They have deep experience. Their education and credentials are impressive. Their skill set matches the role you need filled. But adding new team members to your organization goes beyond what’s on their résumé. Organizational fit matters. Getting that wrong can cost you in time, money, and effort. So, what do you look for that shows someone isn’t a good fit?
We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members about the cultural red flags they look for or try to uncover during the hiring process. Here are 20 you may want to notice—and avoid—in new hires.
1. RISK AND COMPLIANCE IS NOT THEIR PROBLEM
When someone positions risk and compliance as someone else’s problem, that is a red flag. In an interview, it shows up subtly. Credit flows toward their own decisions, and friction gets attributed to legal, human resources, or whoever was not in the room. In my experience, that person avoids the hard conversations, routes around the people they should be working with, and creates blind spots in the places where accountability matters most. In my world, those blind spots have real consequences for the business and for the people moving through the hiring process. The right candidates are the ones who ask the hard question before someone else has to. — Courtney Dutter, ICIMS
2. LATE TO ARRIVE
Being on time or early for work each day is something I value and appreciate. For me, timeliness is a leading indicator of future success or failure. It shows that you care about your work, respect your employer, and have a desire to be treated seriously. Yet so many people have a causal approach to being on time. Trust me, your employer knows who is on time and it does matter. — Andrew Kryder, The Kryder Law Group
3. ATTACHMENT TO OLD WORK HABITS
Artificial intelligence is driving a profound shift in how businesses operate, how decisions get made, and how value is created. As organizations rethink workflows and operating models, one of the biggest red flags for me is when someone is overly attached to how work gets done today. People who thrive are the ones willing to reimagine roles, question existing processes, and stay curious. As AI continues to advance and disrupt, adaptability, a growth mindset, and a willingness to embrace change are what will enable individuals and organizations to evolve alongside it and create better outcomes. — Guillaume Lardeux, Genesys
4. INABILITY TO OWN PAST MISTAKES
The way I assess candidates is by evaluating their communication style when describing challenging circumstances. I focus on how they respond to obstacles but am not concerned about whether they overcome them. A person’s unwillingness and inability to take ownership of their mistakes is the biggest red flag for me. Therefore, everyone I consider hiring has a story that shows how they learned from making bad choices, being given bad advice, or allowing themselves to miss a major opportunity. Individuals who typically relate everything back to being the hero in their stories tend to have difficulty when the rubber meets the road. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
5. HOW SOMEONE TALKS ABOUT THEIR LAST TEAM
If every former manager was bad, every coworker was difficult, and nothing was ever their fault, that pattern usually follows them. I’m not looking for people who pretend past jobs were perfect. I want candidates who can name what went wrong and their part in it. Self-awareness in an interview is one of the best predictors of how someone handles friction once they’re on the team. — Daniel Haiem, AppMakers USA
6. FAILED ANSWERS TO TEAM-BASED QUESTIONS
While there are exceptions, generally the work environment requires individuals to work with others to accomplish shared goals. Yet, some folks simply don’t work well with a team, making them ill-suited to many jobs. During interviews, I like to ask candidates the following questions about their experiences working with others: Do they like it? Why/Why not? What role do they typically play in group work (coordinator, contributor, aggregator, etc.) Where have they seen group projects work well/fail and what happened? Their answers can tell you whether they would thrive in your culture and job. — Christina Robbins, Digitech Systems, LLC
7. FAILURE TO QUESTION THEIR OWN PLAN
During interviews I look for signs that a candidate is open to change. I test this by pushing back on their answers and asking them to revisit a specific decision. I will ask: Looking back, was there another way you could have achieved the same outcome? Did you consider that path at the time, and if not, why? I listen for whether they explore multiple paths and bring in other perspectives or operate in isolation. The biggest cultural red flag for me is simple: If someone cannot question their own plan, they will eventually break your culture. — Trent Cotton, ICIMS
8. HOW THEY TREAT TEAM MEMBERS
I’ve seen it play out time and again—how someone treats the people in their team—the assistant, the junior, the colleague who just got passed over. Faux charm aimed up the org chart is not culture or respect for anyone. Warmth aimed sideways and down is the whole game. A group that called me family went silent the week I had a near fatal accident at their event, while people with nothing to gain showed up hard—that’s where I learned to read it. The ones I trust are warm when no one’s keeping score. — Natanya Wachtel, New Solutions Network
9. THE PERSON WHO AGREES TOO FAST
In an interview it reads as alignment. On a team it is the most expensive hire you will make. Someone whose instinct is to be liked will tell you what you want to hear at the exact moment you need to hear what you got wrong. I run a company built on the idea that the popular answer and the true one are often different. I cannot staff that with people who reflexively reach for agreement. So, I am listening for the opposite. The people who will push back with evidence, and tell me the hard thing before I am ready to hear it, are the ones I trust most. That kind of candor is what keeps a company honest. — Michael Quoc, Product.ai
10. NOT OWNING THE WORK
Mistakes happen, priorities shift, and projects are always somewhat messy. But when someone immediately points elsewhere instead of understanding their part in the larger outcome, it becomes harder for the rest of the team to navigate. Strong teams are not made of people who are always right. They are made of people who care enough to take charge, take responsibility, adjust, and make things easier for the teams around them. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion
11. LACK OF CURIOSITY
This can show up as a lack of research in other elements of the company beyond the role they are interviewing for and little interest or ability to connect with others in the room. When you ask if they have questions, they…don’t. In our company, we want people to connect the dots between business divisions, geographies, and experiences. So, we need people who are genuinely curious about what they aren’t experiencing as well as their day-to-day responsibilities. — Erin Fuller, MCI
12. THE “IT’S JUST A JOB” CANDIDATE
A big red flag is when we see early signals from a candidate that this is just going to be a job to pay the bills, rather than something they’re actually excited about. We try to only hire exceptional people who are excited about the impact they can make here. So, if they’re already focused on how much time they’ll get away from the work before they’ve even started, they’re probably not the kind of person who’s going to be energized by what we’re building. — Zander Cook, Lease End
13. EXCUSES, NOT OWNERSHIP
The one huge cultural red flag for me is when someone always has an excuse but almost never has ownership. I have worked with people who were phenomenally gifted, and at every single missed deadline or problem, they would reason it. I can teach people skills. I can make someone better at writing, strategy, and communications. Ownership is different. The people who are successful on teams are always those who say, “I could have done a better job at this,” and then actually proceed to do it. That sort of accountability will build rapport with you more quickly than any resumé ever can. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand, Blushush Technologies
14. LACK PERSONAL BRAND UNDERSTANDING
A major red flag in hiring when you meet a potential talent or even a new partner, especially when you work in the advertising and marketing industry, is when they struggle revealing their personal brand when being interviewed. If they can’t differentiate who they are, define their own unique identity, or articulate their superpowers or strengths, this could be a sign that they don’t know how to identify any basics, nor communicate and problem solve in a way that stands out and makes an impact. — Ly Tran, stiletto collective
15. LACK OF OWNERSHIP
The biggest red flag for me is a lack of ownership. Skills can be taught, but accountability is much harder to develop. I look for people who take responsibility, solve problems proactively, and don’t wait to be told what to do because I don’t need more to do. In a fast-paced branding/PR agency environment like ours, every team member has to be able to think critically, communicate clearly, and follow through on commitments. This helps prevent bottlenecks. — Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC
16. NO FAILURES TO SPEAK OF
Someone who can walk you through everything they’ve accomplished, but if you ask them to tell you about something they failed at, they go blank. If you’ve never dealt with failure or had some part of a project go sideways, you’ve either not done enough or you’re not being straight with me. Either way, these are both red flags in my book. — Tavares Beverly, Beverly Boy Productions
17. NOT INTERESTED IN COMPANY CULTURE
The biggest flag for me is when a candidate doesn’t ask about culture and/or has not done any research into whether culture matters for us. Culture is such a driver of whether a new hire succeeds or fails, so aligning on this at the start is essential. Also, if the candidate has no questions at all. Curiosity is key for culture to thrive. — Maggie ONeill, Peppercomm
18. COMPETENCE, BUT POOR ATTITUDE
The biggest red flag is a poor attitude masked by competence: low ownership, low humility, and low curiosity. Skills can be taught. Disposition is harder to change. I look for people who are mission-driven, service-oriented, emotionally intelligent, and willing to put team and customer ahead of ego. Servant leadership matters at every level. So does a growth mindset: asking better questions, seeking feedback, and adapting under pressure. Talent that drains trust or resists learning creates hidden cost. The best hires combine capability with humility and purpose. — Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union
19. SELF-CENTEREDNESS
Ambition and self-reliance are both fine, but a potential hire who minimizes the contributions of others, takes credit for work that was not their own, or exhibits no interest in colleagues will not do well in our mutually supportive culture. We’re not hiring that person. He talked more in his interview about himself than he did about me! — Robert Sprague, Yes&
20. LACK OF SELF-AWARENESS
When someone can’t tell me about a time when they were wrong. In this industry, things go sideways constantly: a vendor falls through, a speaker cancels, the venue floods two days before show day. If you can’t own a mistake, you can’t problem-solve one. I’m not hiring perfect. I’m hiring self-aware. — Diana Sabb, Create Something Amazing