moral purity asks whether a decision feels right. Leadership asks what it accomplishes. Judge progress by tangible movement for stakeholders, not applause from an echo chamber.
3. Normalize principled concession. Teach your organization that negotiation is not synonymous with retreat. Sometimes stepping back, re-sequencing an ambition, or accepting an imperfect outcome creates conditions for a much larger advance.
4. Build a challenge network. Surround yourself with people who challenge your assumptions rather than validate your moral performance. Ask trusted advisers: Will this decision advance our purpose, or does it simply make us feel righteous?
5. Explain the “why” behind the compromise. When circumstances require a tactical adjustment, communicate the reasoning clearly. People do not need leaders to pretend every decision is perfect. They need to understand the purpose, trade-offs, and destination.
6. Don’t negotiate away your red lines. Before crisis hits, establish your organization’s bottom line with your board and executive team. Know precisely which lines you will never cross.
THE NEW MEASURE OF AUTHENTICITY
Authenticity without adaptability becomes vanity—a performance of personal consistency that sacrifices real progress. But adaptability without purpose is opportunism of the worst kind.
The leaders who create lasting change are neither moral purists nor cynical pragmatists. They are principled pragmatists. They know what they stand for, but they also understand that leading an institution is not a platform for self-expression. It is an instrument for impact.
Boards should therefore ask their leaders a different question. Not simply, “Are you being true to principle?” but rather, “Are you being true to the purpose—and are you finding a way to move it forward?”
Authentic leadership requires knowing what must never change—and having the courage to adapt almost everything else.
Christopher O.H. Williams is founder and managing partner of Custament Partners LLC.