Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

3 ways to include manager training and coaching in a hiring process

This strategy for coaching and training hiring managers is repeatable, equitable, and friendly to everyone involved.

A man and woman shake hands at work

[images: Alexis Scholtz/peopleimages.com / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Sean Fahey

BY Sean Fahey

Interview coaching is simple to understand and doesn’t need to be difficult to formalize. It starts with creating a framework for how hiring managers should conduct interviews and supporting that structure with digital technology designed to remove biased decision-making. Then, add coaching and training sessions that occur prior to those managers conducting interviews with candidates to create alignment across your hiring teams. The strategy is repeatable, equitable, and friendly to everyone involved. 

THE IMPLICATIONS OF NOT TRAINING AND COACHING HIRING MANAGERS

Companies that ignore or fumble the ball at the hiring process are far more likely to make bad hires. And as many of us have seen, bad hires are one of the most important contributors to new hire turnover rates. Ignoring the interview process is an expensive gamble, and the negative implications of doing so are backed up by multiple studies.

In fact, a Leadership IQ study found that over 80% of hiring managers had suspicions that the new hires would fail. As the study’s authors put it: “And contrary to popular belief, technical skills are not the primary reason why new hires fail; instead, poor interpersonal skills dominate the list, flaws which many of their managers admit were overlooked during the job interview process.”

When hiring managers are not properly coached and trained on a standardized hiring process that includes what to look for in a good candidate, they’re far more likely to ignore the warning signs that a candidate isn’t a good fit for the role. In real terms, this means that in most companies, hiring managers are often seeing the signs during the hiring process but they’re either choosing to ignore them or simply don’t know what to look for at all. 

HOW TO TRAIN AND COACH HIRING MANAGERS IN YOUR HIRING PROCESS

Hiring the right candidates is too costly to ignore, and for most companies, the biggest misstep happens during the interview process. Given that, here are three tips you can implement fairly quickly that will have an immediate impact on your interview process.

1. Create Training Material With Input From Experienced Functional Managers

Your functional managers are your best resource here. They have the insight and experience into your teams to best understand what qualities make a good hire. They’re also going to be far more familiar with the qualities of a bad hire, as well. 

You may also need to break up your hiring manager training and coaching materials into different functions. The type of positive qualities you’re looking for in a sales candidate interview won’t be the same as what you look for when you hire product engineers. 

2. Make Training Material Easily Accessible

There’s no point in making training material if you don’t make it available to your hiring managers. Once you’ve created functional-based materials that will help hiring managers identify the right candidates during the interview process, launch that material in an easily accessible internal storage location, such as a shared drive. 

You may also want to create video guides and walk-throughs so that hiring managers who are going into interviews can also visualize guide material in a way that helps them process that information.

Additionally, consider incorporating that material into reference guides that hiring managers can use while they conduct their interviews. 

3. Build A Structured Interview Process To Ensure Consistent Results

Structure is the key to removing bias and delivering a consistent interview experience for all candidates. It’s also the best way to make sure you get as close as possible to consistent results in your hiring process. 

Creating that structure doesn’t need to be difficult, but it should include a few important design elements, such as:

  • HR-vetted interview questions that focus on candidate competency
  • Rating scales that standardize evaluation (typically using a Likert scale)
  • A consistent flow, where questions are asked in the same order
  • A narrow question focus on skills and competencies

Understandably, too much structure can create a stiff and rigid interview. Every good structured interview also includes space for small talk and answering candidates’ questions.

THE BEST INTERVIEW IS THE ONE YOU’RE PREPARED FOR

People often see the interview as a free-for-all discussion with a randomly interjected list of probing questions. It doesn’t and shouldn’t be that way. Creating thoughtful and HR-vetted questions can reign in the process and ensure a more consistent result. Structured interviews are a direct path forward to create that consistency, especially when the questions are standardized for each interview and the answers are evaluated against a rating guide. Still, adding structure is only one component—your hiring managers must be trained and coached both on what to say and what to take away from the responses they get during the interview.


Sean Fahey is the CEO and Strategic Recruitment Advisor at VidCruiter, the new standard for worldwide online hiring.