Landing a promotion feels amazing. It feels like a real accomplishment, with congratulations, confidence and the rush that tells you, “I did it.” It’s a real dopamine hit.
This happened to me last year when I stepped into a new position. Genuinely excited, I had worked diligently on a transition plan I felt confident in and felt ready to execute.
Gradually, the transition became unsettling. Goals that had initially felt achievable became harder. In my previous role, I was valued for my deep subject-matter expertise in a specific area. In this new role, I was being asked to operate much more broadly across a range of services.
I put a lot of pressure on myself to bring the same level of expertise to all of them. But I couldn’t, and that really bothered me. I was used to feeling confident because I knew the subject matter deeply. Now, I was in situations where I didn’t always know the answer.
Suddenly, the confidence that felt natural just weeks ago started to feel thinner. Shakier. The destabilization crept in as the reality of the role set in.
My confidence started to slip. I felt like I should be doing better than I was and wanted to go back to what I knew I was good at. But what I had been good at before was no longer what my new role required.
That’s when the mental swirl began: Maybe I’m not cut out for this. I should be able to perform better. Maybe this was a mistake.
And then the internal, critical voice got harsher: Maybe I’m a failure.
An everyday problem
It might sound extreme, but for high-performing, driven leaders, the moments I experienced are more common than we admit. When your identity was built on competence and achievement, losing your footing, even briefly, can feel deeply unsettling.
I see this often with leaders promoted because they were exceptional at getting the work done. Suddenly, they’re leading a team or leading leaders of teams, and their success depends less on what they can personally execute and more on their ability to coach, motivate, and enable others to perform.
That transition can be incredibly difficult. The very expertise that earned a promotion can pull them back into the weeds, especially when the team struggles or the stakes are high. Doing the work themselves feels faster and more comfortable.
But the organization is now asking them to do something fundamentally different: lead through others. These moments of discomfort often invite growth.
Milestones and inflection points
Through my work coaching leaders globally, I’ve seen that this experience is a natural part of what happens after many career milestones.
Milestones mark something significant: a promotion, a new role, a major opportunity. They’re often moments of recognition and celebration. But often, an inflection point follows a milestone.
An inflection point asks something different of you. It requires you to operate and think differently, and often redefine how you see yourself as a leader. The skills that helped you succeed in the past still matter, but they’re rarely enough on their own.
That’s why this period can feel so psychologically difficult. You can no longer rely solely on the strengths that got you here, but you haven’t yet developed the capabilities and confidence the next phase requires.
Build an ANCHOR
Over time, I noticed a pattern. The leaders who navigate these moments most successfully don’t rush through them. They focus on building a new ANCHOR, which stands for:
- Awarenessis the starting point. Leaders notice their internal reactions and the stories they’re telling themselves. Self-doubt is normal, but awareness keeps it from quietly driving behavior.
- New perspective comes next. Leaders begin to rethink what competence and success look like in the new role, rather than judging themselves by the standards that defined success before.
- Connection is essential. Transitions can be isolating, especially in leadership roles. Relationships with peers, mentors, or coaches provide perspective and stability.
- Help-seeking requires courage. Many leaders feel pressure to figure it out alone, but asking for support is often what accelerates growth.
- Ownership shifts the mindset from proving to inhabiting the role. Instead of trying to demonstrate credibility, leaders begin defining what success looks like for them.
- Reflection creates space to recognize progress. Growth rarely feels dramatic in the moment, but noticing it builds confidence over time.
These practices help leaders stay grounded while they build the capabilities and confidence the new role requires.
The bigger picture
Organizations have a role to play here as well. Many celebrate promotions enthusiastically but provide little support once the role begins. By the time struggles become visible, leaders may already feel isolated or deeply discouraged.
The reality is this: Milestones are starting points, not finish lines.
The moment you reach a new career level is often when you begin learning to operate in an entirely new way. That process can feel destabilizing, even when the opportunity itself is exciting.
But if you expect that transition and intentionally build the support, perspective, and capabilities you need, those moments of uncertainty can become the foundation for meaningful growth.
The next time you reach a career milestone, celebrate it. Then pause and ask yourself a different question: What will I need to develop, let go of, or learn to succeed in what comes next?
Megan Marshall is the managing partner at AIIR Consulting.