When companies need to hire more people to fill ongoing roles or for expansion, offshore hiring can be a viable option. But working with staff in far-off locales doesn’t come without its headaches, such as time zone issues, or risks, such as workflow review and security concerns. It often takes trial and error to figure out when to hire offshore or when to keep the work in-country.
We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members when is the best time to hire offshore staff members and when should you not do it. Below, 23 of those members share their best advice. It just might prevent some headaches and reduce operational risk.
1. IF AI CAN’T DO IT, KEEP A HUMAN CLOSE
I’m skeptical of offshoring in general, especially now. If the work can be done by an offshore knowledge worker, it can probably be done by artificial intelligence. And if AI can’t do it, that’s exactly the work where you need a real human in that region, close to the business. That logic has become more true in the last two years, and I think a lot of companies haven’t updated their thinking on it yet. — Zander Cook, Lease End
2. WHEN OPERATIONAL PROCESSES MEET THREE CRITERIA
Hire offshore when your operational processes are fully documented, repeatable, and asynchronous. If a role has clear standard operating procedures and success metrics, offshore talent extends your execution velocity exponentially. Never offshore when a process is still ambiguous or evolving daily; distance, time zones, and lack of written documentation will turn strategy gaps into a 24-hour feedback delay. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
3. ONCE CLARITY IS ACHIEVED
Offshoring works best once you have well-defined, documented processes, such as scoped development, quality assurance, back-office functions, or support for non-urgent tickets. It’s not primarily about saving money, but about having a structure others can execute smoothly. Risks are highest early on, when you’re still determining product-market fit. At this stage, rapid feedback and shared context matter most, and time zone differences can get in the way. I’d avoid offshoring roles tied to real-time customer coordination or core strategy until leadership systems are solid. Key rule: Offshore once clarity is achieved, not before. — Joe Faruqui, ASAP Semiconductor
4. FOR DEFINED WORKFLOWS WITH REVIEW
Hire offshore when the work is documented, repeatable, and measurable, and when a clear owner can train and review it. It works well for defined research, data, administrative, and production-support workflows. Do not use offshore hiring to avoid fixing a broken process or to replace relationship-critical judgment. If the work depends on constant context, sensitive client communication, or unclear standards, distance will magnify the problem. — Tavares Beverly, Beverly Boy Productions
5. WHEN SYSTEMS SUPPORT WORK ACROSS TIME ZONES
Being 100% remote has taught me that geography is rarely the deciding factor. Hire outside the United States when the person brings the right expertise, the role has clear outcomes, and your systems support strong communication across time zones. Do not do it simply to cut costs or fix a broken process. A global hire should strengthen the team, not create a separate one. — Stephanie Harris, PartnerCentric
6. WHEN PLANNING FOR THE NEXT FISCAL YEAR
It really depends on the role. If the role demands economies of scale, faster knowledge transfer, and repeatable execution, offshore makes perfect sense. To hire offshore, the best time I believe is when you need to plan for the next fiscal year, say in Q4 of the current fiscal year, so that you can reap the benefit of a full year of productivity. You need to provide adequate time to fail fast and provide enablement time, thus in the process filter and hire the right talents early on in the fiscal year. — Arunava Sen, Tata Communications America Inc.
7. IF YOU CAN’T WRITE THE STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE, YOU’RE NOT READY
Hire offshore when the work is repeatable and the standard is already written down. Don’t hire offshore when the role needs taste, client trust, or judgment you haven’t documented. I run an agency out of Ahmedabad, India, serving clients in the United States and United Kingdom, so I watch both sides fail: The engagements that break are the ones where someone outsourced a decision, not a task. If you can’t write the standard operating procedure, you’re not ready to hire for it. Fix the process first. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, Ohh My Brand
8. FOR OPERATIONAL RESILIENCE
The term offshore has been seen as a negative, but global companies need to utilize talent regardless of location. The best time to utilize global teams is when you need operational resilience and scale for highly structured, data-intensive tasks. However, you should never offshore roles that require deep, localized empathy or complex regulatory navigation where the nuances of human interaction are critical. Our artificial intelligence technology bridges this gap by handling the heavy deterministic data processing flawlessly, which frees up our human team to focus entirely on providing empathetic, high-stakes support to our clients. — Pavan Agarwal, Celligence
9. WHEN YOU HIRE FOR ABILITY, NOT LOWEST RATE
Offshore hiring works best when the role is well defined, the expectations are documented, and you are hiring for ability rather than the lowest possible rate. It tends to fail when a company uses geography as a shortcut for cutting costs. If the work requires constant interpretation or the company has not figured out the role internally, moving it offshore usually makes the underlying problem harder to manage. — Christopher Kiggins, SaunaCloud
10. WHEN YOU HAVE CLARITY AROUND THE WORK
Offshore talent can be incredibly valuable when you have clarity around the work, expectations, communication, ownership, and what success looks like. I would not hire offshore simply because it is less expensive or use it to compensate for a process that is already unclear or broken. Wherever someone sits, they deserve the same clarity, respect, communication, support, compassion, and accountability as every other member of the team. — Angie Hughes, Lets Do Good
11. SORT THE WORK BY WHAT IT COSTS TO GET WRONG
Confidentiality decides it for us. We work on things clients have not announced yet, so that work stays with full-time employees. Offshore has a place at the edges. Our copyeditor lived in Austin for years and freelanced for us the whole time. She lives in Berlin now. She is not offshore labor. She is a known quantity in a different time zone. Design and production travel fine too. If a leak would hurt the client, it does not leave the team. The mistake I see is treating this as a cost decision. Distance is not the risk. Distance from context is, and context is most of this job. Sort the work by what it costs to get wrong. — Kathleen Lucente, Red Fan Communications
12. WHEN YOU NEED THEM
Hire offshore staff when you need them. Don’t hire them when you don’t. I know that sounds ridiculously simple, but sometimes we make this stuff way too complicated. I’ve used offshore teams successfully for years. The mistake is thinking “offshore” is a strategy. It isn’t. Hire the best people for the work you need done, wherever they happen to be. If offshore gives you the right skills, resources or economics, go offshore. And don’t offshore chaos. Bad requirements, bad leadership, and broken processes don’t magically get better because the people working on them are 8,000 miles away. — Daragh Mahon, Werner
13. AFTER THE ROLE IS WELL-DEFINED
Offshore hiring works well when you already understand the role, have clear ownership, and have built good communication habits. Geography tends to expose weaknesses in operating systems that were already there. Before hiring offshore, document how decisions are made, what success looks like, and who owns the outcome. If the role is still poorly defined or requires constant informal coordination to function, I’d solve that first. — Deniz Gezgin, Eightpoint
14. WHEN YOU’RE INVESTED IN COMMUNICATION AND BELONGING
From my time managing teams for the World Bank across continents and cultures, I can’t say enough positive things about blending backgrounds for various perspectives. That said, offshore hiring works best when responsibilities are clear, workflows are established, and leaders are prepared to invest in communication and belonging. Geography shouldn’t determine whether someone feels part of the team. The fit tends to be poor when companies are chasing lower costs or expecting remote workers to fix a broken process. If a role requires constant informal collaboration, sensitive judgment or deep cultural context, proximity may matter more. — Ajay Tejasvi, TLEX Institute
15. FOLLOW THE TIME-ZONE RULE
For us it’s less about borders and more about time zones. Our policy is generally “work from anywhere”—home, a co-working space, our Madrid office— as long as it’s somewhere in the same time zone as Madrid or close to it. Most of the team is remote by design, and it works because people still collaborate remotely in real time, and because we’re intentional about being together in person with regular team days plus two full offsites a year. When the time zones are so different that there’s little or no overlap during the workday, it proves a lot more challenging for us. — Cristobal Viedma, Lingokids
16. MANAGEMENT BANDWIDTH BEFORE HEADCOUNT
Hiring offshore works when you have two things in place: First, crystal-clear role expectations and workflow, and second, real management bandwidth. Most teams don’t fail offshore because they don’t understand what to do. They fail because nobody on the core team has the time to see the work happening and course correct. If you or someone on your leadership can’t spend an hour each week reviewing and coaching a person, don’t hire them yet. Get your operations in order then consider your next move. — Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw, First and Last PR
17. HIRE FOR THE ROLE, NOT THE LOCATION
The best time to hire offshore team members is when the work requires it. My staffing decisions are driven by the jobs to be done, the success metrics, and the service levels essential for performance. If a candidate has the knowledge, experience, skills, and temperament to contribute meaningfully, they enter the consideration set—regardless of where they are located. Geography and market familiarity do influence service levels, so they are thoughtfully factored into the hiring decision. — Christopher O.H. Williams, Custament Partners LLC
18. FOR LOWER-RISK TASKS
Privacy concerns, data leaks related to artificial intelligence, and the need to protect proprietary information are making it increasingly important to think carefully about where work happens and who has access to it. There are plenty of lower-risk tasks where borders should not matter, and offshore talent can be a great resource. But when the work involves sensitive information, intellectual property or decisions with meaningful business consequences, I believe you need to keep that work close, either internally or with trusted U.S.-based partners. The decision should not come down to cost. It should consider the level of risk and accountability the work requires. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion
19. FOR REPEATABLE, CLEAR TASKS
Offshore staffing works when the task repeats and the process is clear enough for a manager to review the result. I wouldn’t use it for work that depends on local judgment or relationship repair, or when sensitive context can’t be handed off safely. Offshore staffing adds capacity to a sound process. It doesn’t create one. — Anthony A. Luna, Coastline Equity
20. FOR WELL-DEFINED, SPECIALIZED PRODUCTION WORK
We run our teams across Pakistan, Ireland, the United Arab Emirates, and the United States. Offshore works well for defined, specialized production work: schema markup, technical SEO audits, and content production, where the deliverable is clear and quality is easy to check. It works poorly for fast, unscripted judgment calls close to the client: crisis handling, high-stakes sales conversations, and anything needing full context in real time. I keep those roles local or handle them myself. — Hasan Saleem, DSS MEDIA
21. FOR DATA ENTRY AND NO DIRECT PATIENT CONTACT
Yes, for transcription, coding, billing, scheduling, data entry for research, and anything with clear protocols and no direct patient contact. No, for any role that touches clinical judgment, patient-facing care, or protected health information without airtight compliance. In healthcare, HIPAA and licensing constraints decide this before cost does. — Steven Giannotta, Giannotta Neurosurgery
22. TO ACHIEVE TARGETED PRICING AND FLEXIBILITY GOALS
I’ve worked in both international and domestic environments and across multiple continents and countries. There are opportunities to leverage international staff or contractors outside of the United States to achieve targeted pricing or flexibility on timelines. For example, I’ve leveraged international technology workers for one-time, project-based work that my internal team didn’t have capacity to complete. For ongoing needs, I usually focus on hiring permanent staff so that I can shape workplace culture and more directly control performance. — Erik Clarke, Trans Lease, Inc.
23. FOR EXPANSION
For our needs, the best time to hire offshore has been during times of expansion. — Andrew Kryder, The Kryder Law Group