Sometimes it’s hard to draw a line between executive coaching and internal feedback. Both involve understanding what a leader is doing, and why. But coaching is concentrated and can focus on more: personal growth, decision-making, management, leadership, and handling situations. Investing in executive coaching can be expensive, paying off when leaders do a better job in some or all aspects of their work, and through retention and job satisfaction.
Deciding when to invest in executive leadership and for which leaders is an important choice. We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members to share how they think about this type of coaching and how they prioritize who to focus on. Here is what 20 Executive Board members told us about their executive coaching approach for their direct reports and other company leaders.
1. OPENNESS TO GROWTH
I recommend executive coaching when a team member shows real openness to grow and takes feedback seriously. It’s not about fixing weaknesses; it’s about helping strong performers sharpen their leadership edge through honest conversation and self-awareness. The goal is to help them unlock their full potential and lead with greater impact. — Stan Gregor, Summit Financial
2. EXPANDING A ROLE
I recommend executive coaching when someone is stepping into a bigger role than their current habits can support. Not as remediation, but as expansion. If a leader is technically strong but struggling with communication, influence, or strategic thinking, coaching accelerates maturity before friction turns into burnout. — Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC
3. NEEDS LEADERSHIP JUDGMENT
I recommend executive coaching when a direct report is already delivering strong results, but the next level of growth depends less on technical skill and more on leadership judgment. The right moment is usually when someone is taking on broader responsibility, managing people, or influencing across teams. I do not use coaching as a fix for poor performance. I use it as an investment in high-potential operators who are ready to become stronger leaders. — Boris Dzhingarov, ESBO ltd
4. GET UNSTUCK
I find coaching to be helpful when there’s a feeling of being stuck, i.e. there’s a feeling of lack of growth in the role, or when someone is unclear on how to allocate priorities. I lean into my coaching background to provide some initial coaching, and from there, I can detect when a higher dosage of coaching is appropriate. — Max Azarov, Novakid
5. PREPARE FOR THE FUTURE
As the owner of a fast-paced agency, I want to make sure my team never stops growing. I have seen and genuinely believe that when we are developing, the clients and whole team feels it. Executive coaching can be about helping someone master a new skill or step up into a leadership role that we believe they are built for, but they may not see. Executive coaching is about preparing for the future. When I think about succession planning or our next phase of growth, I want to be intentional about developing our internal leaders while we’re doing great work, and not out of rushed necessity. — Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw, First and Last PR
6. AN OUTSIDE PERSPECTIVE
Honestly? When I don’t know how to help. Getting an outside perspective, along with strategies to navigate the things they are struggling with, is not something you can provide as a manager when you are so close to it. I’ve seen lightbulbs go off, better habits formed, and the mental health of an employee improve because of great coaching. — Kim Bode, 8THIRTYFOUR
7. TO MOVE PAST REPEATED FEEDBACK
I recommend coaching when a leader’s scope jumps and the same “growth feedback” keeps repeating (delegation, priorities, conflict, exec communication). It only works if they’re bought in, never as punishment or to dodge a tough performance conversation. I would frame it as an operating-system upgrade with one or two measurable goals and a review window (8–12 weeks) to confirm behavior change. — Daniel Haiem, AppMakers USA
8. COACHING IS THE OPERATING SYSTEM
Every partner at our company gets continuous, specific feedback tied to our cultural source code. If you are falling short, you will know. Most companies treat coaching as an intervention. Someone is struggling, so you bring in an outside expert. That framing is backwards. Coaching is not the emergency brake. It is the operating system. Where I see value in outside coaching is when someone hits a capability ceiling that internal feedback alone cannot address, like a leadership transition. But if your culture does not already function as a coaching environment, an outside coach is a patch on broken infrastructure. — Michael Quoc, SimplyCodes by Product.ai
9. LEADERS DRIVING MAJOR CHANGE
Executive coaching is especially valuable when leaders drive major change, such as tech adoption or organizational transformation. Even the best solutions can fail if teams lack context or enthusiasm. Coaching helps leaders communicate the “why” so everyone understands the problem and their role in solving it. I tend to look for coaches who think independently and challenge conventional leadership formulas, rather than repeating frameworks like “The 7 Habits.” Those conversations help leaders develop their own style instead of following someone else’s playbook. — Daragh Mahon, Werner
10. SCOPE EXPANDS FASTER THAN SUPPORT SYSTEM
I recommend executive coaching when someone’s scope is expanding faster than their support system. That usually shows up as a strong performer who is starting to lead through more complexity, influence cross-functionally, or navigate higher-stakes decisions. Coaching helps them build repeatable leadership habits before stress turns into strain. — Stephanie Harris, PartnerCentric
11. NEW PEOPLE MANAGERS
Anyone who steps into a people management role for the first time should get the benefit of manager training or executive coaching. I remember when I first became an associate creative director in an agency and realized that in addition to client deliverables, I had to contend with other people’s problems. I really could have used coaching back then so that I could have been a better manager. — Roger Wong, BuildOps
12. PROACTIVE, NOT REACTIVE
Executive coaching is most valuable when it’s proactive, not corrective. When a leader is stepping into a broader role or navigating increased complexity, coaching can make a meaningful difference. At its best, coaching sharpens decision-making, builds confidence, and helps leaders step back to see the bigger picture. That preparation is critical for guiding teams through transitions with clarity and conviction. — Mark Valentino, Citizens
13. A THINKING PARTNER
I bring in executive coaching when the stakes outgrow the leader’s current support system. Bigger roles bring political complexity, pressure, and isolation. Coaching gives them a thinking partner who isn’t invested in internal dynamics. That outside perspective strengthens judgment, resilience, and communication. It protects both the leader and the organization. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
14. EMPLOYEE INITIATIVE
I recommend executive coaching when someone is stepping into a bigger version of their role. A promotion, higher stakes, broader influence. Skill got them here. Perspective will take them further. Sometimes the signal is subtle. Strong performance with friction in communication or confidence under pressure. A coach helps them see their own patterns clearly. The best signal is initiative. When someone wants to think sharper and lead better, that is the moment to invest. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Blushush and Ohh My Brand
15. AS ACCELERATION
Not as a “fix,” but as acceleration. In creative industries, it’s especially valuable when craft is strong but business strategy, presence, and leadership start to limit impact. The goal is to build leadership muscle before the stakes get high. Done right, coaching turns instinct into repeatable judgment you can scale. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion
16. WHEN SCALE OUTPACES SELF-AWARENESS
When scale outpaces self-awareness. Coaching is most valuable when leaders move from operator to decision architect. At that level, blind spots create systemic risk. — Kevin Leyes, LeyesX
17. PROMOTIONS
Promotion is often the moment a leader’s best trait starts quietly working against them. Speed, conviction, and independence are exactly what get someone promoted—but as teams and stakes grow, those same traits can create blind spots. That’s usually when I recommend coaching. Not because something is wrong, but because scaling leadership requires recalibrating how you see yourself and how others experience you. — Natanya Wachtel, New Solutions Network
18. DURING MEANINGFUL CHANGE
I recommend coaching when someone is navigating meaningful change in their career, from exploring a new industry or area of the business to stepping into a bigger role. The right coach creates space to sharpen decision-making, strengthen communication, and build confidence as leaders grow into their next level of impact. — Val Vacante, Collabsco
19. LEVEL-UP THEIR DECISION-MAKING
In our case, it’s less about polishing executive presence and more about helping someone level-up their decision-making and/or strategic chops. Because most people on our team aren’t outwardly representing the company publicly, executive presence training isn’t always the primary focus. But when someone is stepping into a bigger leadership role or managing larger teams, a coach can be a useful way to accelerate that transition. — Zander Cook, Lease End
20. ALL LEADERS
If it’s available, I recommend it to everyone in a leadership role. We’ve run executive and leadership coaching for our managers at the start of each year, for several years. It helps align personal development with business goals and gives people space to work on communication, decision-making, and leadership skills before the year really ramps up. — Travis Schreiber, Erase.com