Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why high earners can still feel financially trapped

The choices your money provides are as important as the amount.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Ryan Walker

Senior Wealth Manager and CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER®, Meristead Wealth · Meristead Wealth

In financial planning, one of the most interesting things I see is that a high income does not always lead to financial freedom.

A couple may earn $300,000 or $400,000 a year, have a healthy investment portfolio, and own a comfortable home. Yet when the conversation shifts from net worth to choices, the picture can look very different. Could they step away from work for six months? Take a job that pays less but gives them more time? Start a business? Move somewhere they have always wanted to live?

Often, the answer is not yet. Because as income grows, the amount required to support our lives tends to grow with it.

The psychology behind lifestyle creep

Lifestyle creep is often discussed as if it were simply a spending problem. You get a raise and buy a nicer car. You get promoted and move into a bigger house. You start traveling differently or eating at better restaurants.

But the more interesting part is how quickly we adapt.

Things that once felt like upgrades eventually become normal. The house you stretched to buy becomes simply your house. The nicer hotel becomes where you prefer to stay. The convenience you once paid extra for becomes something you no longer want to give up.

Our definition of “enough” moves surprisingly quickly.

That helps explain why people can double their income without feeling twice as financially secure. Historic research on income adaptation suggests the initial happiness boost can fade as higher income becomes familiar. A 2023 study found that emotional well-being generally rises with income, but the relationship varies across people.

A higher number alone may not give everyone a sense of freedom when nearly every income increase gets absorbed into a higher permanent cost of living.As people become more successful, their expectations evolve too. They may live in a different neighborhood, send their children to different schools, upgrade travel, or become accustomed to earning a certain amount.

Over time, income can become tied to identity, making a career change surprisingly difficult. Taking a lower-paying position may make financial sense and still feel like a step backward. Leaving a senior role can feel uncomfortable even when you have enough money.

This is part of what makes golden handcuffs so powerful, especially when they’re built on the life and identity we create around a certain income level.

How much does your life require you to earn?

Imagine two households that each earn $300,000 a year. Identical incomes, but different financial lives.

As one household’s income rose, it gradually increased its spending on a larger mortgage, luxury vehicles, frequent travel, memberships, tuition, and other recurring expenses. Despite their wealth, maintaining their lifestyle requires their current income.

Another household also lives well, but each raise hasn’t automatically led to a larger lifestyle. They put some additional income toward investments, paying down debt, and building cash reserves.

If necessary or desirable, the second household can make a change, such as reducing one spouse’s hours. Someone could take a sabbatical, start a company, or accept a lower-paying position. A disruptive job loss wouldn’t immediately threaten their lifestyle.

They have built something beyond wealth. They have built something I call optionality.

Protect the optionality gap

The optionality gap is the difference between what you earn and what your life actually requires. The wider that gap becomes, the more choices money can give you.

So, someone earning $300,000 can decide intentionally which lifestyle upgrades genuinely make life better and which raise the amount you need to keep earning. You don’t need to live as though you earn $75,000.

A few questions can be revealing. If your income dropped by 30% tomorrow, how much would need to change? What once felt like a luxury but now feels essential? If you received a 20% raise, how much would go toward your lifestyle versus strengthening your financial position?

The value is in asking the questions before your lifestyle answers them for you.

What is the money for?

Most financial conversations focus on accumulation, including how much you earn, how much you save, and how large your portfolio becomes. Research on financial literacy links financial knowledge with retirement planning, resilience, and manageable debt.

But another question should follow: What is all this money supposed to allow you to do?

For some people, the answer is retiring young. For others, it may mean working part-time, changing careers, starting a business, moving abroad, spending more time with family, or knowing they don’t have to tolerate career burnout because of an indispensable paycheck.

High earners can easily miss that distinction. At its heart, financial success is more about reducing how much your future depends on earning at your current level. Lifestyle creep’s real danger is reaching a point where you have accumulated more wealth, more income, and more signs of success, but fewer choices than you expected.

At some point, earning more raises your freedom to choose, not just your standard of living.

Ryan Walker is
senior wealth manager at Meristead Wealth.