Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Marketing’s reporting is a trust problem

When leadership can’t see how marketing drives revenues, teams spend more time documenting their work than doing it.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Debra Andrews

Founder and President · Marketri LLC

When leadership can’t see how marketing drives revenue, marketing tries to prove its worth with more reports, until the reports take up more time than the actual work.

Every marketing function carries two jobs. Employees are paid for the first: positioning, campaigns, and pipeline programs. The second is demonstrating that the first one happened, which means recap slides, one-pagers summarizing other one-pagers, and metrics copied from one dashboard into another built just for the update. This is the work about the work.

It doesn’t move a buyer closer to a decision. Its only audience is the people inside the building who need convincing that marketing is doing enough.

The doom loop

This is a symptom of a deeper problem: leadership doesn’t fully trust marketing, so it holds back funding until marketing proves its value. The same dynamic shows up outside brand budgets too.

A recent Gartner survey finds that 84% of companies are stuck in the same brand doom loop: underfunded measurement leads to unclear impact, rising skepticism, and tighter budgets. Gartner’s data is about brand investment specifically, but the mechanics also apply to marketing.

Whenever marketing can’t prove impact in numbers leadership already trusts, the team gets asked for more proof without more resources, and hours come off the real work to build evidence that the work happened. That loop usually gets discussed as a boardroom funding issue. But its real costs land further down, on a marketing team stretched thin just to keep proving it earns its keep.

The documentation trap

It’s tempting to blame an over-eager marketer or an over-demanding CEO. But that misses where the problem starts.

Leadership can’t trace marketing’s impact on revenue directly, so marketing fills the gap with documentation. More documentation doesn’t rebuild trust; it just gives leadership more material to sift through, which makes the next deck request feel justified. Each cycle adds to the reporting pile and takes time away from the work that pile is supposed to be proving.

The burden isn’t just more reports. It’s the constant work of translating marketing reports into terms that leadership understands. Finance wants the pipeline story in dollars. The board wants it in growth rate. The CEO wants it compressed into one slide for a 40-minute meeting.

Marketing ends up building the same case three different ways for three different audiences, and each version takes almost as long as the last to create, because no version can simply point back to the one before it. The moment a second internal audience needs its own cut of the same proof, the work about the work stops being a byproduct and becomes a second product line.

Gartner’s survey explains why the loop holds. Only 32% of executives say their CMO makes compelling business strategy recommendations based on market or customer data, and only 34% say their CMO effectively identifies the marketing initiatives that will contribute most to company growth.

Leadership doesn’t doubt marketing’s talent. It doubts what it can’t see marketing produce. When leadership doesn’t trust what marketing tells it, marketing responds with more telling, not more doing.

I’ve sat across from CMOs whose end-of-quarter deck was the most polished document their company produced all quarter, more polished than anything a buyer ever saw. That’s the predictable result of a system that rewards what looks good over what is actually true. No one in that system did anything wrong. They simply followed the incentives.

One number, every month

Most leadership teams overestimate how hard this is to fix. It starts with agreeing on one number the CFO and the board already watch, commonly pipeline contribution, and delivering it on a set date every month, before anyone asks.

Gartner’s read on this matches what I see in client work. CMOs who lead with a clear, decision-ready ROI story keep both their budgets and their influence. What builds the trust is consistency, not comprehensiveness. Once that consistent number exists, the rest of the reporting stack has nothing left to justify it.

It also means leadership agrees not to request a separate version of that story for a different meeting. The moment one function gets a custom cut of the numbers, the case for building three more custom cuts is already made, and the loop restarts inside a single quarter.

Trust holds when the story stays the same no matter who’s in the room to hear it.

Retire the second job on purpose

When a team spends more hours describing its work than doing it, the measure worth taking is different: how much trust is missing between marketing and leadership, and what it costs every month to compensate for it.

Leadership built this structure, which means leadership can unwind it. That means picking, once, what proof earns a look, and treating everything else as optional. A decision made at that level holds through every quarter that follows.

Debra Andrews is founder and CEO of Marketri.