Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

16 ways to handle conflict inside leadership teams

What to do when the people making decisions don’t agree.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

When conflict arises among leadership teams, the best laid plans can get derailed. Arguments and counterarguments can cause a decision-making stalemate. Conflict that turns personal can create an environment where leaders don’t feel they can do their best work.

Left unchecked, conflict can destroy team dynamics. The fallout can reverberate throughout the organization. So how do leaders defuse conflict when it arises? We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members to weigh in. Here’s what 16 of those members shared on keeping heated situations under control.

1. CALL OUT BAD PATTERNS

In every leadership conflict I’ve been in the middle of, the issue being argued is the smallest part of what’s happening. Two people are usually defending old instincts—the habits that protected each of them years ago. And those instincts are steering a decision they were never meant to touch. I built this company with my former bosses, the people who used to manage me, so I’ve watched plenty of ego and history collide in one room. When we name that pattern out loud and set it next to the real problem, the heat drops fast. We also have a “code” word, if needed! — Natanya Wachtel, New Solutions Network

2. SEEK CLARITY

When conflict arises within a leadership team, my priority is clarity. I meet with each party individually to understand their perspective, where alignment broke down, and what’s at stake. From there, it becomes about bringing the right people back together with a shared understanding of the facts. Strong teams don’t avoid conflict: They work through it with respect and accountability. In most cases, resolution emerges when everyone is aligned around the mission and committed to moving forward together. — Stan Gregor, Summit Financial

3. DETERMINE THE TYPE OF CONFLICT

There are two types of conflict. There are sincere differences of opinion. Allowing them to play out is healthy and frequently leads to better outcomes. When there is no conflict of this type, there is something wrong. Then there are personality clashes that result from fear and selfishness that often become disrespectful. I confront the latter and encourage the former by focusing the team on the big picture: What is the vision, what are the common goals, and what are clients trying to accomplish, etc. — Robert Sprague, Yes&

4. DEVELOP RULES AROUND DISAGREEMENTS

We have a few steadfast rules about conflict within our leadership team. The first rule is to listen and hear all viewpoints (aka put our skunks on the wall). The second rule is to agree on what the original goal of the situation—and argue on it. And finally, work to move towards each other for an agreement. When all else fails, we have a code word to try and level emotions and get us to a common place. It at least makes us laugh when we have to use it…if nothing else! — Maggie ONeill, Peppercomm

5. TEACH HEALTHY CONFLICT

It’s important to remember that not all conflict is bad. For leadership teams, healthy conflict can actually lead to smarter decisions and better results. How do you tell the difference? Unhealthy conflict can be identified by personal attacks, interrupting others, and a desire to win. Healthy conflict is marked by respectful listening, willingness to support the decision of the group, and a desire to contribute. Often, teaching leaders how to conflict effectively can lead to outstanding results. — Christina Robbins, Digitech Systems, LLC

6. FACE-TO-FACE RESOLUTION

I get everyone in the same room (or sometimes on the same call), fast! Not a thread, not a chain of emails where something can get misconstrued. Nothing beats face-to-face communication! Tension often comes from people filling in what they don’t know with assumptions. The only real cure for that is a straight-up conversation between everyone involved at the same time. — Tavares Beverly, Beverly Boy Productions

7. TACKLE IT EARLY

I address it early and directly, with care and empathy. We get clear on what the real issue is, align on the goal, and talk through what needs to change moving forward. Healthy teams do not avoid conflict: They learn how to work through it without damaging trust. — Angie Hughes, Let’s Do Good

8. CONFRONT PROBLEMS ALONG THE WAY

We’re all comfortable being really open and honest with each other, even when that means getting confrontational. I’m a big believer that if you’re always having the little micro-disagreements as they come up, you never build toward a massive blowup. Conflict doesn’t tend to explode for us because we never let it sit and fester. It’s a lot healthier to address the small things constantly than to avoid friction until it becomes something bigger. — Zander Cook, Lease End

9. MAKE THE COUNTERARGUMENT

Most of it traces back to something simpler than a clash of personalities. Two sharp people reasoning from different facts, arguing their conclusions while the inputs never get compared. So, the first move is getting the real evidence on the table where everyone sees the same thing. Then I ask each person to make the other’s case, out loud, as well as they can. Half the time someone argues themselves partway across the room. The rule underneath all of it is simple: We spar hard while the decision is open, and the moment it is made we commit and execute, even the people who lost the argument. — Michael Quoc, Product.ai

10. DON’T CONFUSE PASSION FOR CONFLICT

Luckily, I do not see it often. But when conflict does happen inside our leadership team, it is usually passion-driven, not ego-driven. That changes how the conversation should be handled. People care deeply about the work, the client, the team, and the outcome. So, disagreements are usually a sign that something matters deeply. My role is to keep the conversation focused, make sure everyone is heard, and help turn the tension into clarity. The goal is not to remove friction, but to use it to make better decisions. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion

11. KEEP PRIORITIES CENTRAL

Reframe disagreements and focus on priorities and constraints. Most leadership conflict comes down to limited resources, especially in smaller businesses or teams. Naming those tradeoffs explicitly shifts the conversation from opinions to problem-solving and helps the team align on a clear path forward. — Mark Valentino, Citizens

12. HANDLE IT EARLY AND RESPECTFULLY

I address it directly and early, even if the situation is uncomfortable. Unresolved tension can slow progress, make working relationships adversarial, and impact decision-making. I encourage open communication, focus discussions on objectives rather than personalities, and make sure everyone understands the business goals we’re working toward. Healthy disagreement often leads to better outcomes when it’s handled respectfully and productively. — Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC

13. ARGUE THE OTHER PERSON’S POSITION

I’d rather have the disagreement out loud than smoothed over in the meeting and relitigated in side conversations afterward. When two leaders are stuck, I make them argue the other person’s position before going back to their own, because most leadership conflict is really two people solving for different things and not realizing it. Once the actual tradeoff is on the table, the decision usually gets easier. — Daniel Haiem, AppMakers USA

14. FOCUS ON OBJECTIVES

I orient my team back to the work at hand. What do we need to do, as a team, to reach our objectives or targets? Is the conflict because of the work, or something else? Bringing the discussion (group or otherwise) back to the how we are or aren’t advancing as a team can diffuse the conflict and reframe next steps in a neutral way. — Pen Stanton, StudioForecast

15. DON’T LET IT SIMMER

Generally speaking, it shows that the participants care enough to challenge the premise. The only question is if the discussion is about reaching the correct conclusion, not about anyone being defensive or worried about their ego. On leadership teams, I champion having conversations upfront and early. A small argument resolved on the spot tends to remain a small argument. A simmering disagreement usually erupts into a full-blown fight later. If we all commit to focusing on the goal rather than the right to be correct, then discussion becomes useful, not destructive. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand, Blushush Technologies

16. GIVE REAL-TIME FEEDBACK

I handle conflict by addressing it directly, early, and in the room where it belongs. Real-time feedback prevents small issues from becoming narratives. I disable triangulation by sending concerns back to the right people for direct resolution. I expect leaders to debate rigorously, but with respect, facts, and shared ownership. I also reward healthy team dynamics, not just outcomes. The “what” matters, but so does the “how,” because durable performance depends on trust, candor, and the ability to disagree without fracturing the team. — Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union