Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Competence can lose the fight for impact

Five communication imperatives for powerful leadership.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Christopher O.H. Williams

Managing Director · Custament Partners

When I was 11 years old and living in Sierra Leone, I took national exams to enter secondary school. Feeling triumphant afterward, I proudly announced to everyone that the test had been easy.

My father, a man of deep and enduring humility, pulled me aside and advised: “Son, don’t say that. Just say you did your best.”

That lesson stuck. Humility is a virtue taught early, and for good reason—nobody likes a braggart. Throughout my early executive career, I remained unwaveringly humble and self-effacing, guided by the self-modulation that my parents had inspired: Stay focused on impact and let the results speak for themselves. What matters is what others say about you when you leave the room, not what you claim for yourself.

I still believe this carries deep wisdom. Humility remains an important pillar of executive maturity. However, in an era dominated by self-styled experts, independent megaphones, and moneyed interests steering mass communications, we must ask a hard question: Is the restraint we were coached to embody serving our work—or is it actively eroding our legacy?

The cost of sacrificial silence

Along my professional journey, I began to see cracks in the “quiet merit” philosophy. In one corporate role, a manager confided that one of my peers routinely walked into their office and threatened to resign unless she received raises and promotions.

True to my nature, I had never exercised that kind of leverage—but simply put my head down, trusting that my talent and output would be recognized. Yet that peer moved up the ladder significantly faster.

“You should tout yourself and demand more,” the executive counseled.

That advice sat uncomfortably with me, and remained unused long after that conversation. I still value genuine humility over self-aggrandizing noise. But experience has taught me that humility has limits.

Corporate leadership forums frequently discuss “impostor syndrome,” the phenomenon in which highly capable individuals hold back from deserved opportunities, driven by self-doubt. But we rarely confront its dangerous twin, the Dunning-Kruger Effect, in which the least competent act with unshakeable confidence and get rewarded with visibility, budget, and advancement.

This isn’t merely an interpersonal issue. In The Unseen Leader, historian Martin Gutmann details how the methodical savant of polar explorer Roald Amundsen was long overshadowed in popular history by the far less competent—but infinitely better-marketed—Ernest Shackleton. Society routinely favors a dramatic narrative over quiet operational efficacy.

When competent professionals labor without fanfare, their achievements look easy from the outside. If they do not explicitly frame and claim their value, they are rarely credited. Meanwhile, opportunists can make a public show of minimal output, and garner praise for manufactured genius.

This systemic clash happens in all spheres of life and in public discourse, with substance versus spectacle (or merit versus megaphones). Competence muzzles itself and loud incompetence steps into the vacuum.

When progress is erased

If competent stewards refuse to market and defend their work, the consequences extend far beyond missed promotions or recognition denied. Whole systems regress.

Decades of painstaking progress—crafted by humble experts who assumed their results were self-evident—are being dismantled overnight. Disingenuous voices peddle glib, simplistic alternatives to complex problems, discrediting deep expertise through sheer volume of talk, bravado, and disinformation. Public policies and corporate frameworks that serve organizations and communities for generations are overturned and replaced with… nothing.

Why? Because their original architects believed good work would sell itself.

It won’t. Abdication of stewardship in the name of humility is not effective leadership; it is an active organizational risk. When competence remains sacrificially silent, society and businesses forfeit their hard-won gains and slide backward.

5 communication imperatives for leaders

To protect progress, we must act. Pride in rigorous work and confidence in proven capability are not arrogance; they are essential truth-telling. Communicating or defending your accomplishments is not self-aggrandizement but an essential act of stewardship.

If you don’t articulate the value of what you have built, you leave it vulnerable to those who will happily tear it down out of spite, self-interest, or ignorance. Effective leadership requires bringing stakeholders along through an intentional narrative.

I’ve adopted five communication imperatives for leaders who wish to protect their legacy and maintain organizational momentum.

1. Articulate the common vision: Don’t just present tactical solutions. Constantly remind your team and stakeholders of the overarching vision you are solving for, anchoring every win to that shared purpose.

2. Demystify the friction: Share both the breakthrough and the grit required to achieve it. When you make complex work look effortless, observers assume anyone could do it—opening the door for reckless alternatives. Turn operational friction into organizational learning.

3. Validate the victories: Continuously demonstrate why a successful outcome matters and what would be lost if it were dismantled. Connect every win back to the mission and never assume people remember the baseline you started from.

4. Defend the ground gained: When bad-faith critiques or flawed alternatives threaten proven progress, confront them directly. Explain the operational reality and why the alternative is insufficient. Don’t allow silence in the face of misdirection to be construed as consent.

5. Popularize the overarching narrative: Repeat the story often enough that others can tell it in your absence. Don’t be the sole champion of your team’s achievements. Instead, empower them and other cheerleaders to own the narrative too.

Reclaim the narrative

I still deeply treasure the lesson my father taught me. Humility remains a vital anchor for character and leadership ethics. But decades in executive boardrooms have taught me an equally crucial truth: Humility is a virtue, but silence is dereliction.

If we care about our work, the people we lead, and the progress we have fought to achieve, we can no longer leave the microphone to the loudest voices in the room who only seek to redefine excellence. Competence must learn to speak for itself—or accept being spoken over.

Christopher Williams is the president and managing director of Custament Partners.