In the 1970s and ’80s, a Fabergé Organics commercial featured spokespeople who said after trying the shampoo, they told two friends, “and they told two friends, and so on, and so on, and so on.” It was a hit ad that captured the power of word-of-mouth recommendations. Today, influencers, independent reviewers, and customer reviews and feedback can create their own viral, word-of-mouth moments. But a great ad can still get the conversation going and creates momentum of its own. So, which works best in 2026 and beyond?
We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members which is more important or effective: advertising or word of mouth. Here, 31 of those members share their insights and choose which has worked best for them and why.
1. YOU CAN BUY ATTENTION, NOT BELIEF
In enterprise software, word of mouth can be a game changer. When we had no U.S. references, we flew a European customer to America to speak with prospects directly. That opened the market for us. Advertising tells people who you are. A customer who believes in you shows them. After 26 years, our first customer is still with us. Real partnerships are central to driving growth. — Dan Amzallag, Ivalua
2. CREDIBILITY IN EXISTING USERS
Word of mouth is more effective because it comes from someone the buyer already trusts and, ideally, from someone who has used the product. That carries a level of credibility that advertising has to work much harder to earn. Advertising, by contrast, can create awareness, but word of mouth creates confidence. A genuine recommendation from an existing user of our software can shorten the decision-making process because it gives prospective buyers real-world validation that the product works and delivers value. — Chris Dunn, ReadyCloud
3. NEITHER EXISTS IN ISOLATION
Advertising can create awareness and reach at scale. Word of mouth can build trust and advocacy. But neither exists in isolation. What happens after someone sees an ad—the experience they have with the product, the service they receive, the way a brand follows up—determines whether that awareness becomes a customer, and whether that customer becomes an advocate. Every part of the business needs to work together to create growth. Marketing can create demand, but sustainable growth comes when the technology, data, processes, and people behind it are connected to deliver on that promise. — Jeff Geheb, WPP Enterprise Solutions
4. BOTH NEEDED TO CREATE INBOUND DEMAND
Both are needed, as the goal is to create an “inbound system of demand.” The problem with word of mouth is that it’s random and unpredictable. You can’t forecast it. The problem with solution-based advertising is that almost all solutions have been commoditized, so saying you’re better doesn’t differentiate you anymore. The key is to shift from solution-centric advertising to problem-centric advertising. Market the problems you solve, not your solutions . . . to become a category of one! — Ari Galper, Selling With Trust
5. ADS CAN’T BUY NEEDED TRUST
Word of mouth wins, every time. Advertising can buy attention. It cannot buy trust. And trust is everything in my business. Being someone clients can trust is the only way my firm works. My first client from 1992 is still with me today, and a relationship that long doesn’t come from a pitch. It comes from years of doing what I said I would do. So when someone puts my name in front of a friend, they’re putting their own name behind mine. No ad can do that. — Richard McWhorter, SRM Private Wealth
6. USE ADVERTISING TO AMPLIFY, NOT REPLACE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE
Word of mouth wins for effectiveness, though advertising still has its place. People trust recommendations from others far more than ads. That’s human nature. A satisfied customer telling a friend carries more weight than a paid message, because there’s no perceived agenda. Word of mouth also compounds: One happy customer can influence dozens more, essentially for free. Advertising helps with awareness early on, but it doesn’t build trust the same way. As a CEO, I’d rather invest in product quality and experience that sparks conversation, then use advertising to amplify that, not replace it. — Joe Faruqui, ASAP Semiconductor
7. THEY SOLVE DIFFERENT PROBLEMS
Advertising buys reach, while word of mouth earns the trust that turns attention into action. Our research found reviews are shoppers’ top confidence driver, and 62% of heavy AI converters say clear sponsored labeling increases trust. The strongest strategy uses paid media to amplify credible customer and creator proof, not manufacture it. — Stephanie Harris, PartnerCentric
8. WORD OF MOUTH IS GRASSROOTS
Word of mouth is like grassroots mobilizing. When we look at civil rights, women’s rights, voting rights, and more, these great movements started with people in community. In my current role, we work with individuals and communities as well as states, coalitions, and national leaders. However, rather than prioritizing one method over another, I prefer to use all channels available to be as effective as possible in achieving our mission and vision. This means utilizing digital advertising, media relations, influencer engagement, thought leadership, word of mouth, or grassroots marketing and much more. — Linda Goler Blount, Community Catalyst
9. CLIENT ENDORSEMENTS MORE POWERFUL
For personal injury law, it is absolutely word of mouth. Many lawyers have built very successful law firms using TV or billboards, but in my view a satisfied client endorsing our services will always be more powerful than a 30-second ad or catchy slogan. — Andrew Kryder, The Kryder Law Group
10. WHERE THE REAL VALUE SITS
Advertising gets you in front of people who’ve never heard of you, which you need. You can’t grow on referrals alone. But word of mouth is what happens when you protect the relationships you’ve already built, and that’s where the real value sits. Those long-standing relationships aren’t just good for business, they’re a record of how your work and your company have evolved. A client who’s been with you for a decade can tell you things about your own growth that no ad campaign ever will. So I’d say: Use advertising to open doors, but it’s the relationships you keep nurturing that build the business. — Diana Sabb, Create Something Amazing
11. CUSTOMER STORIES FIRST; AD DOLLARS SECOND
Nothing beats a real customer telling their own story—especially when you’re launching a brand-new category people don’t yet have a frame of reference for. No ad we write ourselves is as convincing as an unscripted testimonial. Our approach: Treat word of mouth as the raw material and advertising as the amplifier. Capture user stories first, then put paid dollars behind the ones that resonate to amplify the word of mouth. — Chris Brooks, Solius Labs
12. THE BEST BRANDS USE BOTH
Word of mouth wins, without question. Advertising can get you in front of people, but someone recommending you carries a completely different level of credibility. That said, I think the best brands use both. Advertising creates awareness, while word of mouth creates trust. If you can get people talking about your brand without paying them, you have built something much more valuable than an ad campaign. — Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC
13. YOUR REPUTATION PRECEDES YOU
The power of word of mouth is unbeatable. This is especially true for small- to medium-sized businesses. Your reputation precedes you—always. There’s no point in spending money on advertising if your clients aren’t doing the work for you first. Keep your clients happy and they will bring you new business. As your business grows it makes sense to spend on targeted, strategic advertising to promote brand awareness. But I’ve found presenting at key industry conferences and engaging with client decision-makers face to face is the best investment for growth. — Felicity Heathcote-Marcz, PhD, Bare Analysis
14. REACH VERSUS TRUST
Word of mouth is more powerful for trust. Advertising is more scalable for reach. A healthy business should not choose between them. Use advertising to create awareness and make your expertise easier to discover. Then use strong delivery, client proof, and referrals to reduce perceived risk. Advertising can generate attention, but word of mouth determines how much credibility that attention carries. — Tavares Beverly, Beverly Boy Productions
15. ADS ARE A TAP; REFERRALS ARE A WELL
Word of mouth, but only because advertising can’t fix what it exposes. We’ve built the agency with zero ad spend. Every client came from a referral, LinkedIn, or search. Ads buy attention once. A referral arrives pre-sold, closes faster, and negotiates less. The catch: Word of mouth won’t scale on command, so it’s the wrong answer if you need pipeline this quarter. Ads are a tap. Referrals are a well. Dig the well first, then turn the tap. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand
16. THE POWERFUL TRUST TRANSFER
Word of mouth is significantly more powerful because trust is transferred from someone the prospective client already knows. This significantly reduces the time spent during the new client onboarding process. Advertising can highlight awareness and reach people outside your existing network, but it works best when it reinforces a strong reputation rather than trying to replace one. Advertising creates visibility and word of mouth creates natural trust. — Ryan Walker, Meristead Wealth
17. THE REFERRAL DOESN’T END WITH A PHONE CALL
Word of mouth is most effective, and I am biased, because it built my company: We’re almost 19 years old, and referrals are a strong part of our success. But a referral no longer ends with a phone call. The person you were recommended to asks an artificial intelligence engine about you first, and that answer gets assembled from press, podcasts, reviews, and whatever else has been published. If none of it is current, the referral fades and you never hear about it. So I do for us what I tell clients to do. Get in the press. Say yes to the podcast. Keep the reviews current. Advertising buys attention. It cannot manufacture the answer a machine gives about you. — Kathleen Lucente, Red Fan Communications
18. WHAT PEOPLE SAY ABOUT YOU DECIDES THINGS
Advertising and word of mouth do different, integral jobs. But if I had to choose, I’d pick word of mouth. You can buy people’s attention with advertising, but you can’t buy what they say about you in their own group chat, team meeting, or when you’re nowhere near the room. That’s the version of your reputation that decides things. — Jen Jones, Siteimprove
19. ADS FIT OUR PRODUCT NATURE
For us, it’s advertising, but only because of the nature of what we do. People don’t tend to know how their friends and neighbors financed their vehicle, so lease buyouts just aren’t a natural dinner-table conversation. That makes word of mouth a weak growth vector for us regardless of how happy our customers are. In general, though, word of mouth is far stronger, and if you can build a groundswell among consumers, you should. — Zander Cook, Lease End
20. QUANTITATIVE REACH AND QUALITATIVE TRUST
I see it as the difference between quantitative reach and qualitative trust. Advertising can put you in front of thousands of people very quickly, but word of mouth carries something advertising cannot buy: someone else’s experience with you. A recommendation from a client, colleague, or trusted peer comes with context and credibility already attached. Advertising is important for visibility and scale, but especially in a professional services business, recommendations often lead to healthier, more sustainable relationships because trust is already part of the introduction. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion
21. REFERRALS OFFER BETTER SPEED-TO-DEAL
Most people will probably say both are important, but I’ll pick a horse: word of mouth, all day. You could spend $100,000 on ads and never get the speed to deal or size of deal that a strong referral can produce. When someone a prospect already trusts tells them to talk to you, you’ve skipped a huge part of the work marketing normally must do. If I could only keep one in my marketing mix, I’d choose word of mouth without hesitation. — Andrea Lechner-Becker, GNW Consulting
22. BROAD AWARENESS VERSUS AUTHENTICITY
Both are important, but they work in different ways. Advertising can create broad awareness, yet it often gets lost in the noise of impersonal messages. Word of mouth doesn’t scale as easily, but it is far more cost effective and carries greater passion and authenticity because it travels through trusted personal networks. In my experience, word of mouth consistently drives deeper engagement and tends to be more enduring and effective over the long term. — Christopher O.H. Williams, Custament Partners LLC
23. TRUST ALREADY ATTACHED
If I had to choose one, I would choose word of mouth because it arrives with trust already attached. That matters even more for an expensive, highly considered purchase. Advertising is still useful because it creates reach and gives a business more control over growth, but it works best when it amplifies a reputation that customers are already willing to recommend. — Christopher Kiggins, SaunaCloud
24. NOTHING REPLACES A TRUSTED INTRODUCTION
Word of mouth wins every time in my experience. When a referral comes from someone who already knows and trusts me, our close rate is essentially 100%, far higher than anything paid ads could produce. Advertising can build awareness. But nothing replaces a trusted introduction when it comes to closing business. — Kevin C. Roy, GreenBanana SEO
25. THE HOLY GRAIL OF VIRAL ADVERTISING
You need both to be effective. Advertising can quickly reach the masses and spark, while word of mouth is a better closer but needs the luxury of time. The holy grail is viral advertising, where content with an emotive hook not only spreads with organic velocity, person to person, but is bolstered with some level of paid ad amplification. Crowd validation is the cue, and positive energy is the currency to put ad dollars behind. — Ly Tran, stiletto collective
26. WHAT PEOPLE SAY WHEN YOU’RE NOT IN THE ROOM
The most effective marketing is what other people say about you when you’re not in the room. You can buy attention, but you can’t buy belief, and belief is what moves someone to act. A recommendation from a trusted source beats any ad, because people believe a peer over a brand every time. Online reputation management takes that principle and makes it visible in search. Search engine optimization ranks the words you write about yourself. My company ranks the words other people write about you—the feedback, the threads, the opinions—so the trust is authentic and it’s the first thing people find. — Scott Keever, Reputation Pros
27. OUR ADVERTISING BUDGET IS ZERO
Our advertising budget is zero, so I’d have to say word of mouth. But I’m defining word of mouth expansively here to include people finding us organically through search engines and artificial intelligence answer engines as well as telling each other about our offerings. And it’s working. The community around our as-yet-to-be-released AI verification layer for commerce has grown to hundreds of members without any outbound marketing. — Michael Quoc, Product.ai
28. ADVERTISING FIRST, RECOMMENDATION SECOND
They’re not rivals for us, they’re sequential. Our marketing and public relations teams do the work of putting our product in front of the right families at scale, but the moment that converts a skeptical parent is almost always a recommendation from someone they trust. So I’d say word of mouth is the more powerful conversion tool, but it only works at the volume we need because of the advertising and brand work that gets us in front of people in the first place. — Cristobal Viedma, Lingokids
29. COMMUNITY IS THE MOST POWERFUL ASSET
Word of mouth is fundamentally more effective for building long-term trust. In a market saturated with trend chasing, sustained growth and brand endurance come from building a relationship with your customer. Advertising is important to amplify your brand, but if the customer journey has a ton of friction or your product is unreliable, your digital footprint and customer feedback online will show that. When those elements run smoothly, your community becomes your most powerful asset, creating organic demand that no paid campaign can replicate. — Benjamin Spiegel, POLYWOOD
30. EARNED CREDIBILITY, AMPLIFIED BY ADS
I own a public relations agency so believe in the power of word of mouth. It moves product in ways paid advertising can’t touch, especially now. Someone who loves a product—a creator, a peer, anyone authentic—carries a credibility that an ad, no matter how beautiful, ever will. That’s why TikTok Shop is reshaping retail. It’s not just a social media platform. It’s a social conversation platform where real recommendations drive real sales. For my clients, the question isn’t “advertising or PR?” It’s earned credibility that can be amplified by advertising. I’ll always stand by the power of earned media. — Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw, First and Last PR
31. DEPENDS ON PURCHASE RISK
It depends on your product or service. The more risk involved in the purchase, the more word of mouth matters (e.g., long-term contracts, high prices, regulatory exposure). The lower the risk, the more advertising becomes the key (e.g., cheap products, short commitments, impulse buys). — Tia Katz, Hu-X