Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Before you sell, consider the crossover

Business owners should run the math on a successful acquisition.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Ron Smith

Founding Partner · Cordis Group

In my practice, most owners preparing to sell want to improve the business. A few want to make it bigger, and almost none ask whether to buy something first.

But in my work at the Cordis Institute, where we advise on acquisitions and sales, I’ve watched two owners in the same business sell a few years apart for very different numbers. The one who spent those years buying a rival and folding it in sold higher, and to a different buyer. The difference was size.

The reason is a quirk of how private companies are priced. The bigger the business, the more a buyer will pay for each dollar of profit it earns. Cross a certain size and price per dollar of profit jumps, and a new, deeper class of buyer starts bidding. Call it the crossover line.

While this article is not investment advice, I’ve seen businesses find a way past that crossover line: Buy a smaller competitor a few years before you sell, and fold it in.

What the crossover line is worth

Smaller companies tend to sell for a lower multiple of profit than larger ones, and the gap widens as a business grows.

The same dollar of profit can get a very different price, mostly due to the company’s size. To see what that is worth, calculate the deal in cash.

Say you earn $4 million in profits a year. At about 7 times, your company is worth roughly $28 million.

You buy a competitor earning $1 million. A business that small sells for around 5.5 times its profits, so it costs you $5.5 million in cash.

Now you earn $5 million, and combining the two saves another million in costs, for $6 million in profit. That pushes you into the next band, where buyers pay closer to 7.5 times, and the combined company is worth about $45 million.

You spent $5.5 million. Your company is now worth roughly $17 million more than it was. Every dollar you put in came back as about three dollars in value inside the business. Three things stacked to get there:

  • The $1 million in profit you bought is now valued at 7.5 times, not the 5.5 you paid, making it worth $7.5 million.
  • The $1 million in savings is now worth $7.5 million, without a separate purchase.
  • And the $4 million you already earned re-rated from 7 to 7.5 times, adding $2 million in value, simply because the company got bigger.

Who is allowed to buy you?

Crossing the line also changes who is bidding, which matters as much as the price. Below a certain size, your buyers are a thin crowd, mostly individuals and searchers. Each can borrow only what a government-backed loan allows, which runs out around $5 million.

Move up into the next band and the door opens to family offices and private equity firms, professional buyers that own similar companies and compete to add yours. Those add-on deals are now the majority of all buyouts. More buyers with deeper pockets, bidding against each other, turn a higher multiple into a higher price.

Why most of these deals fail

This approach is one of the hardest things an owner can try, and most who do fall behind. Think of the run-down house next door. When joined to your lot, it is worth more than the two apart, but only if you can genuinely renovate it, not just afford it.

Most acquisitions disappoint, because the math is what fools people.

And as our Cordis Institute working paper puts it, “on enterprise value, every version of this deal looks good…only the well-executed version survives.” Get it wrong, and you can possibly lose a quarter to a third of your money.

3 things that make a crossing work

In my experience, I’ve noticed there are three things separating a deal that transforms your exit from one that sinks it:

1. Conversion test fit: You’re bringing in a business in your own line of work that you understand well enough to truly absorb, not just a cheap pile of profit.

2. Execution: Combining the two into one clean company and paying off any purchase debt before you sell, so a buyer sees a healthy business, not a loaded one.

3. Timing: Leaving five to seven years for the combined company to settle, because buyers price the last two or three years.

Miss any one and the deal fails.

The hardest part is turning two companies into one, and experienced acquirers are far better at that than first-timers.

None of this makes buying before selling the right move for most owners. The honest answer is to grow, or to sell and diversify. The test is built to screen most owners out, not in.

But for the rare owner who can truly absorb what he buys and has the years to let it settle, the crossover line is one of the few late moves that changes what the company is worth. Before you decide, be honest about whether you are that owner.

Ron Smith is head of research at The Cordis Institute.