Some of the biggest stories to dominate our attention in 2023 were stories about brand value.
Former President Donald Trump was accused of inflating his brand value by some $4B as part of 91 criminal charges brought against him last year. Another controversial headline-grabber, Elon Musk, is estimated to have erased anywhere between $4B and $20B of brand value from Twitter in 2023 when he renamed it ‘X’ (a moniker he’s applied to both his companies and his offspring).
Then there was the clamor made by generative AI, heralded as a source of massive risk to brands (bias, misinformation, deep fakes, data protection) and a source of transformative potential across the marketing cycle, including mass content personalization.
All of these stories about brand value came amidst the backdrop of a challenging economic environment which saw global mergers and acquisitions (M&A) deal value tumble for most of 2023 as companies grappled with rising inflation and interest rates.
THE TRILLION-DOLLAR BRAND VALUE OPPORTUNITY
As we step into the year ahead, I expect many in the business community will be hoping for some different headlines—stories about the fair administration of justice, thoughtful corporate leadership, responsible management of new technology, and perhaps an economic rebound. Time will tell.
My hope is that amidst the inevitable distractions of the year ahead, business leaders will pay attention to the foundational importance of brand value and the trillion-dollar opportunity that’s there beneath our noses, hiding in plain sight.
Brands are significant financial assets for corporations, estimated to generate about a third of their total market value. While brand valuation is not an exact science, the value of intangible assets like brands has been soaring in recent years and could represent as much as 90% of the total market value of the S&P 500. Let that sink in.
Even if the 2023 global M&A deal volume of $3T remains constant in 2024, that’s more than $1T attributable to brand value in deals. Brand strategy can have a massive effect on a company’s value, and according to the American Marketing Association, the right brand strategy can add more than 23% to the expected post-merger shareholder value of the corporation.
Yet while the gigantic contribution of brand value to a company’s market value is evident, and the importance of a comprehensive brand strategy in the failure-prone world of M&A is well documented, brand is still rarely given the focus and investment it deserves. I believe that’s a huge waste and one we can’t afford to make.
As we look to the year ahead, investors, deal makers and corporate leaders should focus on the creation of brand value through the development of winning core brand strategies, whether divesting brands, acquiring brands or nurturing existing portfolios. They must also be clear-eyed and honest about the institutional challenges and biases that stand in their way.
EQ & CQ: DECODING THE CREATION OF BRAND VALUE
At TRIPTK, the brand transformation consultancy I founded in 2017, we’ve had the privilege of developing core brand strategies behind some significant M&A deals in recent years. For every transformation in which we play a role, brand strategy is paramount to delivering stakeholder and shareholder value.
Frameworks abound for brand development through the M&A cycle, and every management consultancy will be quick to offer its own. From my experience in the field, the most frequently overlooked aspects are human factors and the critical role of cultural intelligence.
Transforming a brand organization requires work at two levels: the internal brand culture (the vision setting, execution processes and inspiration of talent) and the brand in culture (the meaningful brand experiences the brand confers to its audiences). Any team tasked with creating brand value must bring exceptionally high EQ (emotional intelligence) and CQ (cultural intelligence) to both of these areas. When it comes to brand transformation and value creation, all the tech and toolsets without the right skill sets and mindsets will invariably fail.
When partnering with firms like TRIPTK and building internal teams to realize brand value creation, corporate leaders need to select core EQ and CQ competencies that can overcome the barriers within their own businesses:
- To combat ‘data paralysis,’ transformation teams need to be skilled in the synthesis, triangulation and prioritization of both thick (qualitative) and big (quantitative) data. Too often, data volume becomes a substitute for insight and the kinds of transformative story-led strategies that move organizations forward.
- To combat ‘silo syndrome,’ teams need to be adept at consensus building and collaborative program design. Too often, brand value creation fails to activate all aspects of brand (customer, employer, corporate brand) or create buy-in across a wide array of disciplines and departments.
- To combat ‘boardroom bias,’ teams need to be able to frame brand strategy for the entire executive function. This is particularly important when C-suite diversity is still lagging.
- To combat ‘the continuity crutch,’ teams have to be equipped to challenge tightly held assumptions and imagine novel solutions and strategies unencumbered by legacy ways of thinking. This is of vital importance when future market possibilities aren’t an extrapolation of present realities.
2024 will inevitably be a year that tests the business community, but it can also be a year of huge value creation. While GenAI can be a great co-pilot to strategy, it doesn’t possess the EQ and CQ qualities required to create brand value. As Donald and Elon demonstrate, brand value can be challenged or eroded rapidly. Building brand value requires discipline, and it will be the qualities of the humans at the helm that determine success.
Sam Hornsby is the Founder and CEO of global brand transformation consultancy TRIPTK.