A few months ago, a professional-services client nearly lost a final-round candidate. The woman, in her early thirties, was exactly who my client wanted to hire. She spent the last 10 minutes of the interview asking whether the plan covered fertility treatment, if it was easy to access mental health therapy, and whether her benefit plan could flex if her life changed.
Despite a genuinely strong plan, my client couldn’t answer the candidate’s questions. The plan had been sold on price and network, so nobody on the employer’s side had been briefed on the family-building or behavioral-health provisions. The coverage was decent, but no one knew that.
It would be easy to file that away as one demanding candidate. Our own numbers say otherwise. Across roughly 800 small-group and mid-market renewals my team has run so far this year, more than 90% came through with no fertility coverage at all.
The coverage gap
Employer IVF coverage among large employers climbed from about 22% in 2019 to roughly 47% in 2024, according to Mercer. In Carrot Fertility’s global survey of 5,000 people, 65% said they would change jobs to work for a company offering fertility benefits.
The Mercer survey is among large employers, but nearly half of American workers are at companies with 500 employees or fewer, below the survey’s threshold.
That’s the disconnect. Younger workers hear about—yet can’t access—benefits concentrated in the companies most don’t work for. A 29-year-old at a 60-person firm reads the same articles as her Fortune 500 peer, and then opens a plan document that hasn’t changed in a decade.
Benefits advisors to companies helped build this gap. We compete on price to get the renewal signed, and family-building coverage is the easiest line to cut because it protects only a small number of employees. I’ve been in rooms and watched it come out of a plan in under a minute, and I haven’t always argued hard enough to keep it there.
I’m encouraging clients to reconsider that decision, because that line item is now one of the first things a candidate may ask about.
Beyond fertility
Other employee benefits that I’ve seen help attract and retain younger talent include student-loan support with employer contributions toward student debt, retirement matching programs tied to student-loan payments, and other programs that help employees manage education-related debt. For employees helping aging parents, benefits can include backup care, dependent-care assistance, and caregiver support services and resources.
The traditional benefits package was built for a fairly uniform employee moving through predictable milestones on a predictable timeline, and that employee is disappearing. In my experience, when younger workers see a plan that ignores all of this, they read it as designed for someone who isn’t them.
Deloitte’s latest global survey finds millennials and Gen Z putting sustainable workload, long-term success, skills, and well-being ahead of the next rung on the ladder. It’s a different scorecard, and benefits sit near the center of it.
Mental health coverage is common in employer health plans, and KFF’s 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey found that 70% of firms believed their largest health plan provided timely access to mental health services.
In my experience, younger employees scrutinize whether the benefit is real, because a paper benefit doesn’t guarantee easy access. That means in-network providers who are actually available, reasonable session limits, telehealth, and a workplace culture that doesn’t penalize people for using it. They can tell the difference between a benefit that exists on paper and one they can use on a Tuesday afternoon.
The same test applies to everything else. In my work with employers, personalization is increasingly becoming a benefits-design principle,, with options that let people assemble benefits coverage around their own life stage rather than accept a single template. To me, a benefits package that can’t flex increasingly signals that the employer hasn’t caught up with how its workforce actually lives.
What the renewal room misses
Most leaders miss that, to a 28-year-old, a benefits package answers a question they ask about every employer they consider: Does this place understand the life I actually live?
They hear “yes” from a plan that maps to how they build families, manage their mental health and carry financial stress. A plan frozen in an earlier era tells them “no” long before anyone says it in an exit interview.
The companies pulling ahead started treating benefits as something to listen for and design around, which requires a different muscle than cost control.
Which brings me back to those 800 renewals. Fixing the issue starts by asking a question almost nobody asks at renewal: What does this plan say to the person reading it?
Jennifer Schaefer is founder and CEO of JS Benefits Group.