Company leaders spend an extraordinary amount of time talking about culture. Companies articulate values, develop leadership principles, conduct engagement surveys, and gather employees for town halls designed to explain the kind of organization they aspire to become.
Much of that work can be useful, but employees are also receiving another set of messages every day. They watch who gets promoted, which numbers get the most attention, what behavior gets rewarded, which failures carry consequences, and what leaders are willing to tolerate when a high performer delivers results.
Across my career in consulting and executive roles, I have worked in industries as different as banking, technology, construction, manufacturing, industrials, and financial services. The operating models vary considerably, but the mechanics of organizational behavior are pretty consistent. People learn quickly what an institution truly values because organizations continuously create conscious and unconscious incentives.
If leaders want to understand their culture, they should examine the entire system of rewards, consequences, and status that surrounds their employees.
Every metric teaches people something
Consider a company that tells its sales organization to build enduring customer relationships but only celebrates new bookings. Or an organization that says collaboration is essential while promotions disproportionately go to individuals who maximize their own functions’ performance. Leadership may sincerely believe in the stated value, but employees have little difficulty interpreting the operating signal.
This is one reason poorly designed performance systems can create unexpected behavior without anyone explicitly directing employees to behave badly. People optimize around what the organization makes important. A target influences where they spend time. A compensation plan affects which opportunities receive attention. A promotion demonstrates which behavior the company associates with advancement.
I have seen the importance of those connections from the financial side of organizations, particularly when working on pricing, sales strategy, forecasting, and staff performance. A decision that appears to be a financial mechanism often becomes a behavioral mechanism once it reaches the organization. Change the metric and you can change which customers a salesperson pursues, which projects a manager prioritizes, or how aggressively a business unit pushes for growth and/or margin.
What you tolerate can matter more than what you reward
Imagine an organization that describes teamwork as a core value but continually protects a manager who produces strong results while creating dysfunction around them. The company may never formally reward the behavior, yet every employee who observes it internalizes that performance buys an exception to the stated standard.
Leaders create similar signals when deadlines are treated differently depending on who misses them, when poor management is overlooked because someone possesses valuable technical expertise, or when one department is allowed to bypass processes everyone else must follow. These decisions can seem isolated when viewed individually. Collectively, they establish the boundaries of acceptable behavior.
Culture therefore lives partly in what an organization refuses to trade. Employees will notice whether leadership preserves its principles when doing so becomes inconvenient, expensive, or personally uncomfortable. Values that survive only when there is no cost attached to them are unlikely to have much influence on behavior.
When an employee is significantly out of line with the company’s intended culture, they should not be allowed to remain in their role. They can significantly damage the larger team and organization by overlooking critical system culture issues.
This does not require rigidly treating every situation the same way. Good management requires context and judgment. It does require leaders to understand that every visible exception is also an organizational communication and a cultural risk.
Promotions may be the strongest cultural signal of all
Compensation tells employees what the company wants this year. Promotions tell them what kind of person succeeds there. That makes succession and advancement decisions particularly consequential. When someone moves into leadership, the organization signals which behaviors, capabilities, and results it values.
If executives want collaboration but consistently promote the strongest individual operators, they should not be surprised when ambitious employees focus on individual visibility. If leaders want innovation but advancement goes to predominantly workhorses who carry on the process, employees will learn to avoid calculated risk.
Companies should consider promotions and compensation for the traits they are prioritizing at a given time. Those decisions will largely drive the company’s culture.
Culture as an organizational system
Good company cultures include prioritizing a purpose and values. Organizations need language that describes the standards they are trying to create. But those aspirations become credible only when the company’s operating system reinforces them.
Company leadership cannot dictate every aspect of organizational culture, and employees are motivated by far more than statements. But leaders exercise enormous influence over the environment in which behavior takes place through their own actions, decisions, and incentives. Every organization has a system that tells people, explicitly or otherwise, what it wants to see in people management.
Our company values reflect whether someone could accurately infer them simply by watching what the company rewards, promotes, measures, and permits.
Erik Clarke is chief financial officer of Trans Lease.