Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why marketers misread Gen Z’s contradictions

Brands that understand the tension behind Gen Z’s contradictions will connect better than those chasing another archetype.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Joshua Nu U Steele

Gen Z has a contradiction problem.

They track their sleep but stay up late scrolling. They distrust institutions but seek guidance constantly. They grew up online but increasingly want to get off their phones. They care deeply about individuality yet long to belong to a community.

It’s easy to conclude that Gen Z doesn’t know what it wants. But after surveying 2,100 Gen Z consumers across the U.S., U.K., and Australia, I think marketers have the diagnosis backward. Gen Z has clear preferences.

What looks like contradiction is Gen Z responding to the conditions they’re living in.

Raised on shifting ground

Over the last decade, institutions that once supported people through adulthood have quietly shifted that responsibility onto individuals. Career paths are less predictable, financial milestones feel less guaranteed, and trust in institutions has declined. Community has become something you have to actively seek, and even identity takes more effort than it used to.

Gen Z came of age inside that shift. Much of what gets labeled inconsistency is really a rational response to changing conditions. Gen Z is essentially triaging, constantly optimizing to meet the demands of modern life. They are recalculating what’s worth their limited time, trust, and energy.

In the survey we conducted with Ogilvy, we looked at marketing’s four most common stereotypes about Gen Z.

1. Energy

    The stereotype is that Gen Z is lazy, entitled, or puts self-care above responsibility. They are the generation that popularized quiet quitting and mental health days.

    Yet our survey found that work is one of the last things Gen Z cuts when life gets overwhelming. Sleep is the first thing they cut back, and 76% told us they’re actively trying to manage their energy. If anything, they are an overcommitted generation.

    2. Authority

    We think Gen Z distrusts institutions, rejects expertise, and wants to figure everything out on their own. However, our data found only 1 in 5 want to decide things fully alone. Most want a trusted sounding board, not a directive.

    3. Belonging

    We assume Gen Z is isolated, online, and either doesn’t care about community or has replaced real connection with parasocial internet relationships. Although 62% say self-expression matters deeply, they still seek a sense of belonging. However, under 20% say belonging comes naturally. Nearly three-quarters say they must actively work to create a sense of belonging with 42% achieving it through fandoms and hobby groups and 44% through friendships.

    4. Technology

    Gen Z was raised on screens, so it’s assumed they prefer digital life over physical presence. However, our data shows that 52% want more in-person time, more than they want additional travel (42%), fitness (35%), or entertainment (37%). Only 6% feel satisfied with the in-person time they get now.

    That scarcity of in-person time may explain why their AI use is so split. They are fluent and quick to adopt, but nearly a quarter of U.S. Gen Z opts out of AI tools entirely. The U.K. is the only market with a net positive AI-connection score with 29% of Gen Z feeling more connected with AI, versus 22% who feel less connected. The U.S. and Australia both have net negative scores, but for different reasons. In the U.S., the drag comes from a large non-adoption group—24% of American Gen Zers don’t use AI tools at all. In Australia, AI adoption is higher, but 31% feel less connected as a result of using it.

    Both can be true

    Which version is the real Gen Z—contradictory and confused or rational and pragmatic? I believe both are true and that marketers need to better understand the challenges Gen Zers face. Gen Z is being forced to negotiate between optimization and enjoyment, autonomy and support, individuality and belonging, and digital convenience and physical presence.

    Meanwhile, there is a disconnect between what marketers believe about Gen Z and what Gen Z believes about itself. Our data found only 30% of Gen Z believe brands truly understand them.

    Another generational archetype probably isn’t going to fix that. A better place to start is with the conditions producing Gen Z’s behavior: a daily life is full of contradictions.

    Instead of creating a single archetype brief, marketers should ask which of these four most common stereotypes their brand is currently helping Gen Z to resolve. Then test your messaging and learn which tension your audience is currently negotiating, rather than assuming what consumers feel.

    Joshua Nu’u Steele is cofounder and chief revenue officer at Ideally.