Private market firms have spent the past year asking themselves whether they should trust agentic AI. But that framing does not survive contact with a limited partner (LP) due diligence questionnaire, because trust is a feeling and feelings are not evidence. The question that gets tested is narrower and less forgiving: Can a firm audit exactly what an agent saw and the decisions it took on demand, months after the fact?
THE CONFIDENCE-READINESS GAP
Grant Thornton spoke to 950 business leaders and found that 99 of the 100 responding private equity firms are exploring, piloting, scaling, or embedding agentic AI in some form. Set against that near-total adoption, only 9% of these respondents said they were very confident they could pass an AI governance audit within 90 days. This was the lowest rate of any sector in the survey, and less than half the cross-industry average of 22%. That is not an indictment of whether the technology works, but it is an indictment of whether a firm can currently produce the accountability trail an auditor, buyer, or regulator would expect.
The fact that most firms do not have certainty over their agents’ actions has wider workforce implications. In conversations with asset management and private equity leaders, KPMG found that 43% of employees resist using AI agents because confidence and quality fall below limits. This comes ahead of any worries about workload or job security. This finding matters because it shows a confidence gap has emerged among the teams that should be spearheading adoption.
FALLING EXTERNAL STAKEHOLDER TRUST
Buyer diligence, LP due diligence, and regulatory examination are three moments where robust auditability is tested. A firm should be prepared to show these stakeholders the audit trail.
Common failure modes with AI agents include model drift in revenue projections, unauthorized data access surfaced during due diligence, and workflow errors that cascade as a firm scales. These are not failures of the AI itself, but failures to log and enforce the guardrails set around it. The root cause is usually weak governance: no clear owner for an agent’s output and no process for containing errors before they spread. So when an LP, buyer, or regulator asks what happened, there is no audit trail to produce.
In today’s market, we see an increase in LPs questioning and scrutinizing their asset and fund managers’ data and automated reporting. Private Equity International found that almost half of LPs monitor how their general partners (GPs) adopt AI in investment and operational processes. But monitoring is the polite word for what’s happening. They’re really asking GPs to show their work.
HERE IS WHAT MAKES AGENTIC AI AUDITABLE
This is an argument for a different definition of what makes agentic AI usable in the first place. And there are three things in particular separating a firm that can pass an audit from one that cannot.
- Traceability: Every output an agent produces needs to map back to a source, so that when an investment committee member asks where a figure came from, the answer is a page reference rather than a shrug.
- Consistency: The result for a given set of data should be reproducible rather than a fresh answer every time the same question is asked again.
- A defined human checkpoint: Place this at important moments rather than applied as blanket oversight to everything an agent touches.
Allvue’s 2026 GP Outlook Survey found the private markets industry starts from a weaker foundation with AI. Only 8% of firms report highly mature data environments, and 70% still depend on manual workflows and spreadsheets as their default operating model. That matters because traceability is impossible to fake. An agent cannot point to a source if the underlying data was never structured well enough to have one. Auditability, in other words, is a data problem before it is an AI problem. This is why the firms furthest ahead on governance tend to be the same firms that did the unglamorous work of consolidating and ordering their data first.
FIRMS SHOULD SHOW THEIR WORK
In three to five years, the performance divide in private markets will run between firms that can produce documented, auditable evidence of what their AI did and why, and firms that can only describe what it probably did, which is harder to defend under scrutiny. We would all prefer to be in the first group, able to treat an LP due diligence questionnaire, a regulatory examination, or a buyer’s diligence request as a routine exercise. Put the work in now, or you might find yourself explaining a black box instead of raising a fund.
Ivan Latanision is chief product officer of Allvue Systems.