Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why workplaces need a conduct standard

A survey of 1,500 U.S. workers shows toxic colleagues walk away without consequences more often than they are removed.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Houman Akhavan

Founder and CEO · GCheck

Talk to any HR leader and you’ll hear a version of this story. The market turned, budgets tightened, the bar for who gets hired climbed higher than it has in years, and managers stopped tolerating average work from the people already on the team.

If that story holds up, one person should have felt it the most: the toxic colleague whose behavior consistently makes everyone else’s job worse. Every team has one. Ask coworkers to name that person and they will answer in seconds.

Ask what happened to that person once the job market tightened, and the answers get thin. People can name the colleague in seconds, but almost nobody can say what happened to them. We decided to find out what actually happens to them.

Toxic colleagues rarely pay

At GCheck, we surveyed 1,500 U.S. workers for The Consequence Gap study, and found what everyone assumes: 85% had worked closely with a toxic colleague.

However, what happened next tells a different story: among the 1,272 respondents who described a toxic coworker, 38% said their toxic colleague faced no consequences and 23% said their coworker was rewarded, promoted, or protected instead. Six times out of 10, that colleague walked away without repercussions or even came out ahead. Only 36% of toxic coworkers eventually left or were removed from the workplace.

Leaving is harder

When employers don’t act, the burden shifts to the employee. For many workers the only solution to escaping a difficult coworker is to leave. But in this job market, there are fewer options.

In the past, someone who had reached their limit with a toxic colleague could quit and land a new job within weeks. That’s no longer the case.

Finding the next job takes longer now. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, in September 2026, 27.1% of unemployed Americans had been out of work for 27 weeks or more, compared to 19.2% in February 2020. The unemployment rate itself has barely moved, holding between 4.1% and 4.3% since March, but the squeeze shows up in the length of the search.

Quit rates reflect it. The quits rate stood at 1.9% as of August 2026, down from roughly 3% in 2021. Fewer workers are willing or able to change jobs.

Our company works with employers across the country, and I watch job searches that used to close in weeks now stretch into months. Our research shows the exit still happens. Among the 630 workers whose situation had ended, 30% say they were the one who left. It just takes longer now.

Accountability flows downhill

Rank changes the odds of removal. When the toxic colleague was the respondent’s own manager or someone above them, they were rewarded or protected in 36% of cases and removed in 21%. Junior colleagues saw close to the reverse: 24% protected, 41% removed.

Accountability tends to flow downhill. Rank explains what happens once a senior person is involved but it does not locate the problem. Of the 1,272 workers who described working with a toxic colleague, 47% said the person was a peer at their own level, and only 10% pointed at their own manager or a leader above them. Because the toxic employee is usually a colleague, and not a manager, leadership typically misses the problem.

I see this from the other side of the table, too, as a board member sitting on audit and compensation committees. I have seen a rising executive’s outburst be excused as a rough patch while the same outburst happening two levels down becomes a disciplinary action. This often happens when there is no written conduct standard because leadership must weigh who the company can afford to lose. Gallup’s research points to the same weakness. Surveying 23,000 employed adults, it ranked creating accountability last among seven leadership competencies. Only 30% of managers rated their own leaders as outstanding at it, while 46% of leaders rated themselves that way.

Write the standard down

That gap is familiar to me. The remedy is to decide the standard before you know who it will apply to. It’s the exact problem background screening solves before someone is ever hired: a defensible background check leaves nothing to a manager’s gut feeling. It requires:

•      Stating in advance what’s being evaluated and why it’s job related.

•      Applying it to every candidate, regardless of who they are.

•      Reviewing unusual facts rather than relying on a blanket rule.

•      Documenting the reason so the decision holds up if questioned.

•      Allowing the candidate an opportunity to respond before anything is finalized.

We apply that rigor to a stranger before their first day but once they are hired, that rigor disappears. Decisions about employee conduct are made case by case, shaped by performance and rank, and rarely put on paper. Yet workers notice the difference: when 38% watch while nothing happens and 23% see bad behavior paying off, they learn what the real standard is, and it isn’t the one in the handbook.

The instinct is to watch people more closely but surveillance doesn’t build trust. It erodes it. What closes this gap is the discipline we already use before day one: put the policy in writing, apply it consistently, and record why.

Four questions worth asking

To determine if your organization has a conduct standard, ask yourself these four questions.

1.  Have you defined what conduct consistently makes work worse at your company? Vague rules let rank and revenue quietly fill the gap.

2.  Would the consequences be the same no matter who is involved? Workers ranked this their second-most requested fix, behind early manager intervention.

3.  Could you explain on paper why two similar situations were handled differently? If not, you have a discretion problem.

4.  Does the outcome change with the person’s rank? Two years of escalations, sorted by level, reveal more than any policy document.

What workers want

Workers already told us what would help, and none of it requires a new department or a new tool. The most requested fix was managers addressing problems early (61%). Consistent consequences, applied regardless of performance, came in second (52%). Nobody is asking for softer rules. Holding your best performer to the same bar as everyone else is harder than what most companies practice today.

I think about it the way I think about a background check. Nobody objects to that rigor applied to a stranger before their first day. The objection shows up once that same rigor gets asked of someone already inside the building, someone whose title makes an exception feel reasonable. I recommend putting it in writing before that decision gets made by default, one exception at a time.

Houman Akhavan is founder & CEO of GCheck.