Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

4 tips for reimagining your employee benefits strategy

Employers need to be ready for surging healthcare costs.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Alison Myers

President, Venbrook Insurance Services

Your employee benefits strategy is about to be tested—again.

For many employers, 2027 will mark the second consecutive year of double-digit renewal increases. Commercial healthcare cost increases are expected to reach a 17-year high in 2027, with group medical costs projected to rise 9% and individual market costs 8.5%. For employers, another year of significant cost increases will put renewed pressure on benefits budgets and long-term planning.

What’s behind these staggering increases? For one, as the cost of care rises, providers are demanding higher reimbursement rates. Carriers have little choice but to absorb these costs and pass them along to employers. At the same time, mental health conditions, chronic diseases, cancer treatments, and catastrophic diagnoses are driving higher-cost claims. As more people turn to GLP-1 medications, specialty drug spending is accelerating, too.

State regulations add additional nuance. In California, for instance, large-group plans issued or renewed in 2026 must now cover infertility and fertility services, which can increase premium costs. Other changes, such as the Managed Care Organization (MCO) Tax and other transparency laws, add a new layer of administrative and financial strain. 

Who pays for these increases?

Climbing rates mean many carriers will pass costs to employers, leaving organizations to grapple with big decisions about how much of the increase to absorb and how much to pass on to employees. From my vantage point, we’re right back to where we were when the Affordable Care Act passed a decade ago. The law introduced new coverage requirements and required larger employers to offer affordable health insurance or potentially face penalties, forcing organizations to reconsider how they structured their employee benefits packages.

We’ve already seen organizations move employees to high-deductible health plans to keep premiums manageable. That might work for a healthy executive earning $100,000 a year, but it doesn’t work for an employee who makes $65,000 and can’t afford a $5,000 deductible. We’re also seeing younger workers question whether health benefits are worth the cost at all—instead opting to pay out of pocket for concierge primary care or discount prescriptions.

With these factors coming to a head, the organizations that treat this as another annual health insurance renewal cycle will struggle. Organizations that use this time to rethink their broader benefits strategy will be far better positioned to keep their business afloat despite the challenges ahead.

Here are four tips to help employers maintain as much stability as possible.

1. Assess the direction of your business

Before you make another benefits decision, step back and consider where your business is headed. What are your workforce demographics—are your employees aging, are they parents? What are your goals and objectives with your team? What are your pain points? Are you investing in AI, people, or both? What is your hiring strategy for 2027? What do you hope to achieve with your employee benefits—to attract the best talent or retain employees?

Clarifying your direction will help determine where to invest, whether it’s in technological advances like AI or in expanded benefits for your workers. A holistic assessment will give you the groundwork to make informed, clear-eyed decisions about employee benefits—all aligned with your greater vision for the business.  

2. Ask your employees

With renewal increases on the horizon, now is the time to find out what benefits your employees value. Consider conducting an employee engagement survey to collect data on how employees are using their benefits or what additional benefits they’d like to see. 

Building a comprehensive benefits portfolio that’s both financially sustainable and tailored to your team’s real-life needs can go a long way in improving engagement and retention. Things like health advocacy support, hospital indemnity plans, legal services, or financial assistance are all lower-cost options that hold tremendous value for workers.

3. Don’t forget your independent contractors

One solution amid rising costs is relying on independent 1099 contractors and part-time workers to fill productivity gaps. For these workers, access to benefits is rare. Explore the possibilities of building a voluntary benefits marketplace for independent contractors and part-time workers.

This strategy is effective even in states like California, which have strict rules around what employers can offer independent contractors. A voluntary benefits marketplace simply allows contractors to purchase coverage at negotiated rates—it won’t go through payroll or be filtered through their costs.

In practice, this might look as simple as providing a valuable contractor with a $250 credit to purchase dental insurance or an accident plan. It’s one low-cost way to show workers that you value them, even if they’re not on your payroll as a full-time employee. This strategy can be especially great for hospitality businesses with many contractors or part-time employees.

4. Keep employee retention top of mind

As the cost of benefits increases, take this as an opportunity to own your culture and how people show up. What’s your plan for people and technology? What decisions can you make today that will shore up engagement and retention in the future?

Smart organizations will use this time to evaluate their strategy and determine where to shift dollars. Even if you plan to reduce your workforce, consider whether you might increase your benefits package to retain the top employees at your organization.   

Bottom line

The next few renewal cycles won’t be easy with higher costs, changing regulations, and eroding trust. But now is the right time to recalibrate your approach, guided by your long-term vision for your business and insights into what benefits matter most for your employees. 

Taking a strategic and well-planned approach during this wave of change will help set your organization up to weather the storm—and strengthen employee engagement and retention while doing it.

Alison Myers is president of Venbrook.