For years, digital marketing measurement has relied primarily on “the click” to track success. As a customer searched, browsed, and (hopefully) converted into a sale, we could track their journey virtually every step of the way. While not as linear or clean as our models made it look, we had signals connecting discovery with actions.
AI is disrupting and sometimes eliminating those signals altogether. As customers increasingly use AI tools to research, compare options, and narrow their choices before visiting a brand’s website, that part of the journey is becoming invisible.
When I first joined Siteimprove earlier this year, our marketing operations director quickly acknowledged our data and reporting structure was holding the team back. It wasn’t built for the agentic era. But like many in that seat, the urgent kept pushing the important down the list.
Eventually, I blocked his calendar for two weeks so he could focus on fixing the issues. While not everything ran smoothly during that brief period, it was not nearly as chaotic as people had feared.
The transformative results meant we no longer waste time patching holes in old dashboards or devising new strategies based on incomplete information. Instead, we have an agent-aware measurement framework that lets us move faster and more accurately.
Here are my insights on how AI has changed our industry and what we need to do next.
THE CLICK IS NO LONGER ENOUGH
In fact, with half of consumers already using AI-powered search, McKinsey predicts traditional search traffic could decline by as much as 50%. Nearly two-thirds of marketing leaders say AI-driven discovery is their hardest channel to attribute, and 54% say it has weakened their confidence in existing attribution models. Only 8% can track its influence on revenue and conversions.
Those challenges point to the real issue: Most marketers are trying to measure an entirely new customer journey with a framework built for an older one. We built our reporting to track clicks, not conversations happening somewhere we can’t see. That has to change.
Every page, product description, or piece of thought leadership now has two audiences. First, humans and second, the AI systems deciding whether it’s credible and useful enough to surface, cite, and recommend. We need a new layer of measurement to capture this new audience data.
HOW TO BUILD AN AGENT-AWARE MEASUREMENT FRAMEWORK
Whether you’re a marketer or business owner, the key is to think like an AI agent. You need content that’s visible, credible, compelling, and a way to quantify it. Start by asking yourself these three questions:
1. DO YOU SHOW UP?
First, make sure your brand (or your client’s brand) shows up across the AI platforms your customers actually use. Measure how often your brand appears for key questions and how that compares to competitors. Marketing teams have spent years tracking their brands’ share of voice in search and media, and the same basic principle now applies to AI-generated answers.
Strong site performance there doesn’t guarantee AI visibility. Optimizing it is a smart place to start, but your site may represent only 5-10% of the sources AI search actually references, so you’ll want to gauge visibility beyond your digital perimeter, including affiliates and user-generated content.
2. HOW DO YOU SHOW UP?
The context in which a brand shows up in an AI-generated response matters. Track whether your company is cited as a source in AI results or included in a recommendation when an AI system compares options.
Then look at what’s actually being said.
Accuracy and sentiment are vital. If an answer cites outdated information, misrepresents your offering, or consistently links a competitor to a capability you want to own, simple visibility (from the first question above) can become a misleading vanity metric.
3. DOES AI SEARCH INFLUENCE OUTCOMES?
Showing up well needs to drive business outcomes. Establish a baseline today, then track movement of metrics such as citation rate, AI share of voice, and brand sentiment in connection to conversions over time.
The goal is to move beyond visibility as a standalone metric and understand how content optimization correlates with meaningful results.
FIX THE MEASUREMENT FOUNDATION FIRST
As more consumers turn to AI as their preferred search engine, marketers should prioritize measurement along with AI content strategy. In some cases, that may mean temporarily pausing the constant stream of reporting requests to fix the foundation underneath them.
Many marketers pride themselves on their ability to move quickly, but sometimes there’s immense value in pausing the “day-to-day.” That’s especially true when it comes to building a dynamic, AI-based measurement structure for your team.
Adding another dashboard to an attribution model built around clicks may give us more numbers, but it won’t necessarily give us a better understanding. Sometimes you have to hit full stop long enough to ask and answer: what exactly do we need to know? The result is often transformative.
As AI becomes a key participant in the customer journey, our measurement frameworks need to account for this “second audience” without losing sight of the first. The same qualities that earn a person’s trust, including clarity, accuracy, and structure, increasingly influence whether AI systems surface, cite or recommend our content.
Marketers have been working toward those standards for years. What’s changed is the need to measure whether we’re meeting them across both human and AI-driven discovery. The brands willing to pause the noise long enough to see the signal will have a much clearer picture of what’s influencing customers, even when there’s no click trail to follow.
Jen Jones is chief marketing officer at Siteimprove.